Dream Theater
Black Clouds & Silver Linings


4.0
excellent

Review

by Trey Spencer STAFF
June 19th, 2009 | 1119 replies


Release Date: 2009 | Tracklist

Review Summary: Dream Theater expand their metal influences and deliver a collection of actual songs in the process.

Dream Theater have gained a reputation within the metal community as the kings of musical masturbation. Whenever a negative comment is made about the band it generally includes the fact that they can’t write actual songs and only seem capable of jerking off their instruments and blatantly emulating their influences. Of course, fans know that these accusations are false but even they’d have to admit that actual songwriting doesn’t seem to be as big of a priority as it used to be. There was a time when the band put musical composition first and integrated their need for extended instrumentals into that structure. This formula worked well and resulted in two of the band’s most highly regarded albums - Images & Words and Awake. It wasn’t really until Jordan Rudess joined that the focus seemed to change from songwriting to extended jams. This wasn’t necessarily a bad thing since it did result in Scenes from a Memory, but the lack of actual songwriting has still been missed. With the release of Black Clouds and Silver Linings it won’t have to be missed anymore.

Black Clouds sees the band moving back towards songs that are as much complete compositions as they are progressive and technical. A large reason for this is due to the band’s continued push into metal territory. John Petrucci has become much more proficient at writing heavy, memorable riffs that are capable of providing a solid foundation. These riffs dominate most of the songs and help create a sense of consistency that allows the band to go through their various movements while still maintaining an underlying uniform sound. The strength of these riffs as both an outlet for the band’s metal influences as well as a tool to provide stability within constantly changing songs is reinforced by the playing of Mike Portnoy. Mike’s willingness to deliver enough simplified patterns and standard double bass fills is the final element required to completely establish the riffs as a solid, static element in which the songs can remain anchored to despite any number of transitions.

It turns out, though, that Mike isn’t the only one willing to exercise a little bit of restraint when a song calls for it. Dream Theater’s two biggest showoffs have always been Jordan Rudess and John Petrucci, but even they’ve toned it down a little bit. Both of them contribute a large number of melodies and solos that actually fit the songs and don’t just jolt them in totally new directions. This self-control is displayed on every song, but it’s mainly on the more expansive closing songs where it really shines through. In the past, the band’s longer tracks generally suffered from underdeveloped melodies and an overabundance of random soloing turning them into chores to finish. This time John and Jordan provide enough simple, solid melodies that the songs don’t suffer when they inevitably move into something more self-indulgent, and make no mistake, the self-indulgent sections are still present - they’re just fewer.

Another element that is still present is the vocals of James Labrie. In the past, he seemed to occasionally struggle with heavier parts of songs but he seems to finally be comfortable with his voice. He is now just as capable of belting out the metal parts in his Mustaine-inspired rasp as he is the singing that he was originally hired to do over 17 years ago. Mike Portnoy has also continued his effort to provide deeper, harsher vocals to accentuate the heavier sections of each song. As on past albums, his vocals border on cheeseball self-parody and just barely miss ruining the parts he chooses to contribute to. The near-growls that he provides in a few sections aren’t bad, but he either needs to start delivering whole-heartedly or give up because this restrained, spoken word delivery that he does isn’t very good.

What is good is that Dream Theater have finally started exercising their song writing skills again. This makes for an album that is able to deliver great songs that also display the musical showmanship that fans expect. The result is the kind of solid album that the band hasn’t written since Scenes from a Memory combined with songwriting skills that haven’t been this consistent since Awake. Basically, Black Clouds & Silver Linings is an album that continues the band’s increased use of metal riffs combined with extended musical interludes but also brings in strong compositional skills that give the songs the kind of consistency they require in order to be truly memorable and engaging.



Recent reviews by this author
Sick of It All The Last Act of DefianceMeshuggah I (Special Edition)
Cannibal Corpse A Skeletal DomainRabbit Junk Pop That Pretty Thirty
Anathema Distant SatellitesFlotsam and Jetsam No Place for Disgrace - 2014
user ratings (1527)
Chart.
3.7
great
other reviews of this album
1 of
  • Kenneth E. Rathburn (4)
    Dream Theater begin to rectify their compulsive habits....

    lak89 (4)
    Dream Theater have struck a musical balance between their metal and progressive side....

    Blake Reno (4)
    Dream Theater remembers how to write coherent music and creates their best album in a good...

    Austin (4)
    Finally combining their recent metal sound with songwriting as excellent as their 90's eff...

  • Aziz STAFF (4)
    Dream Theater have meticulously crafted an album that is a huge step in the right directio...

    Jorn van Schaïk (4)
    Dream Theater finally rediscover their knack for songwriting, and deliver their best album...

    Motiv3 (4.5)
    For those expecting another disappointment like the last two albums, you may be pleasantly...


Comments:Add a Comment 
Willie
Moderator
June 19th 2009


16051 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

I've seen three other DT reviews posted and they were all track-by-tracks, so I took a different approach with my review and don't really discuss any specific songs.

Shrapnel94
June 19th 2009


2213 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0 | Sound Off

Good job, good review, great album.

KYZAR
June 19th 2009


513 Comments


not a big DT fan but i may get this, it looks good.

Altmer
June 19th 2009


5652 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0 | Sound Off

I agree on most of this.

Wizard
June 19th 2009


19522 Comments


This formula worked well and resulted in two of the band’s most highly regarded albums - Images & Words and Awake.

Two of their worst albums tbqh.

What is good is that Dream Theater have finally started exercising their song writing skills again.

I guess I'm a fan of their older wanky stuff because when I listen to their more song oriented approach, I fall asleep. They sound kind of fake in a way when they aren't wanking.

Review was excellent.


Digging: Godflesh - A World Lit Only By Fire

Phantom
June 19th 2009


8930 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

This is good, but I decided I don't really need the 3 disc version. It's not that good.

Great review.

shindip
June 19th 2009


3536 Comments

Album Rating: 2.5

Great review, but i disagree with the rating.

MassiveAttack
June 19th 2009


2688 Comments


Nice review Trey

SmurkinGherkin
June 19th 2009


1769 Comments


yea, awsome review. May look into this.

Willie
Moderator
June 19th 2009


16051 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Two of their worst albums tbqh.
Two of their worst? Really? Damn, I don't think I've ever heard that from a DT fan before.
This is good, but I decided I don't really need the 3 disc version. It's not that good.
The cover songs aren't bad although they're not required listening. The instrumental versions will be cool to have, though.

HenchmanOfSanta
June 19th 2009


1882 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Is there a stream of this somewhere or did it already come out somewhere else?

Digging: Godflesh - A World Lit Only By Fire

Willie
Moderator
June 19th 2009


16051 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

It came out as promotional material ;)

jabberwockyGC
June 19th 2009


116 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

Great review, but I agree that their older wankier stuff was better. More than usual, their lyrics especially get to me on this album, some of them are so lame. But alot of the music is still pretty good, especially Count of Tuscany. Even an average DT album is a good album, IMO.

Jim
June 19th 2009


5110 Comments

Album Rating: 2.0 | Sound Off

great review

i find this really bland and unimaginative, and even more overblown than octavarium

Willie
Moderator
June 19th 2009


16051 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Thanks for the change. I had it like that originally and the damn paperclip told me it was wrong... needless to say, this is the last time I believe a talking paperclip.

lauriej
June 19th 2009


1712 Comments


whaaat, you still have the paperclip enabled?!?

Poet
June 19th 2009


5935 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

This is better than I originally expected, but it's nothing amazing.

Phantom
June 19th 2009


8930 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

whaaat, you still have the paperclip enabled?!?


Haha, pretty much what I thought when I saw the comment.

Flyboy
June 19th 2009


395 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

I pre-ordered the album a few days ago. I got the three disc version. This album seems promising but I love DT so I pretty sure i'll dig this. Good review by the way.

This formula worked well and resulted in two of the band’s most highly regarded albums - Images & Words and Awake.

Two of their worst albums tbqh.


Awake is my favorite album by them. How the fuck do you figure those are their worst?

Willie
Moderator
June 19th 2009


16051 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Hey, it's a work computer. I have a Mac at home with iWork. No paperclips, no crashes, no problems.



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





FAQ // STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2014 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Privacy Policy