Alestorm
Black Sails at Midnight


3.0
good

Review

by Simon Harris (SCREAM!) USER (56 Reviews)
July 3rd, 2009 | 15 replies


Release Date: 2009 | Tracklist

Review Summary: Alestorm release what could be their last relevant album

Those who read my review for the Leviathan EP might remember me ending the review with a warning directed towards the band. Now I know you are all too lazy to go check it yourselves so here it is:

"Although the listener should beware. If the band plans on releasing another album like this it could make for a very tedious experience due to the lack of new ideas. The band can’t expect the same stunts to stay fun forever."

Now seeing as how the new album features the title track from the EP and the cover of Wolves of the Sea, things were not looking good for Alestorm’s newest outing, Black Sails At Midnight.

After going through the album once I could see spots where the bands had tried to follow criticism received about their debut, but overall, their sound has stayed the same. It definitely still makes for an interesting and fun listen but not as much as their first album did which is sad because the songs on this one are just as well written, if not better, than on the first. But their sound is slowly starting to age like the rum they so often sing about.
Now if you have heard their debut or their Leviathan EP, you will already be familiar with the band’s general sound. Driving guitar riffs are accompanied by accordion-like keyboard melodies to create the “piratey” atmosphere. With these the band create many catchy and fun melodies and choruses that still have the power to stay stuck in your head for hours. The riffs are essentially power chords. The band only seems to have tried to obey the criticism about the simplicity of the guitar riffs in the title track which features a thrashy sounding main riff and short melodic guitar breaks during the chorus. This works very well with their pirate sound and finally shows the listener that the guitarists don’t need the keyboards as a crutch…they just choose to have it that way. But the guitars really shine during the solos where they deliver fast, technical, scale-based solos that they manage to make fit right into the song.

Not much needs to be said about the rest of the album. The singer continues to deliver lyrics that revolve essentially around drinking rum, getting wenches and battling across the high seas. He delivers them in his drunken pirate style of singing that is a perfect match with the music and themes of the album. Nothing needs to be said about the bass since it cannot be heard and the drums continue to provide very solid beats while throwing in many interesting fills every now and then.

So overall, Black Sails At Midnight is another fun album by the now famous (or infamous) Alestorm. But the album suffers from sounding like everything else the band has released. Their sound is starting to lose its novelty and fast. They just manage to get away with it on this album but they will need to put more effort in song writing and especially the guitar riffs if they hope to stay relevant in today’s metal and not disappear like the pirates (Somalian pirates don’t count).

Yours truly,
SCREAM!



Recent reviews by this author
Agalloch The Serpent and the SphereForteresse / Chasse-Galerie / Monarque / Csejthe Légendes
Fuck the Facts AmerManeige Les Porches
Dark Castle Spirited MigrationSunn O))) ØØ Void
user ratings (178)
Chart.
3.2
good
other reviews of this album
Tom Chatt (3)
More of the same yes, but a fairly enjoyable more of the same....

Tristan (4)
Ten swashbuckling pirate tunes; Alestorm proves themselves as more than just a cheap fad....

Matthijs van der Lee (1)
AAAAARRRRRRRRRRRRRRRe these guys serious?...

Greg Wood (3.5)
Alestorm show that there’s more to this pirate lark than just wenches, treasure and ale....


Comments:Add a Comment 
SCREAM!
July 3rd 2009


10212 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

Ew... quote does horors to formatting

BallsToTheWall
July 3rd 2009


44630 Comments


One sentence in and you're already implying us to read one of your past reviews. (Sigh) I dont know SCREAM!, iI just dont know. Short but effiecent review anywho.

Digging: Mare Cognitum - Phobos Monolith

SCREAM!
July 3rd 2009


10212 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

I put the quote in there so you wouldnt have to go read it silly

BallsToTheWall
July 3rd 2009


44630 Comments


There's about a page of space so I guess I kind of missed that. I think this will be a cool and entertaining album while trying to brew mead.

Greggers
July 3rd 2009


2375 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

I understand where you're coming from mate, I guess I'm too much of a pirate NOT to love this though.

south_of_heaven 11
July 3rd 2009


5436 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

Review really barely talks about the album at all...or even mentions any songs really.

So ya not a good review bud.

rasputin
July 4th 2009


14550 Comments


Put the quote in quotation marks so it doesn't ruin the format. Don't use bold for album titles, use italics. Please please please stop signing your username at the end of your reviews. Oh and stop giving positive ratings for Alestorm, they deserve none of them.

SCREAM!
July 4th 2009


10212 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

Should i put the song title in bold instead? cause had those in italics right now.

And the username stays :P

.........so does the rating

Zip
July 4th 2009


5312 Comments


Ew a 3? I hate this band.

Metalstyles
Staff Reviewer
July 4th 2009


8371 Comments

Album Rating: 2.5

yay a 3.5, this is fun!

TricksterGRex
July 4th 2009


2087 Comments


Band deserves nothing higher than a 1.

Zip
July 4th 2009


5312 Comments


^

Metalstyles
Staff Reviewer
July 4th 2009


8371 Comments

Album Rating: 2.5

hey Zipper, where u been anyway, you were strangely gone exactly a week, you got banned?

gaslightanthem
July 4th 2009


5209 Comments


alestorm moar liek failstorm lol

Zip
July 5th 2009


5312 Comments


No I was not banned, vacation.



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





FAQ // STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2014 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Privacy Policy