Porcupine Tree
We Lost the Skyline


4.0
excellent

Review

by Rob USER (7 Reviews)
February 26th, 2008 | 16 replies | 24,179 views


Release Date: 2008 | Tracklist

Review Summary: Enjoy a nice evening with Steven Wilson and John Wesley performing acoustic, stripped down Porcupine Tree songs for you.

3 of 3 thought this review was well written

On October 4th 2007, Orlando was given a very special treat. Porcupine Tree showed up for an in store performance and signing session at Park Avenue CDs. It had been planned originally for the whole band to perform, but due to the space limitations only Steven Wilson and John Wesley took the stage. The set list includes some songs heard rarely, if ever, live and this makes for a very intimate and special show. The set just contains vocals and guitar from the two, mainly acoustic though there is some electric guitar in a few of the songs.

After hearing the first few electric guitar notes and Steven softly singing, “We lost the skyline. We stepped right off the map. Drifted into blank space and let the clocks relapse.” you can tell this is something special. This rendition of The Sky Moves Sideways, while being greatly abridged, captures a tempered beauty of the original. Even Less picks up the tempo right away and brings some energy to the stage. While it's great to hear this song on here, it's a little sloppy in one or two places. Overall it doesn't really derogate the song as a whole and it remains a welcomed addition. The third song is Stars Die from 1993, and as Steven mentions on the album, it was also the first Porcupine Tree song to ever receive radio play. The acoustic rendition of this song is fantastic and it really fits well on this CD.

The first three songs are performed solo by Steven and for the remaining five tracks John Wesley joins the stage on electric guitar and backing vocals. Waiting is the first track with John and it's a good change of mood. Despite it's lyrics, musically the song has more of a lighthearted feel. Next up is one of the highlights of the night, Normal. It's the newest song on the set list and it comes from the Nil Recurring EP. This song works really well here, especially the vocal harmonies of Steven and John going back and forth. It's the catchiest song of the night and beforehand Steven has a nice little anecdote about the difficulty in perfecting the song, he even messes up the intro and has to start over. It's something that adds a little humor and character to the performance.

I've always been a fan of Drown With Me and it's perfectly suited for this performance. It keeps up the energy that the last track had, but in a different way. Lazarus is the weakest song on the album. It's not bad but without the piano line it loses some flavor. After which is probably the most well known Porcupine Tree song on here, Trains. It was the song that first got me into the band and it sounds great on here.

This is a wonderful collection of stripped down Porcupine Tree songs. It's a special set with some nice surprises and just an enjoyable listen all around. The sound quality and production for this live recording is really good, it sounds as if you're sitting next to a warm fireplace with Steven Wilson and John Wesley creating beautiful sounds as gifts to your ears. My only complaints are that I was slightly letdown with Even Less and Lazarus, though my expectations could have been a little too high. And while I love Trains, I almost wish that another rare treat would've been included in its place. Fadeaway or Nine Cats would have been very nice inclusions. Either way, I highly recommend this to both fans and even non-fans of Porcupine Tree.



Recent reviews by this author
Skinny Puppy The ProcessTiger Army Early Years EP
Danzig 7:77 - I LuciferiVNV Nation Empires
AFI Black SailsDanger To The System Beware the Military Industrial Complex
user ratings (133)
Chart.
3.7
great

Comments:Add a Comment 
Windows
February 26th 2008



76 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Great review. God I can't wait for this. It was supposed to come in the mail today, but it didn't! Hopefully tomorrow...


Kage
February 26th 2008



1173 Comments

Album Rating: 2.5

Porcupine Tree fans will praise anything the band puts out.

Did this deserve an official release? Nah. Steven Wilson isn't good enough at the whole stripped down thing to make it worthwhile at all.

Doppelganger
February 26th 2008



3124 Comments


Sort of want.

Geedrummer
February 26th 2008



607 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

I need this and will DIE if i dont get it. i didnt realise it was coming out so soon.

Hewitt
February 26th 2008



371 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0 | Sound Off

It's only $10 on the Porcupine Tree website. I'm not sure if it's just going to be available on the web or in stores.

Flyboy
February 26th 2008



394 Comments


Good review mate :thumb: now I want it!

Jim
February 27th 2008



5110 Comments


yeah this looks interesting. nice review.
:voting smily:

Altmer
February 27th 2008



5652 Comments


yeah I want this too

McP3000
February 27th 2008



3941 Comments


I'd rather just get a new LP than redone songs :/

Willie
Moderator
February 27th 2008



15875 Comments


I like PT, but I like the songs for all the things going on.... I think a stripped down release would just bore the crap out of me. Good review though....

Digging: Emperor - In The Nightside Eclipse - 20th Year Anniversary

Foodforthegods
March 15th 2008



425 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Just ordered it from the PT store with the new CD/DVDA version of Lightbulb sun (including a two track bonus Cd for a limited time)

moltenlava
July 6th 2008



312 Comments


This shoulda been a bonus disc on a re-release or something similiar.




Rebelagainstthei
December 2nd 2008



5 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

that's so cool. my band got to play at Park Ave cds, and I had heard that Porcupine Tree played there also. I had no idea that they recorded it and put out a cd of it. definitely gonna check this out when I get some money.

wakeem
July 1st 2009



100 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

I dont normally like live CDs, especially when they are 'stripped down' live CDs for whatever reason. But this was actually quite a decent collection, surprised to find that I enjoyed it.

The CD doesnt receive anywhere near as much rotation as most other PT albums but it was well worth a listen and I still listen to it occasionally. Normal was definitely the high point - for the song and the 'intro'.

Firecracker
November 20th 2009



106 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

I have the lp.
had such a beautiful few minutes listening to it in our record room in the dark

IMZA1793
February 20th 2012



843 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

I love "Stars Die" in this one. Actually found it better than the original.



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





FAQ // STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2013 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Privacy Policy