John Lennon
John Lennon/Plastic Ono Band


1.5
very poor

Review

by Nick Butler EMERITUS
July 19th, 2005 | 66 replies


Release Date: 1970 | Tracklist


John Lennon - John Lennon/Plastic Ono Band
Released December 11th, 1970.
Capitol Records.
#22 in Rolling Stone's Top 500 Albums Of All Time.
DISCLAIMER - I'm warning you right now, up front, this review is CONTROVERSIAL. If you like this album, you'll probably want to kill me by the time you're two paragraphs in. And if you thought br3ad's Coldplay review wasn't helpful, well.....

I'll make no bones about this - you need to know the story of Plastic Ono Band before you can judge it properly. In brief, then: in 1970, The Beatles had just broke up. I shouldn't need to tell you it shook the world. Like many people, though obviously more than most, John Lennon felt lost, and sank into a depression of sorts. His attempted solution was found in Dr. Arthur Janov's radical Primal Scream Therapy, which involves recollecting a painful memory and, basically, screaming as loud as possible to exorcise your demons. The therapy appeared to be working for Lennon....until it was cut short. The details are slightly sketchy, but the general gist is that the US immigration authorities threatened to kick Lennon out of the country, and once Lennon found he could not get one of Janov's therapists to come to Mexico with him, he stopped attending therapy sessions.

Understandably, this left Lennon in a strange place. To understand this totally, imagine that the therapist is a surgeon. Would you leave the surgery before he had a chance to re-seal the wound? This is exactly what Lennon did. Janov and his followers only had time to bring Lennon's demons to the surface. They never let him deal with them, and heal accordingly. And that, in a nutshell, is what Plastic Ono Band is - John Lennon's final therapy session.

We can acknowledge several good things about this album (on paper, at least). It's honest, direct, and open. It's stripped back, presumably to make the message more powerful. It's totally unique. It's also highly influential, being one of the key records that kicked off the singer-songwriter trend. Oh, and - bafflingly - Phil Spector produced it. You'd think that might lead to a good album. Think again.

I remember, quite clearly, the first time I heard this record. I wasn't quite sure what to expect - I'd been warned that it was far more raw and personal than anything The Beatles had ever done, I knew the backstory, and I'd also read some pretty scathing reviews of it (but a fair few positive ones, too). As the first track, "Mother", started, I thought 'this sounds okay'. It's a very simple track, and it's certainly never going to trouble a 'John Lennon's Best Songs' list, but it wasn't too bad beyond Lennon's out-of-tune melismas. I started to zone out 3 minutes in, bored with this song already. Then, roughly 4 minutes in, it happened. 'What the fuck is he doing?!?' Tuneless, tortured screaming is what. 'Momma don't go, daddy come home'. Over and over again, for a full minute and a half, getting worse, and worse, and worse. If this is what primal scream therapy sounds like, I never want to hear it again. 'Please,' I thought, 'don't let that be a sign of what else is on this album.'

Well, I got my wish....for a while. There's no tuneless screaming on "Hold On" - the problem is that it's boring as shit, and a useless waste of 2 minutes. "I Found Out"? Happy joy for all - a combination of tuneless vocals, AND a boring arrangement! I was beginning to wish I was hearing "Mother" again. Song after song flew past, gradually sapping more and more life out of me. By the time "Well Well Well" rolled around, I officially hated this record. Even more tuneless and abrasive than "Mother", tied to the sort of lyrics any half-decent songwriter could toss off in their sleep. At this point, I had to (with a sense of disgust) acknowledge that "Mother" is actually the third best song on the album. To call Plastic Ono Band a rock album is to mislabel it - it's nothing less than an endurance test.

It's not an album without its highlights (see the Recommended Downloads below - two stone-cold classics do lie amongst the crap), and there is a very occasional flash of inspiration (the first few chords of "Isolation", for instance), but as a whole, Plastic Ono Band is the aural equivalent of a spoiled child throwing his toys out of the pram. It's annoying, tiring, tuneless, and above all, totally attention-seeking - aside from the fact that one song is called "Look At Me" (who the fuck are we listening to, Geri Halliwell?!) and another is called "My Mummy's Dead", lyrics include such gems as "I don't expect you to understand/After you've caused so much pain" and this stunningly awful rant, on "God".

I don't believe in magic
I don't believe in I-ching
I don't believe in Bible
I don't believe in tarot (pronounced wrong)
I don't believe in Hitler
I don't believe in Jesus
I don't believe in Kennedy
I don't believe in Buddha
I don't believe in Mantra
I don't believe in Gita
I don't believe in Yoga
I don't believe in kings
I don't believe in Elvis
I don't believe in Zimmerman (that's Bob Dylan to you and me)
I don't believe in Beatles
I just believe in me
Yoko and me
And that's reality


Presumably, "God" is short for 'God, what the hell happened to John Lennon? This is the man who wrote "Strawberry Fields Forever"! This is the man who wrote "Tomorrow Never Knows"! This is the man who wrote "Jealous Guy"!' (I think we can be forever thankful he held that one back for Imagine - I'd hate to think of such a great song buried under the shoddy production of this album.) Incidentally, early demo versions of this reveal that the line 'Yoko and me' wasn't added until very late on. Pussywhipped, John?

Plastic Ono Band should be acknowledged, understood, even respected. But how the hell anyone can enjoy this mess is beyond me. Clearly, there are an awful lot of people who DO like it (check the RS number!), but I just cannot get into that mindset, which is something I can't say about any other album. There are those who have claimed you need to be deeply depressed, or have experienced mental instability, to truly love this record. Thing is, I've experienced both, and I still hate it. Everything from the production (shoddy at best), to the basslines (plodding and bored), to the piano parts (far too simplistic), to the lyrics (truly awful), is shockingly bad. Had anyone other than John Lennon recorded this, it'd have been immediately dismissed and forgotten. Hell, it probably wouldn't even have been released. I guess that sort of critical blindness is the perk of being a former Beatle. Even John himself seemed desperate to forget this, returning immediately to the sound he was famous for on "Imagine".

John Lennon is undoubtedly capable of writing deeply personal, cutting, great songs (see "Help!" and "Jealous Guy" ). Here, he fails to do so, time and time again. What Lennon failed to realize is that there are far better ways to express your anger than throwing a tantrum. Ever heard anyone say that Yoko Ono ruined John Lennon? They were lying. It was Dr. Arthur Janov. Here's your proof.

Within The Genre - 2.5/5
Outside The Genre - 0.5/5

Recommended Downloads -

Working Class Hero

This album's saving grace. Lennon's aim was clearly to write a direct, emotional album that pulled no punches, and this is the ONLY track that he got right. Perfect, in fact. Honestly, despite what I've said above, I cannot get enough of this song. It's the only song on here with the sort of strong melody you'd expect from Lennon, the only song with good lyrics, and the only song to accurately convey Lennon's anger and spite without coming off as forced. Despite the 'I don't believe in Zimmerman' protests, this is incredibly Dylan-esque, and all the better for it.

Power To The People
Embarrassingly, this wasn't included on the original version of Plastic Ono Band, which means I should really rate it even lower. However, I'm being kind, since as far as I'm aware, all the versions in print now include this as a bonus track. "Power To The People" is one of Lennon's most universally recognized songs. It retains some of the elements that make the rest of the album a chore (the vocals, notably, and the self-obsessed nature of re-using the lyric 'Say you want a revolution?'), but wraps it up in a sunny, jazzy saxophone line and a mass gospel choir.

Further Listening
Lou Reed - Metal Machine Music



Recent reviews by this author
Krzysztof Penderecki and Jonny Greenwood Krzysztof Penderecki / Jonny GreenwoodLana Del Rey Paradise
Scott Walker Bish BoschEmilie Autumn Fight Like A Girl
Susanne Sundfor The Silicone VeilPepe Deluxe Queen of the Wave
user ratings (304)
Chart.
4.2
excellent
other reviews of this album
Chris Davanzo (4)
“I don’t believe in Beatles, I just believe in me.”...


Comments:Add a Comment 
Zmev
July 19th 2005


983 Comments


Nice Further Listening Album

Little Man being Erased
July 19th 2005


87 Comments


Nice review.

drummerguy274
July 19th 2005


32 Comments


rreally good review

Iai
Emeritus
July 19th 2005


3553 Comments

Album Rating: 1.5

Nice Further Listening Album

Was hoping somebody would pick up on that.

br3ad_man
Emeritus
July 19th 2005


2125 Comments


DISCLAIMER - I'm warning you right now, up front, this review is CONTROVERSIAL. If you like this album, you'll probably want to kill me by the time you're two paragraphs in. And if you thought br3ad's Coldplay review wasn't helpful, well.....


hah.

Really really good review man. One of your best for sure. I'm going to check out this album because the only song I've heard was the only one you said was good (well, I have Lennon Legend and there's probably stuff from this on there but I can't remember any of that cd).

Iai
Emeritus
July 19th 2005


3553 Comments

Album Rating: 1.5

I'm going to check out this album because the only song I've heard was the only one you said was good

Masochist, eh? :p

masada
July 19th 2005


2733 Comments


Great review.

I love the cover to the album.

robo2448
July 19th 2005


132 Comments


I think you're insane. It's one of my favorite albums. Good detailed review though.

Robert Crumb
Emeritus
July 19th 2005


165 Comments


Presumably, "God" is short for 'God, what the hell happened to John Lennon?


:lol:

Fantastic review.


BlackDeathMetalJazz or really ANYTHING else please-
July 20th 2005


200 Comments


That further listining part was kinda mean. Great reveiw anyway. Even though I haven't heard this yet. :-/

br3ad_man
Emeritus
July 20th 2005


2125 Comments


[quote=Iai]
Masochist, eh? [/quote]

:lol: Not quite

temporary
July 20th 2005


207 Comments


Great review, although it was increadably contriversal.This Message Edited On 07.20.05

Tsuruka
October 5th 2005


55 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

Amazing review.

But I stronly disagree on the rating, but yeah, I read the disclaimer.

Blackbird
November 12th 2005


39 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

I also strongly disagree on the rating. This is a 5/5 no doubt.

Mother
Working Class Hero
Love

are by far the best

This album is a true expression of emotion. John's raucous and begging vocals are incredible.

I think this finished 22 in Rolling Stones best albums list didnt it?

El_Goodo
December 10th 2005


1008 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

I love this album...and John's screaming is among some of the best I've heard in rock songs! Also the songs are catchy, and it shows what John Lennon's really like, he's a rock n' roll singer! And anyone who doubts that can listen to Well, Well, Well, which I think is a great rock song!

sj_2150
December 10th 2005


251 Comments


Iai this album was released in the 70s... its a very good job considering its the 70s

Iai
Emeritus
December 11th 2005


3553 Comments

Album Rating: 1.5

Are you suggesting that the music of the 70s is somehow inherently worse than the music of today?

masada
December 11th 2005


2733 Comments


It's just as good, and just as bad.

Hyper Music
December 11th 2005


45 Comments


HaHa, I thought this was a wonderfully honest review.

Bron-Yr-Aur
April 15th 2006


4405 Comments


Yeah. Certainly not album of the year. This is more Yoko than John, who seemed to be merely a puppet and figure head after the Beatles.



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





FAQ // STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2014 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Privacy Policy