The Strokes
Is This It


4.5
superb

Review

by SuperDuck USER (1 Reviews)
June 25th, 2009 | 12 replies


Release Date: 2001 | Tracklist

Review Summary: The best album of the post-punk revival.

So with news surfacing of a Strokes comeback and new album, I feel it necessary to give a review of the album that put them in the public eye in the first place. While I only recently discovered this album, i'm going to give a few details about it's history, for those who are in the same position I was. This was released in 2001 to almost universal acclaim, and generated a fairly large hype bubble which this album, at least, lived up to. Their next two efforts, while good in their own right, weren't nearly as consistent as this, nor did they show much expansion on the bands songwriting formula (although, they both still contained a few gems to equal the gems on this record, I would still reccomend getting them if you don't mind skipping the occasional average track). But anyway, this was the album that basically set the wheels in motion for the post-punk revival scene, still pretty prominent to this day, although The Strokes themselves have somewhat faded away, as they went on indefinite hiatus in 2006. They are working on a comeback album as we speak, and if they do something like this again (although that would be a difficult feat indeed), they could perhaps achieve the status they initially seemed destined to acquire.

Anyways, the record as a whole is a confident, memorable effort. It contains both blazing indie anthems, such as the instantly recognisable and memorable "Last Nite", catchy yet expertly crafted songs such as "Someday", and "Hard to Explain", and atmospheric songs such as "Trying your Luck". The music in general follows formula, but they rarely repeat their ideas and and as a result, even though the band can be easily labelled "indie rock" with no real differentiating characteristics, they still have enough variety and identity to keep things interesting throughout. The guitar riffs are simple, yet memorable and well crafted. There are a few interesting solos, but for the most part the band's main focus is to make interesting, memorable songs, rather than comitting to flashy musicianship, while still retaining the instrumental parts and licks. This pays off on virtually every track, as you are never left thinking "yeah, that was good, but a little more ____" would have been nice.

Perhaps the most recognisable (if subtle) element to the bands sound is Julian Casablancas' vocal style. On most tracks, he keeps things fairly low range and quiet, yet still manages to get his melodies stuck in your head. It sounds so effortless, and fits with the music perfectly. His lyrics, while hardly profound, are extremely well written. The topic of choice throughout is his social and sex life (which may be why this album rang so heavily with the public - rather than focusing on something abrasive, The Strokes just wrote about ***ing girls, failed relationships and nights outs). This means that for most people the album isn't going to exactly hit any emotional buttons lyrically (we all love clubs and nights out, but if it's your main interest in life, you should probably get some new hobbies), but this album definitely beats out just about any i've heard for feel-good anthems and catchyness. It's almost too memorable, the songs becoming ingrained on your subconcious after repeated listens.

So what is it that seperates this from the albums of all the other post-punk revival bands playing the same style? Well, for one, this album is the main reason there is even interest in those bands and probably a blueprint for their initial sounds. While those bands no longer need to rely on The Strokes popularity to keep interest in them, they are certainly only getting recognition because Is This It brough the style into fashion. Secondly, the melodies here are quite simply (and I know I keep mentioning this) much much catchier and better written than anything else you'll hear of the genre. It sounds effortlessly so, but it's clear that they spent a lot of time working on the arrangements to make everything fit together so potently. Thirdly, the production on this captures the bands sound perfectly - the band clearly realised this and decided to almost replicate it for their next effort, "Room on Fire" (Hear Reptilia before this if you want to check the band out, by the way - it's not on Is This It but it's definitely my vote for the band's best song). And lastly, the band simply knew exactly who they were and what they were doing. I simply haven't many records with more pure identity than Is This It.

With musical styles, you'll find that the innovators are almost always also the best bands of the bunch. And while no, The Strokes weren't the first band to play their style, they certainly were the first band to play it in the modern age (no pun intended, however that is a great song). Thinking of getting into indie rock? (indie rock as the NME would call it, or as you would think when you think of.. Well, a band like The Strokes). Look no further than this album. It's a modern day classic (obviously it's not quite perfect, but it's still definitely influential and potent enough to be called a classic). Almost anyone could enjoy this, and if you don't, you needn't look any further into the genre. Because this is the best album of the post-punk revival, and one of the best of the decade.


user ratings (2010)
Chart.
4.2
excellent
other reviews of this album
1 of

Comments:Add a Comment 
SeaAnemone
June 25th 2009


20559 Comments


Someday and Hard to Explain are two of The Strokes' best... good review, I wouldn't go as far to call this a "modern day classic" though, especially considering that The Strokes have done better since this.

Digging: Dirty Beaches - Stateless

shindip
June 25th 2009


3536 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

Good review. this is my fave strokes album

SuperDuck
June 26th 2009


327 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

hey, i'd still call it a modern day classic, since it started off a scene and has no sub-par songs and some really awesome ones.

Electric City
Staff Reviewer
June 26th 2009


15743 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

I don't like this as much as I did when I wrote my review. I don't think I've even listened to it more than twice since I wrote the review tbh. First Impressions is their best.

Digging: Flying Lotus - You're Dead!

BludgeonySteve
June 26th 2009


558 Comments

Album Rating: 2.0

Pretty average review, and the rambling within parentheses was kind of annoying. But seeing as this is your first review, well done. You've persuaded me to listen to this.

AggravatedYeti
June 26th 2009


7685 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

Pretty good review, needs to be proof read again, but it's not a bad start.
Album is boss.

SuperDuck
June 26th 2009


327 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

Parentheses are my trademark (it's not like I need them, I just think it looks suave as hell).

STOP SHOUTING!
June 26th 2009


631 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

Think you overrate this a little, because they were never that groundbreaking, they were more of a re-tread, a bit like The Killers.
I liked some of the stuff like Last Night, but it wore out pretty quickly.

CelestialDust
June 26th 2009


3155 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

whole album sounds the same to me

BludgeonySteve
June 27th 2009


558 Comments

Album Rating: 2.0

Me too. This review made me want to listen to it. And I did. And I didn't really like it. Last Night is a good song though.

DiceMan
February 2nd 2010


7068 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

Yeah, this is an epic album.

Ire
February 2nd 2010


41803 Comments


I only have their last album, i love it... i guess i should put this on my list.



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





FAQ // STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2014 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Privacy Policy