Rosetta/Balboa
Project Mercury


4.5
superb

Review

by Slimjim367 USER (19 Reviews)
May 1st, 2009 | 13 replies


Release Date: 2007 | Tracklist

Review Summary: A great split LP featuring hardcore band 'Balboa', but it may have been better without their completely different approach to atmosphere.

Those of you who already know of Rosetta will know how ambitious and creative this group is. Considering that, the name of this split should come as no surprise to you, and infact, should be quite expected. Project Mercury was the name of the U.S space program that put a human in orbit in 1959. Seeing as Rosetta's discography is a story of space travel littered with vocabulary and themes such as this, the name should actually be quite obvious.

What's not expected on this split is the other band on it. Hardcore band Balboa's themes dont usually cross with Rosetta's, and after hearing this album, it's clear why. it's not that Balboa doesn't add to the atmospheric feel of a Rosetta song, which they do, quite well, during the beginning of their songs. It's not that Balboa isn't 'heavy' enough for Rosetta, which they surely are. The thing that makes these two not fit is their individually unique sounds. While Rosetta goes from beautiful introductions that reminisce of floating in through space, to simply gorgeous melodic passages that tell the tales of said things, Balboa goes from the same feeling, to fast, heavy hardcore, which, though it may be well-written and executed in itself (it is), does not fit together with a band such as Rosetta. That being said, I quite enjoyed this album, though I would have released 2 different EP's.

The LP opens with Balboa for the first 3 songs. Primitive Accumulation is a truly pretty song in it opening, and lasts that way for about a minute and a half before all hell breaks loose. The rest of the (short) song is screamed and blastbeated away with thick distortion. 'Kaddish' doesnt follow this pattern however, as it goes from another breathtaking intro to another fast heavy part typical of this band, but then breaks the mold by going into a light, cleanly plucked out journey of guitar-work for the remaining 7 minutes, only filling the last 40 seonds with the same heavyness. The final Balboa song, 'Planet Of Slums', is actually quite gorgeous, starting with distrotion, at about a minute it gets lighter, though not quite yet. This song includes singing, which actually adds quite nicely to it. It ends pretty quietly, which is a perfect prelude to the Rosetta half of the split.

TMA-1 starts softly and is the most stunning instrumental this band has ever released, spanning over ten minutes, it goes between heavy and light, but doesnt break it's feel. I've come to expect this kind of emotional sound and progressive songwriting form Rosetta. The next song isn't any shorter though, as 'Clavius' reaches almost 12 minutes, typical of the genre. Clavius is my favourite song on the album, and also uses the 'big-small, heavy-light' songwriting style.

The last song, conveniently titled 'Project Mercury', is apparently played by both bands. Although I'm not sure of the combination of who exaclty is playing/writing, this song reaks of Rosetta's sound to come, on Wake/Lift. It sounds like 1 guitarist of each band sound-wise. It is also instrumental, lasting over 8 minutes, and is a very satisfying end to such a strange and complicated album.

All in all, this Project Mercury is great, though as I said before the choice of bands together changed the mood signifigantly than a full Rosetta or full Balboa release, but perhaps that was the desire.



Recent reviews by this author
Meshuggah obZenPelican What We All Come To Need
Becoming The Archetype DichotomyNo Hawaii Bruce Lee In Your Brain EP
Seneca ReflectionsRosesdead Stages
user ratings (48)
Chart.
4.2
excellent

Comments:Add a Comment 
Athom
Staff Reviewer
May 1st 2009


17230 Comments


This should probably be under Rosetta/Balboa since its a split.

had no idea this existed, which is weird because i like both bands.

Slimjim367
May 1st 2009


512 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0 | Sound Off

Yeah i was checking them out on Wiki (Rosetta) a while ago and found this.

Athom
Staff Reviewer
May 1st 2009


17230 Comments


if you liked Balboa you should get their self-titled. its legit

Slimjim367
May 1st 2009


512 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0 | Sound Off

Hm, I'll check it out tonight
I'd heard random songs by them in the past, but never an album
with this split I've gotten interested in them though but wasn't sure where to begin
thanks

Wizard
May 1st 2009


19641 Comments


Really enjoyable review. Rosetta are a little overrated but good none the less. I will most likely look into this.

Digging: Ash Borer - Cold of Ages

Photon
May 1st 2009


1292 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

i have heard some songs off this..they are really good .....will be getting this

br3ad_man
Emeritus
May 1st 2009


2125 Comments


Great review. I actually prefer the Balboa tracks on this split, even though I definitely like Rosetta more as a band. Both bands rule and this is a really great release.

Slimjim367
May 5th 2009


512 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0 | Sound Off

Yeah although you can boviously tell how closely i hold rosetta by this review i tried to be fair
though in hindsight i really gave rosetta more attention in terms of writing

witchxrapist
May 2nd 2010


11057 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

The song that's both Rosetta and Balboa together is just fucking epic.

VinVal
May 30th 2014


972 Comments


i had no idea this existed, rosetta does splits with alot of different bands


Digging: Sigh - Ghastly Funeral Theatre

tacos N stuff
November 10th 2014


397 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

Can we acknowledge the amazingness of Clavius please?

Digging: IDYLLS - Prayer for Terrene

VinVal
November 11th 2014


972 Comments


quite true mate

VinVal
November 11th 2014


972 Comments


but i prefer TMA-1



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





FAQ // STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2014 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Privacy Policy