Red (USA)
Innocence and Instinct


5.0
classic

Review

by mizzinineman USER (1 Reviews)
September 20th, 2009 | 22 replies


Release Date: 2009 | Tracklist

Review Summary: With Innocence and Instinct, Red have crafted the most important Christian, maybe even secular, album of this decade. Be ready for an experience not delivered by any band left today.

What happened after the New-Metal phase? Did bands think it couldn't be crafted and shaped into a more mature sounding piece of art? Red believes that it can delivering their second studio album which boasts everything we who loved our Linkin Park came to love. It was a sad day the hour 'Minutes To Midnight' was released simply because it marked the end of an era, what was pretty much the creator of their genre we watched a titan fall. There was nobody to grab the realms and direct those who were still left aching for a solid release by a band who knew how to harken that animostic sound. 'innocence and Instinct' is just what the radio needs to rebirth that of the New-Metal phase.

The album starts with "Fight Inside" pretty goo song to start it all off things off with. Rambunctious intro of all the instruments clashing together it almost sounds like it'll bridge into metalcore, which shows the range this band is willing extend for. Barnes' voice is like that sent from heaven just the right amount of melodic with heavy angry shouts to back up all the forceful parts. Barnes' is a true sucessor to Bennington as he weilds the band around his voice. - 5/5

"Death of Me" comes a rockin in with its cool tech-y vocal effects and psychedlic groove riff kinda. Everyone is on their game here especially drummer Hayden Lamb who isn't even a credited member of the band but still produces good things. You can tell by some of the style changes the band is clearly a group of geniuses. - 4.5/5

The first slow-y song of the album "Mystery of you" has still got its fare share of heaviness. Its got cool scratch things going in the background its a pretty cool song so far the weakest to be heard, but that's kind a of an understatement since its amazing still still it is kinda boring after like 2 or 3 listens. - 3/5

"Start Again" is just a beautiful song. - 3.5/5

My second favorite song on this album is "Never Be the Same" because of its perfect verses of nice acoustic guitars and a piano that can just barely be heard. It's definitely better than the last song. And it. It starts the climb to the better half of the album. - 5/5

This song it brutal and shows the metal side of Red. "Confessions" is just like Transformers 2 its pure action and its what we all want. It doesn't start once it stops. My favorite part of this song is the screamed outro which shows that Barnes' might even be a better singer than Chester. Who woulda thunk it? - 5/5

"Shadows" sounds like a song Chevelle would do but here's the catcher it sounds better. Its heavy and then its not and then it is, and its just so crazy the way it switches up the tempo and beats. The drumming is again phenomenal but what really does it here are the guitars. The chorus is perfect its sings about everything that people go through, "There's a hate inside of me like some kind of master I tried to save you but I can't find the answer I'm holding onto you I'll never let go I need you with me as I enter the Shadows." And there's some cool "Ahhhs" in the background. - 4.5/5

"Ordinary World" is a Duran Duran cover I think, anyway I wish they wouldn't have done a cover because it took them forever to make this album and then they don't even release their own material wtf is that about? Anyway sorry about that short rant, its ok I heard its better than the original so that's great but I just can't get over how its not their own song, so it gets a bad rating. - 1/5

"Out From Under" thankfully delivers after the horrible slip up of a song that wasn't even theirs and is aggressive and heavy but doesn't over do it kinda like "Faint" ya know? Barnes is screaming almost death growls and its really scary the first time you'll hear it but after listening to it like 4 or 5 times you'll adjust I did at least. - 4.5/5

A beautiful way to close out the most important album of the decade is with the most original acoustic performance I've ever heard. There's like death whispers which would be the equivalent of death growls I guess. It's so good because it really showcases the power in Barnes' voice. He hits some pretty impressive highs and eerie sounding lows. Really good way to close out the album. - 4/5

So there you have it the reason why this is probably the most important album of the decade is because its been released by a band who isn't afraid to spread a message. They are able to recapture all that New-Metal fire and final deliver something worth listening to. It's a very beautiful progression by a band that already sounded solid. They know how to incorporate all of their influences sounding poppy sometimes and then down right metal the next you never hear this kind of stuff in music anymore and its why RED have released an album to be heard by everyone.


user ratings (670)
3.8
excellent
other reviews of this album
1 of


Comments:Add a Comment 
mizzinineman
September 19th 2009


12 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

please go easy on me my first time trying to review music. i'm gonna try to review an opeth or tool album next but i can't decide, but i just love this album alot.

pizzamachine
September 19th 2009


27166 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

Did someone say fanboy?

mizzinineman
September 19th 2009


12 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

i guess i do kinda like em. lol

does anybody know why my review isn't on the front page, do i need to pass some sort of test? jk

ninjuice
September 19th 2009


6760 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0 | Sound Off

Several things:

-You're gonna get LOTS of crap for this review. Put on a fire suit.



-It's spelled "nu-metal", but I don't necessarily blame you for having proper English. If you're gonna review though, try to learn genre names.



-Linkin Park didn't kill, create or popularize nu metal by themselves.



-Look up "hyperbolic" in the dictionary.



-There's a lot of spelling and grammar mistakes that Word or the (Free Office?) equivalent would probably catch.



-Track by tracks aren't popular here. Reviewing the album as a whole - its core sound, strengths or weaknesses of the band members, whether or not it flows well / is generic / has good lyrics, etc is more interesting.



-When you do a track-by-track, don't just skip out on a description like you did with Start Again.



-Reviewing albums which have plenty of reviews all ready - i.e. most any Tool or Opeth album - is frowned upon as well.



-The moderators have to approve first reviews. I'm assuming it's to stop spam.



-Stick around. You'll find plenty of awesome music if you do.

Romulus
September 20th 2009


9109 Comments


I hate when people neg first-time reviewers. What ninjuice said.

KYZAR
September 20th 2009


513 Comments


is it, is it really THAT great? Because come on "Red have crafted the most important Christian, maybe even secular, album of this decade" Thats a ridiculously bold statement, i wouldn't even give that (- the christian thing) to Cynic's "Traced in Air" and i doubt that this is better than that.

But yes stick around, maby you will see there's more to metal than this.

Observer
Emeritus
September 20th 2009


9393 Comments


I do love this album, but its not a technical marvel by any means.

Barnes has a great voice.

endlessartix
September 20th 2009


275 Comments


I love "Death of Me," I might get this soon. This might be the most important Christian album this year, definetly not of the decade, Christian or otherwise.

Observer
Emeritus
September 20th 2009


9393 Comments


Agreed. "Shadows" is really a great song as well. Get the deluxe edition as the bonus tracks are quite good.

Emim
September 20th 2009


35267 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

As per ninjuice's post, LOTS of CRAP. That being said, this is your first review and thus slack will be cut. Follow what he listed, and you should do alright.



Oh, and "death growls"? Really? You plan on reviewing Opeth, and call it "death growls"?

/rant

Captain Civic
September 21st 2009


441 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Wow. I haven't read the review, but your summary is way over the top. I like these guys too, but they're in no way revolutionary.

Captain North
September 21st 2009


6793 Comments


Also, if you do do a track by track review, make sure the ratings match up. There are far too many 3's and a 1 to result in a 5/5 album.

Asiatic667
September 21st 2009


4651 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

what was pretty much the creator of their genre we watched a titan fall




Linkin Park didn't invent nu-metal - Korn and Slipknot had more to do with it than they did

Willie
Moderator
September 21st 2009


20212 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

There is so much wrong with this review. From the overblown/totally wrong statements, to simpler things such as basic grammar.

ScorpionStan
September 21st 2009


1911 Comments


With Innocence and Instinct, Red have crafted the most important Christian, maybe even secular, album of this decade. Be ready for an experience not delivered by any band left today.


hmmm i kinda feel sorry for you.

fr33convict
April 19th 2010


11723 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5 | Sound Off

With Innocence and Instinct, Red have crafted one of the most important Christian, although probably not secular, album of this year. Be ready for an awesome album that kicks ass.



Slightly less overblown. I'm a Red fanboy and that review embarassed me.

Emim
April 19th 2010


35267 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

^thank you for reminding me what a terrible review this is.

fr33convict
April 19th 2010


11723 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5 | Sound Off

your welcome, i love reopening old wounds in a painful manner.

tiesthatbind
April 19th 2010


7441 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

This really is terrible... "New-Metal"?

metalheadrunner
January 20th 2015


343 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

I'm not gonna neg or pos, but this could use some work. Like everybody said, do try less of a track-by-track, and vary up the descriptions a little. Also, Red's one of my favorites, as is this record, but it's rated a little too high. Awesome record, but it's more of a 4, a 4.5 at the highest. But not a terrible review in the least bit.



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2023 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy