The Old Dead Tree
The Nameless Disease


3.5
great

Review

by Kyle Ward STAFF
February 7th, 2008 | 18 replies


Release Date: 2003 | Tracklist

Review Summary: A brilliant musical dedication bred from tragedy

A deep frustration's running through my veins
A dark light's entering the church
By pale glass windows
And I feel so cold.
I can't stop looking at the wooden box placed
In the very centre of the nave.
I'm trying to imagine you...
...Sleeping.
We're in the home
Of life and death,
Where each being takes end.


French Metal band The Old Dead Tree began it’s life in the city of Paris in 1997. The sought to play an interesting and quite unique mix of death metal, progressive, doom metal, and dark metal. Vocalist and guitarist Manuel Munoz and guitarist Nicolas Chevrollier were the founding members of the band, soon joined by drummer Frederic Guillemot and bassist Vincent Danhier. They wrote music over the next few years, and soon released their first EP entitled The Blossom in 1999. It generated a small fan base which appreciated their style of slow, pounding guitar riffs and smooth transitions between clean and growled vocals. In 1999, however, their successful and promising debut would be thrown into the air.

A few months after the release of The Blossom, Frederic Guillemot committed suicide, and amidst all of the confusion, mourning, and chaos, the band’s future would be paved.

After the suicide, the band members were inspired to describe the dramatic loss of their band mate and friend by expressing their darkest feelings and frustration which his death provoked in a brand new concept album based around this experience. The result, after much thought and four years of preparation, was 2003’s The Nameless Disease. It was an exercise in all that was running through the head’s of the remaining members, something which varied from depression to confusion, raw anger, grief, sorrow, remorse, apathy, and frustration.

All the things let undone,
All the smiles that are gone,
All the love you won't know,
All the places you won't go.


It’s evident in everything from the song titles to the guitar riffs what exactly each song portrays, and what each song is meant to say in regard to this tragedy. It is a concept which seems so real, and seems so close to the hearts of everyone who wrote music on this album. It’s this sense of closeness and direct influence which makes the album concept execute so well. The lyrics seem like unspoken words out of each band member’s head, words which have to be released one way or another. It’s strange how you can just choose a random song and know exactly what emotion is going on in the song. If you listen to “How Could You”, it’s quite obvious that this song expresses deep mistrust and anger toward Guillemot, with vocalist Manuel Munoz in simple disbelief that it all happened. “It’s The Same For Everyone” is an anthem written in the deepest stages of depression and uncertainty, something evident from the vocals to the guitar riffs. The album strangely seems much longer than its 50 minute play time would hint, something which is both surprising and constantly evident while you try to listen to The Nameless Disease in one sitting.

The album is instrumentally solid, showing a heavy dose of doom-influenced song structures and musical style. The guitar riffs can be slow, crushing, and at times very melodic. The music takes numerous breaks throughout the album, slowing down to a crawl at some points where nothing but a simple drum beat and the vocals progress the songs. At other times, however, the music can be upbeat, melodic, and fast paced. Toward the end of “It’s The Same For Everyone” The Old Dead Tree manages to incorporate a really impressive and quite inspiring guitar solo, which continues through the ending chorus. With the guitars comes the majority of the music, something which isn’t left to the acoustic guitar alone. In the short, ballad-like track “All…”, nothing but acoustic guitars and drums are used, continuing into the final track “The Bathroom Monologue”. Throughout the album, you will hear some really intense melodies which give a strong nod toward melodic death metal, adding to the overall appeal of the music.

The vocals may be hit or miss for some. For the majority of the running time, the vocals are sung cleanly in a voice which is quite hard to compare to anything else. They aren’t poorly performed at all, quite the contrary actually, they are performed with nothing but pure emotion fueling them, and it is quite noticeable in some songs how the vocalist feels about his friend’s suicide. They aren’t to everyone’s liking though, and may take some time to become more tolerable to some people. Don’t fear, though, since the vocals sometimes transition to a really, really well-performed death metal growl, such as some of the passages in “How Could You”. So, for those who don’t like just clean vocals (me being one of them) there is a fair share of those growled vocals which so many metal fans appreciate. The real staple of the album, and the vocal performance, however, is the great execution of the clean vocals.

Give you the strength
To fight for life
To face your pain
But you have preferred
To close your eyes and run away.
I imagine your face
Quietly kissing death


With The Nameless Disease, The Old Dead Tree have written and performed one of the finest concept albums I have had the pleasure to listen to. While it is far short of a classic metal album, it is an accessible listen which many metal fans will like. The album shows that if a band can take a tragedy so devastating as this one, they can unleash their emotions into an album which will have an uncanny way of captivating the listener and making them feel the pain, the sorrow, the rage which has occurred before you.

Pros
+ Great guitar riffs
+ Brilliant realization of a concept
+ Excellent vocal performance
+ Solid musicianship
+ Good variance

Cons
- Vocals may take a while to get used to
- Some parts may become boring or repetitive



Recent reviews by this author
In Flames Siren CharmsPanopticon Roads to the North
Empyrium The Turn of the TidesWolves in the Throne Room Celestite
Agalloch The Serpent and the SphereInsomnium Shadows of the Dying Sun
user ratings (26)
Chart.
3.9
excellent

Comments:Add a Comment 
BallsToTheWall
February 7th 2008


44358 Comments


Another solid review. Nice structuring of it, something I'm not capable of doing. Cool name for a band, I listened to a song from this album on myspace, it was good but the vocals were indeed a bit to swallow. Check my Primordial review, i'm sure you'll like that album as the black metal influence is pretty high on that album.

Digging: Pharmakon - Abandon

LifeInABox
February 7th 2008


3708 Comments


you're bangin out reviews like hand children, dude.

Crysis
Staff Reviewer
February 7th 2008


16389 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

I like to do about one review a week.

Digging: Spectral Lore - III

beans
February 7th 2008


2332 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

good review man! gets my vote fo sho

sounds like a good band, but the thing is (with me) the vox either make or break the music, so im hoping the music can shine through the vocals, ill be checking this out.

Crysis
Staff Reviewer
February 7th 2008


16389 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

The singing vocals were the ones which took a while to grow on me, at least 3 full listens, but now I really like them.

beans
February 7th 2008


2332 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

i just downloaded the first 3 tracks and im liking them pretty damn well, im working on getting the rest of the album

Willie
Moderator
February 8th 2008


15975 Comments


Great review... I need to check this out quick.

Digging: Necropoli - I

Pebster49
February 8th 2008


2992 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

excellent review, checking out there myspace, I like "It Can't Be".

Sweet, its on Itunes too....wooo

Crimson
February 8th 2008


1935 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Good review, didn't think I'd like this, as it seemed from your review it was doom metal, but this is actually pretty good.
I like the clean vocals for some reason.

FR33L0RD
February 8th 2008


1464 Comments


good review, i didnt know this band

Crimson
February 9th 2008


1935 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

This is actually a lot better than what I was expecting, their is a lot of really good stuff on here. The clean vocals didn't take any time for me to appreciate them.

Joy & Happiness is simply stunningThis Message Edited On 02.09.08

Crysis
Staff Reviewer
February 9th 2008


16389 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

Glad you like this, Joy & Happiness and It's The Same For Everyone are my favorite songs.

beans
February 9th 2008


2332 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

and thank you crysis

rasputin
March 8th 2008


14544 Comments


I want to get this. I sort of felt your actual review was more than a 3.5, but doesn't matter.

Sciroccu
August 2nd 2010


764 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Great album indeed !
Clean vocals are good to me.

loosethefiend
July 6th 2011


4 Comments


really dug the review! thanks for getting this done!

Zion
December 18th 2011


812 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

I heard this album prior to reading, and couldn't pick out all the lyrics. But I could tell at least parts were about a suicide. The emotional power of the album is chilling... I found it deeply moving. Tracks 5, 6, and 7 really drive it home.

Egarran
April 27th 2014


269 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

A little gem. It is indeed very moving.



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





FAQ // STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2014 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Privacy Policy