maudlin of the Well
Part the Second


4.5
superb

Review

by Keelan H. EMERITUS
May 15th, 2009 | 100 replies


Release Date: 2009 | Tracklist

Review Summary: maudlin of the Well v. 2.0

The newly released maudlin of the Well album (or mini-album) Part the Second, could be considered a covers album. This is a collection of songs interpreted by lead man Toby Driver in a different paradigm then at the time he began writing the songs. This is the Toby Driver of today covering the Toby Driver of yesteryear. The main problem with an album of covers is that no matter how well a band or artist interprets another work, there is the inherent glass ceiling. There will always be the comparison to the original piece holding the work back from greater things. What separates Part the Second from this problem, and ultimately makes it an entirely different entity, is that this material is being recorded for the first time. What is presented creates an intriguing examination of the personal and musical growth of the main man, Toby Driver. To simply compare this to the works of the former maudlin of the Well (motW) is like digging into a mine until you find silver and then stopping. A few feet further and you would have discovered gold.

Perhaps the symbol of Driver’s musical growth is the inclusion of violinist Mia Matsumiya in a prominent role on Part the Second. While strings were not a completely foreign instrument to motW in the past, they were used sparingly and mostly as a texture. Album opener, “An Excerpt From 6,000,000,000,000 Miles Before the First, or, The Revisitation of the Blue Ghost”, begins with a light interplay between guitars, keys, bass and drums before the violin slowly rises out of the mix. It rises into a soaring melody before the song shifts into its main theme. Similarly, the boundlessly beautiful, neo-classical opening of “Rose Quartz Turning to Glass” follows the piano and violin as they interplay between major and minor chords. The passage is reminiscent of Romantic era concertos, that is until the tribal percussions come in giving the song a decidedly mystic flair. After a heartbreaking violin solo, the song moves into a more tradition motW territory with a study in the contrast between the beautiful and the ugly.

Despite Drivers new perspective on music, he never loses sight of the fact that this stuff was written to be a part of the motW canon. Most of the old characteristics of the band are intrinsically placed within the compositions. The sudden, seemingly radical changes in dynamic, such as the sudden cut out and shift into percussive and tense territory after the shredding guitar solo in “Keep Light Near You, Even When Dying”, are still there. True to form, these shifts at first seem inorganic and forced but become more natural with repeated listens. Oh yes, those guitar solos are still there too. The ones that lifted past songs such as “Girl With a Watering Can” into a completely different place. Whereas the more experimental Toby Driver either used snippets (ie. “Wayfarer”, or “__On Limpid Form”) or ditched the blazing guitar solos altogether, Part the Second tempers them into something less flashy and more necessary in terms of composition. Interspersing the solos within passages of neo-classical experimentation gives the songs an interesting sense of balance. It works in the same way as that contrast between beauty and ugliness.

As previously mentioned, motW were very good at mixing styles that ultimately portrayed a struggle between the light and the dark; the beautiful and the ugly. However whereas the former motW relied mainly on extreme metal to signify the ugly and dark, the more mature Driver has become more diverse. While short bursts of metal passages make appearances, especially on the double-kick frenzy at the end of closer “Laboratories of the Invisible World”, a lot more emphasis is placed on what is played, instead of how loud or distorted it is played. The build up in the middle of “Clover Garland Island” never explodes into a distorted fury, rather it uses chord progression to signify something darker. The vocals work in similar fashion to aid in this more nuanced approach to light and dark. As with the last Kayo Dot record, Driver is done with the growls and the screams. To portray ugliness, Driver instead uses vocal experimentation, such as the murky yelping in the middle section of “Rose Quartz Turning to Glass” or the Gregorian chants that sprawl out in “An Excerpt From....”.

While it is all too easy to describe Part the Second as simply a mixture of old maudlin of the Well and Kayo Dot, this summarization would be missing the bigger picture. This is a refinement of an older sound, adding and subtracting from the equation to ultimately achieve a similar, but slightly different goal. Whereas the Toby Driver of old wanted to make really excellent progressive metal, the Toby Driver of new seems more interested in simply making really excellent progressive music. Not to discredit the Bath era maudlin of the Well for the great music they produced, this is just something different. It is like writing a short story at the age of twenty, brimming with talent and invincibility. Then you return to that same story at the age of sixty, with a life of learning and experience behind you. Now you flesh that short story out into a novel, with deeper characters and a more studied plot. From the neo-classical violin and piano passages to the downright funky bass groove on “Clover Garland Island”, Part the Second presents a new take on something already great as it was, and expanding on it. Sitting here, listening to the last piano lines flicker into the distance, it sinks it. Who cares if this is the best Toby Driver material ever released? This is just pure, fantastic music. Bon appetite.



Recent reviews by this author
Sufjan Stevens Silver & GoldAndrew Bird Break It Yourself
Florence and the Machine CeremonialsBlitzen Trapper American Goldwing
The Muppets The Green AlbumThe Horrors Skying
user ratings (530)
Chart.
4.1
excellent
other reviews of this album
Kevin Goldfinger (5)
An astounding showcase of skill from Toby Driver's project, maudlin of the Well. Part the Second is...

mcg182 (2)
While the music on the album is slightly above average, Part the Second featuring a surprisingly laz...

NLY (4.5)
Toby Driver returns to maudlin of the Well in the manner of a newly rich kid who's so exuberant with...

Nick Greer EMERITUS (4)
A trip down memory lane for Maudlin of the Well devotees laced with some compelling new renderings f...


Comments:Add a Comment 
thebhoy
Emeritus
May 15th 2009


4461 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

this has usurped Andrew Bird's Noble Beast as my favourite thus far in 2009. Oh nose! No album art? I will try to fix this.

Electric City
Staff Reviewer
May 15th 2009


15743 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

album's great, kind of like what Blue Lambency could have been if they played more songs. I like it.

Review's pretty good too

iarescientists
May 15th 2009


5863 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

it's sort of what blue lambency could have been if it was called Part the Second and released by maudlin of the Well

BallsToTheWall
May 15th 2009


44805 Comments


A-D-D S-O-M-E A-R-T-W-O-R-K B-E-C-A-U-S-E I-T I-S -F-U-C-K-I-N-G I-R-R-I-T-A-T-I-N-G W-I-T-H A C-A-P-I-T-A-L F.

Lucid
Contributing Reviewer
May 15th 2009


7025 Comments


Opener is one of the best songs of the year

jingledeath
May 15th 2009


7104 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

Listened to this once, it was pretty alright, probably will grow on me with more listens. In the mean time I shall go acquire Bath

marksellsuswallets
May 15th 2009


4848 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Second half of Rose Quartz makes me feel strange...

thebhoy
Emeritus
May 15th 2009


4461 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

I could write about this 3 weeks from now, and then my view can change another 3 weeks after that, perspectives change all the time. This is mine now, I've digested the music, formulated my thoughts on it in a larger context and wrote it down. I don't see a problem with this. Sure I could come back in a few months and think, man was I wrong, but so what? I'm pretty sure 90% of the critics who wrote off Talk Talk's Laughing Stock wish they could go back and change that. If you read the review and then had a problem with what I said, that's fine.

Iluvatar
Staff Reviewer
May 15th 2009


16089 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5 | Sound Off

Well the point is that an immediate reaction is much more apt to change than an opinion you've let had time to develop. Really, the only reason to post a review within a day is because you just HAVE to be that first review, which I mean if thats your goal good for you, but I am sure a lot of people who read this in the coming days wont take it as seriously if you had let it sink in more.

rotterdog
May 15th 2009


489 Comments


Typo on the third to last sentence. Sitting "here" listening to... It's a good review, but I'd probably make some of those paragraphs a little shorter.

thebhoy
Emeritus
May 15th 2009


4461 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

fair enough Iluvatar, my goal wasn't just to be first. I just have a day off work so I wanted to review something, and this is the album that I had been listening to the most and had the most thoughts on. Plus I generally use this site as an exercise to practice my writing, so if I came across as a bit apprehensive towards your original statement I'm sorry. I'd just rather hear something about my actual writing and if there is anything I need to improve on.

Typo fixed rotterdog.
This Message Edited On 05.15.09

LiquidVelvet
May 15th 2009


628 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

I think this was a really well-written review.
I personally have listened to this three times, and I can most definitely say that there is no way my opinion will change. This is a pretty solid masterpiece.

Shrapnel94
May 15th 2009


2213 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

I totally just got their FLAC download they put up =D

joshuatree
Emeritus
May 15th 2009


3742 Comments


album's good

Photon
May 15th 2009


1292 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

track 5!!!!

HenchmanOfSanta
May 15th 2009


1926 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

The opening sentence is as pretentious as this album.

And that's awesome.

Lucid
Contributing Reviewer
May 15th 2009


7025 Comments


Bath > Choirs Of The Eye > Part The Second > Leaving Your Body Map >>>>> other Kayo Dot

Yazz_Flute
May 15th 2009


18875 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

Bath > Choirs Of The Eye > Part The Second > Leaving Your Body Map >>>>> other Kayo Dot


yup, except I'd put My Fruit Psychobells about tied with LYBM.

Digging: DIR EN GREY - Arche

rasputin
May 15th 2009


14555 Comments


leaving your body map rules you guys are idiots

TheGreatD17
May 15th 2009


1141 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

Yeah for some reason I think people disregard or don't even bother listening to LYBM, which confuses me since I think it's clearly better than Bath. Toby will never top Choirs of the Eye though.



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





FAQ // STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2014 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Privacy Policy