Eminem
The Marshall Mathers LP


5.0
classic

Review

by Nick Butler EMERITUS
January 16th, 2005 | 2307 replies | 139,184 views


Release Date: 2000 | Tracklist


#302 on Rolling Stone's Top 500 Albums Ever.
#5 on Q's Top 100 Albums Ever.


Albums, sometimes, are big. You know Elephant? That was big. And then, sometimes, albums are huge. Hybrid Theory? That was huge. And then, every so often, an album comes along that practically eats the world. Everywhere you go, it's there. It seems like everyone you know owns a copy. The lyrics and images within the album become an essential part of our culture. The artist comes to be among the world's most important fashion icons, and has their entire career made up. And for a while at least, it feels like nothing and nobody is seperate from its influence.

Albums like this don't come every day. In the 90's, only 3 albums could really claim that status - Nevermind, Jagged Little Pill, and OK Computer. And this decade, only one - The Marshall Mathers LP.

You'd have to be about 7 years old to not remember how massive this album was. It broke all records for first-week sales by a solo artist. It went 5-times platinum in its first month of release, a feat matched only by 2Pac and Notorious BIG. It has since sold 9 million copies in the US alone, and 15.3 million worldwide. It helped turn hip-hop into the most commercially lucrative form of music in the world. Without it, D-12 and 50 Cent wouldn't exist, and it's probable that Jay-Z and his ilk wouldn't be the stars they are today.

Nowadays, in the wake of this album, Eminem's every move and every utterance is scrutinized. He's recently come under fire for 2 bootlegs - one saying he wished the President was dead, and one attacking an ex-girlfriend - these events led to FBI investigation and a public apology after the song about his girlfriend was construed as racist by The Source (a magazine that has declared all-out war on him). Oh, and he's won an Oscar.

Perhaps the influence of this album can be put to words by the reader's comment on Q's Top 100 Albums Of All Time. 'It made me give a shit about music again.' That's exactly what this album did for me. I'm sure I'm not the only one. Before this, I saw music as being one of three things - unintelligible noise, boring, or for little kids. Sometimes all three. Then this album came out.

It still amazes me how well this album did, commercially. It's witty, intelligent, and not easy to listen to. Those aren't qualities you tend to associate with a 15-million seller. Eminem resolutedly HATED pop music. The moment this album dropped, he BECAME pop music. The face of the charts changed. Just as symbolic as Nirvana displacing Michael Jackson, Eminem displaced Britney Spears in the Billboard charts.

The key element to The Marshall Mathers LP is its intensity. Eminem didn't water down his sound to become such a success. This album was more intense, harder, louder, cruder, scarier, funnier, wittier, more shocking, infinitely more soul-bearing.....it was The Slim Shady LP to the nth degree. And you know he means every minute of it. You know that's he's hungry to prove himself - to prove all those Vanilla Ice comparisons wrong, to prove he's not a gimmick, to prove that white guys can rap.

And prove it he does. This is the album that stamped Eminem's reputation as possibly the best MC since Rakim - certainly the best to gain mainstream acceptance. There's more than enough here to prove his wit and technical ability - Who Knew's explanation of the hypocricy of middle American parents; Amityville's portrayal of the Detroit he grew up in; The Way I Am as a whole.

What elevates this above most mainstream rap albums is the variation. From Kill You's excellent use of silence and sparcity, to Stan's sampling of Dido and use of rain and writing sound effects, to The Real Slim Shady's twisted pop, to Marshall Mather's lonely acoustic guitar, to Bitch Please II's Dre-trademarked G-funk, to Kim. Oh man, you have to hear Kim. It's utterly incredible. Emotional, epic, tragic, disturbing, thought-provoking. It's the under-rated jewel in this LP, and indeed, Eminem's career.

The album is flawed only by a couple of skits (the Ken Kaniff skit is disgusting and has no place in music) and by guest appearances. Amityville would be much better off without Bizzare. D12 have never been up to Eminem's standards, a fact first proved on Under The Influence. Remember Me is better, but below average for this album. No such problems with Dido on Stan or Dre, Snoop, Xzibit, and Nate Dogg on Bitch Please II, though. Something that should be mentioned - although it is not necessarily a flaw as such - is the amount of nods to The Slim Shady LP. Drug Ballad is a sequel to Cum On Everybody, Kim ends the way '97 Bonnie & Clyde started, and the skit for both albums run parallel (Public Service Announcement, Ken Kaniff, and Paul are all on both albums). This may mean that this album becomes more enjoyable after having heard Slim Shady.

I'm willing to lay money on the fact that the vast majority of people reading this have already heard this album and made up their minds. If you haven't you pretty much missed out on the most culturally important musical event since grunge - maybe even since punk. Nevermind though. (Pun intended.) And it's for that reason that I'm not sure what score to give this album. It's not perfect (the 3 skits and Under The Influence could be slashed from this album without any caring), and thus doesn't deserve 5 on that scale. Not to mention, it is an immensely opinion-dividing album, and one blamed for offending as many people as it delights. And yet, a 5 denotes an album that everybody should hear and should own - and I believe that to be true of this album. Even if you ignore the album's importance, it remains a truly special album, unique in rap's canon, owing its spirit to rock and its heritage to rap, in a way I've rarely heard. How can I give it anything less?

5/5.

Recommended Downloads -
The Way I Am

Built over doomy, gothic arpeggios, rumbling bass, and church bells, Eminem lays down one of the most perfectly formed lyrics of his career, weaving in and out of a tight rhyme scheme that echoes the loping piano motif. Interesting aside: this is one of the first Eminem songs that gives M. Mathers 100% of the writing credits.

Kim
Immense. Scary. Epic. Touching. Powerful. Reprehensible. Provocative. This is Eminem's tour-de-force, the most unique, singularly brilliant song he has ever recorded. Starting with a sample of a music box, Eminem talks sweet baby-talk to his daughter before exploding into a raging argument with his wife, Kim, over a piano loop that extends the arpeggios from The Way I Am (rather than gothic, it's now downright fucking EVIL), a marching funeral beat, and a mournful, pleading violin. If you want any sense of meter or rhyme in Eminem's lyrics, you're going to be disappointed. What you get instead is a deranged and utterly convincing murder fantasy that revels in its own hideousness, and a song so heavy it makes Raining Blood sound like We Are The Cheeky Girls. And the best thing about the song? You listen to him choke the life out of the mother of his child, put her in a body bag and throw her in the trunk of his car......and you SYMPATHIZE WITH HIM. Incredible.

Marshall Mathers
A curio, in that even people I know who hate this album love this song. Maybe it's because it's built over an acoustic guitar looping a Im-IVm-V7 chord progression, AND it has a guitar solo. And maybe it's because it's got some of the funniest put-downs in rap's history - ICP's diss track Slim Anus prompts the response 'Slim Anus? Yeah, I don't get fucked in mine, like you two little flaming faggots'. Maybe it's because it's the most blatantly confessional song on the album (Kim aside), and 'blatantly confessional' aren't words you associate with mainstream rap too often. In any case, it's a great song.

Stan
If you haven't heard this, you probably make a career out of living under rocks. It tells the story of an obsessive fan who kills themselves because their idol (Eminem) never writes back, and introduces one of the album's key themes - the scary power of fame. Ironic, then, that this album made him the biggest cultural figurehead on the planet. It starts with a sample of Dido's Thank You under a sample of rain. This sample goes on to form the song's hook, relating the level of Stan's obsession and almost making him a sympathetic character (Your picture on my wall/It reminds me that it's not so bad....). Offsetting this is Eminem's raps under the persona of Stan, which reveal him as a reprehensible character; mentally unstable, self-mutilating, sexually confused, volatile, and abusive to his pregnant girlfriend (whose life he takes too, when he takes his own). Eminem's final verse is him attempting to write back, asking him not to be like this guy he saw on the news....Overplayed? Yes. But even so, of all of Eminem's singles, this one demonstrates his power as a rapper and his skill as a poet best.



Recent reviews by this author
Krzysztof Penderecki and Jonny Greenwood Krzysztof Penderecki / Jonny GreenwoodLana Del Rey Paradise
Scott Walker Bish BoschEmilie Autumn Fight Like A Girl
Susanne Sundfor The Silicone VeilPepe Deluxe Queen of the Wave
user ratings (2855)
Chart.
4.3
superb
other reviews of this album
1 of

Comments:Add a Comment 
Iai
Emeritus
August 15th 2004



3553 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0 | Sound Off

I'm sorry if this isn't quite up to my usual standards....I've spent all day trying to get rid of several annoying trojans and pieces of spyware, and I'm tired.

Bartender
Emeritus
August 15th 2004



826 Comments


One of the few Top 500 albums I could have reviewed, gone. Better than I would have done though, so tis a good thing overall.

I really like this album, basically because I enjoy quick, flowing, witty rapping, and Eminem is really very good at it. I used to listen to it frequently, when it first came out, but now it's not my usual genre of music by a long shot, so I don't listen to it very often. I haven't listened to it in a long while actually, though that's as much to do with not being able to find it as anything else.

SubtleDagger
August 16th 2004



737 Comments


He's good at what he does, but I don't appreciate that you give this album so much credit simply because of its sales. And the fact that you mention Jagged Little Pill and OK Computer is just proposterous. Those albums have nothing in common with each other. They did not attain the sales of Nevermind or this album. They were not breakthrough/crossover albums by any means.

If there's one thing I dislike, it's going through sales garbage in a record review. It's just wrong.

LoveBuzzed
August 16th 2004



8 Comments


It went 5-times platinum in its first month of release, a feat matched only by 2Pac and Notorious BIG.

You said this ^^^^^

Are they the only "rap/hip-hop" artists to do this or are they the only people ever?

YDload
August 16th 2004



1207 Comments


Ever since the most popular punk bands were replaced by "pop" punk and all intelligent political and social discourse was removed, Eminem has been the undisputed king of pissing people off. Plus, he's a very good rapper with regards to voice and speed, not to mention he's pretty damn funny when he wants to be.

Thanks for reviewing this; it's starred on the list now.

ludacrishiphop
August 16th 2004



6 Comments


did you write that yourself?? its not really an album review, its more of a sales review.... but ludacris likes :cool:

bassitup
August 16th 2004



6 Comments


"...Before this, I saw music as being one of three things - unintelligible noise, boring, or for little kids. Sometimes all three. Then this album came out."

i hate you for that comment.
maybe you should listen to some real music.


eminems good at what he does, but im not into rap/hiphop/rnb - my most hated genres, equal with anything heard on the radio.

and i dont believe you wrote this review. its like something out of an article.

brycey
August 16th 2004



205 Comments


The review does seem a tad professional I have to admit. I love this album. It was one of the first albums/artists I listened to and that got me into music. Suspiciously fantastic review.

Iai
Emeritus
August 16th 2004



3553 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0 | Sound Off

"...Before this, I saw music as being one of three things - unintelligible noise, boring, or for little kids. Sometimes all three. Then this album came out."

i hate you for that comment.
maybe you should listen to some real music.


Note that I said - BEFORE THIS. Indicating, that I didn't bother listening to music properly until this came out. It was this album that made me realise there was more out there. Pretty obvious if you read the quote before - 'It made me give a **** about music'. How about reading it properly, yeah?

did you write that yourself?? its not really an album review, its more of a sales review....


As I said, I didn't feel there was much I could say as an album review, because pretty much everybody has heard it. Over the whole spectrum of this forum, I'd reckon on maybe a maximum of 30 people having not heard anything from it. And those are people who live in obscure countries.

Are they the only "rap/hip-hop" artists to do this or are they the only people ever?


They're the only hip-hop artists ever. Sorry, should have clarified that.

He's good at what he does, but I don't appreciate that you give this album so much credit simply because of its sales.


Did you read beyond the first paragraph?

And the fact that you mention Jagged Little Pill and OK Computer is just proposterous. Those albums have nothing in common with each other. They did not attain the sales of Nevermind or this album. They were not breakthrough/crossover albums by any means.


Sales isn't the most important thing. The influence they had is. As soon as OK Computer was released, everybody was labelling it the best album ever. It has been labelled as such in many reader-voted polls. And it proved to be a massive influence on Travis, Elbow, Coldplay, Snow Patrol, Mansun, Martin Grech....there was a massive wave of indie bands who appeared in the mainstream bearing an obvious debt to this album, and they're still appearing today. Jagged Little Pill did much the same - Jewel, Mel Bainbridge, right up to Michelle Branch and Avril Lavigne today. It re-invented the idea of being a female singer-songwriter.

And, in fact, Jagged Little Pill outsold Nevermind by quite a large margin.

And, again as mentioned in the review, the sales are merely a barometer of the cultural impact it had - a concrete way of saying it.

And in response to.....everyone, pretty much....yes I did write this, with the help of the web for the sales figures, and one quote taken from Q. I'll take the fact you think it's plagiarized as a compliment.

Iai
Emeritus
August 16th 2004



3553 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0 | Sound Off

[QUOTE=bassitup]eminems good at what he does, but im not into rap/hiphop/rnb - my most hated genres, equal with anything heard on the radio.[/QUOTE]

Might I also add that, if you hate anything on the radio, why do you have RHCP as your avatar? Get your head out of your ass.

mexicanfloydian
August 16th 2004



165 Comments


Great review. I liked this album long time ago.

Kiedisfan69
August 17th 2004



42 Comments


One of my favorite rap albums of all time. All of these songs are catchy and have good lyrics. My favorite songs are: Criminal, Marshal Mathers, The Way I am, and Under the Influence. Out of those, "Marshal Mathers" has the most interesting lyrics.

CommieCanada
August 17th 2004



68 Comments


[QUOTE=mexicanfloydian]Great review. I liked this album long time ago.[/QUOTE]
yeah, back when eminem was "cool".... sellout

superpeer
August 17th 2004



257 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

This album is pretty good. But not really my style anymore.

The Scentless Apprentice
August 17th 2004



17 Comments


i think he raps about his mum too much.. well thats all i see on music channels, he must rap about his mum in at least three songs and i think now its time that he moves onto another topic

*then again it is my own stupid fault for watching music channels in the first place.

ken1kanniff
August 18th 2004



3 Comments


i write lyrics...pretty well , some have told me. and for that i would like to point out to anyone in these forums interested in the lyrical aspect of music that eminem...whether you like rap or not...is one of the most talended lyricists of our time. Quite possibly THE most. i don't even listen to rap and still...if you have an open enough mind to respect something for what it is whether you prefer to listen to it or not...nobody with half a brain can deny this kid his pure ability.

he has turned the world on its ear with what he's done. in an industry filled with folks rappin about cars money and otherwise i think it's refreshing to hear somebody rap about politics, the dangers of drugs (albeit also endorsing on occasion), and the f##ked up things that go on in the music industry.

great album

and i'm a granola head DMB and grateful dead loving hippie...but i can admit when someone is good at something...eminem is the only really tallented person in maistream rap today....imho

pixiesfanyo
August 18th 2004



1222 Comments


He's a pretty good lyricist. Not the best by any means though.

Eminem is decent. He is getting kind of old with D12. And I'm a bigger fan of the Slim Shady EP (since it's insane and he is on it).

Great review

SubtleDagger
August 18th 2004



737 Comments


I'll give him credit for writing something personal and having an excellent rapping style, but his lyrics really aren't that insightful. Matter of fact, they're pretty boring.

But at least he tries to do something personal, which puts him on a higher level than many rappers.

Shadows
Moderator
August 19th 2004



2530 Comments


And, in fact, Jagged Little Pill outsold Nevermind by quite a large margin.
Nothing personal, but that sickens me.

Rap/hip-hop is not my type of music by any means, and overall I find Eminem to be extremely annoying to any extent, so I can't really contribute to the thread. I suppose it was a decent review, although I find track-by-track reviews to be much more useful and interesting to read.

The Scentless Apprentice
August 19th 2004



17 Comments


in fact after a while i find his voice rather irrateing 'these chicks dont even know the name of my band' try hearing that on TV everyday 100 times

*oh yeah, 'band!?' wtf!?



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





FAQ // STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2014 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Privacy Policy