Isis
Oceanic


5.0
classic

Review

by Ben Padgett USER (1 Reviews)
November 17th, 2008 | 15 replies | 4,273 views


Release Date: 2002 | Tracklist

Review Summary: Probably the most amazing quality to this album is its ability to replicate an ocean. The heavy parts feel like the rough, unforgiving waves, and the softer passages like the gentle sea-water splashing at your toes.

8 of 8 thought this review was well written

Here we have ISIS - An Avant-garde metal, Experimental rock, Post-metal, Psychedelic rock, Atmospheric sludge, 'whatever you call them' band. Now, my first experience with Isis was their latest record - In The Absence of Truth. I was impressed by what i was hearing, but i didn't believed in matched the hype surrounding this band. I decided to venture back to their past records which were both hailed as masterpieces - Oceanic and Panopticon. I immediately purchased both.

As soon as i received Oceanic, i gave the CD a listen. I thought i would be doing this album and Isis an injustice by not sharing my opinion. Here is a track by track review:

(1) The Beginning and the End:

This song starts out with a nice drum groove accompanied by mildly-heavy guitar. At 0:35, Mono-tonal vocals kick in and the song becomes blisteringly heavy. The guitars becomes fierce, the vocals letting out a brutal, almost robotic yell. At 1:25, the song takes a complete U-turn. Everything becomes softer, more ambient, not to mention the vocals cut out. This part shows off Isis' trademark. The passage continues for a few minutes occasionally steering away to reveal its heaviness. This song becomes mesmerizing, almost hypnotic. The repetition of the instruments, the subtle changes to each one - It all builds and molds the atmosphere Isis creates with this song (and all of Oceanic, in fact). At 4:25, All instruments cut out except for guitar, which plays a subtle riff before being joined by the sheer onslaught of the rest of the band. Things become hectic, the vocals return again, Isis reveals some of their best musically here.

(2) The Other:

This song begins on a softer note. It begins to build-up and grow as the intensity rises. At 1:50 we are again greeted by Aaron Turner and his guttural screams. The song becomes heavy, like it's predecessor, but this passage only continues for a short time, before returning to it's previous state of tranquility. This does not remain for very long, and we are again faced with the same heavy passage. This continues much longer than before and shows a great amount of dimension to Turner as a vocalist. The song then alternates between heaviness with vocals, and without. The song then ends on a heavy note.

(3) False Light:

This song begins brutally heavy. and continues that way until 3:00 where the music takes a sudden stop and turn around to the more subtle, atmospheric passages we are quite familiar with. This song steadily continues this until 6:00 where the guitar takes in-front and leads the rest of the band into full-fledged chaos. At 7:00, The infamous Turner returns with his guttural screams and the song ends on this note.

(4) Carry:

A very mellow song from the beginning, Carry follows the classic Isis trademark and builds up slowly until 4:00 where everything becomes heavy, the vocals soon accompany and the song dives into uncharted-heavy-territory, but this time we find Turner with a female accomplice. Her subtle presence adds a great deal of depth and purpose to this simple song.

(5) - :

This track acts more like a rest than anything else. This track does not feature Isis playing whatsoever. In fact, it really isn't anything. Just an array of natural sounds. The track offers the listener some comfort and reflection on what they have just experienced, and what they are about to experience.

(6) Maritime:

A track must like its predecessor. This track is actually quite different from the entire album in that it has a distinct electronic flavor to it. This song is relaxing, calm, gentle. The song has no real change in dynamics and retains a very soothing tone.

(7) Weight:

Now, this is where Isis return! A song very similar to 'Carry' in structure. However, this song is much more 'patient' in it's delivery. It steadily builds and grows until 8:33 where we are greeted by that female singer which we were introduced to in 'Carry'. She repeats a line that is lost and buried in the mix, her vocals are hypnotic, and as the music becomes heavier, you find yourself in a trance, unable to break free until the song comes to a sudden end.

(8) From Sinking:

One of the heavier songs on Oceanic. It begins and ends on a heavy note. Throughout the song, there is mild contrast to the heaviness with soothing passages, but these are sparingly disposed of for heavier and more brutal passages, that tend to dominate this song.

(9): Hym:

The final track on the album. This song has more of a heavier tendency, but their is no shortage of softer parts. Overall, a fantastic end to the album. It shows diversity, and some of Isis' best songwriting yet. It is a good representation of what the listener has just experienced with Oceanic.

__________________________________________________ _


Oceanic. Words cannot describe the sheer beauty of this record. The majesty of Isis' instrumentation, the multi-dimension to Turner's seemingly mono-tonal voice, the way in which a unique atmosphere is created every single song.

Probably the most amazing quality to this album is its ability to replicate an ocean. The heavy parts feel like the rough, unforgiving waves, and the softer passages like the gentle sea-water splashing at your toes.

Do yourself a favor and buy this album. Experience this unique journey. Let Isis encompass your every senses and drag you out to sea. 5/5 = 10/10 = 100%


Positives:

Originality
It's ability to be heavy, yet beautiful.

Negatives:

None.


user ratings (1757)
Chart.
4.3
superb
other reviews of this album
Alex Robertson STAFF (5)
Wow....

Andrew H. EMERITUS (5)
...


Comments:Add a Comment 
Zeranna
November 17th 2008



10 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

Hey everyone, this is my first review.. ever actually

Please be nice.. hehe... nah be honest.

I realize i tend to have more depth in reviewing earlier tracks, but i got tired typing at 3 in the morning lol

Tell me what ya think

Merkaba33
November 18th 2008



702 Comments


good for a first. try not to get dragged down into describing each track but rather try and describe the album as a whole. this can be really hard with track-by track reviews so it's probly better just not to do them (i think i speak for most ppl here) and if its late at night just put it off a day. i'd rather see a more in depth review a day later than one that somebody skimped on.

I've never really got into these guys even though they seem to have a lot of respect on this site.This Message Edited On 11.18.08

Zippermouth
November 18th 2008



1305 Comments


Track 5 has no name, and the numbers dont correspond with the actual track listing, you might want to fix that.

Avoid doing track-by-track reviews, they're boring and tedious and nobody will read them.
There are a few grammar errors but nothing serious. Its pretty good for a first.

NortherlyNanook
November 18th 2008



1285 Comments


No, the Sputnik tracklisting is not what the actual album goes by. His is correct.This Message Edited On 11.18.08

ManWomanBoogie
November 18th 2008



185 Comments


Pretty good tbt.

Zeranna
November 18th 2008



10 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

Thanks everyone

I will definitely take the track-by-track thing into consideration.



SynGates
November 18th 2008



2467 Comments


Also, it's not good to do a play-by-play. Like, you shouldn't just say, "at 4:32, this comes in" and should instead just concentrate on the whole record's sound. It's well written, though.

Zippermouth
November 18th 2008



1305 Comments


Nice job dude, you've racked up two pos votes. Thats pretty decent for a TBT and a first timer. Mad props. I think I'll pos too.

ikarus
November 18th 2008



562 Comments


eh never got into this band

the post-metal = sounds of the ocean analogy is getting fucking old

spoon_of_grimbo
November 18th 2008



2240 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

ikarus, the reason it's gotten old is because of the ridiculous amount of bands who've ripped off Isis!!!

this is an amazing album, probably about equal to Panopticon in quality (although that one always seems to be raved about a lot more, never figured out why), although i prefer ITAOT over both of them, it's got a much wider range of sounds and a nice dose of general weirdness.

great review Zeranna, although i'll have to echo the sentiments of some of the others - it's not usually a good idea to do a track by track unless you're reviewing a very short EP or maybe a compilation. still worth a pos vote though! welcome to sputnik!

ohhhcomely
November 18th 2008



175 Comments


I should REALLY listen to this. Nice review.

cbmartinez
November 18th 2008



2525 Comments


The first track and first light are two of their best tracks but other than that this album doesn't really do it for me.

Wizard
November 18th 2008



19344 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

Welcome to the site !

Good first review. I can certainly attest that most people who join this site write slightly fanboyish reviews, but yours had a bit more credibility to it. Good job for a first, I would venture off the path of TBT's.

Digging: Mistigo Varggoth Darkestra - The Key to the Gates of the Apocalypse

AnimalsAsSummit
September 21st 2013



701 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

Flood, Ocean Machine, and Oceanic = best water albums

Digging: Volcanic Queen - Sullen Empire

BigPleb
September 21st 2013



36127 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

P cool album.

Digging: Arc Iris - Arc Iris



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





FAQ // STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2014 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Privacy Policy