Circle Takes The Square
As the Roots Undo


5.0
classic

Review

by Alex Silveri EMERITUS
November 8th, 2007 | 96 replies | 8,997 views


Release Date: 2004 | Tracklist

Review Summary: An unrivaled and astounding masterpiece. Never has anything sounded so desperate, so absolutely and totally emotionally charged as this album.

For an album at the pinnacle of the scremo genre, it might come as a surprise that it’s actually hard to find any one thing on this album that you can really relate to. Maybe it’s the obscure lyrics or the bizarre but mind-bending instrumentation. But no, it goes completely beyond that – As The Roots Undo doesn’t so much relate to any feelings as it does create entirely new vocabularies of sonic and emotional expression. You won’t find yourself singing along to these songs as you will screaming out words you can’t even figure out – but it won’t matter. Passion and desperation don’t need words, only an outlet for escape. Well then, welcome to the biggest f'ucking exit sign this side of music.

The compositions here are some of the most intricate and elegantly crafted pieces of noise to be ever set on record, and perhaps some of the most unique works of music anywhere in their genre. It's not that they're especially technical, just put together with an amazing sense of clarity. But these aren’t symphonies or orchestrations - crafted only by the three members of Circle Takes the Square, it’s one hell of a feat; Every instrument here is stretched to its limits, churning out riffs and beats with a sort of reckless abandonment, reveling in their interwoven fragments of insanity and beauty. The result? An unrivaled and astounding masterpiece; Never has anything sounded so desperate, so absolutely and totally emotionally charged as As The Roots Undo.

There are even points here where it feels like the instruments themselves are screaming out to be heard, only to be cut short by the tattered melodies and torn rhythms that the band creates, while every now and then emerging unbound with a viciousness only matched by the desperate and frenzied cries of the band members themselves. Songs like ‘Kill The Switch’ and ‘In the Nervous Light of Sunday’ live off these dynamic shifts, moving seamlessly from thundering, distorted heavy strings and frantic drumming to slower and more melodic phrases, while other parts of the album, like the stunning ‘Interview at the Ruins’ falls back upon Circle’s love of post-rock crescendo elements. ‘Non Objective Portrait of Karma’ in particular features one of the most beautiful and atmospheric introductions to a song ever written, building itself up from the moving sounds of what can only be described as spheric guitar lines, while an ocean’s worth of ambience envelops the song completely before erupting into a blaze of roaring passion.

Kathy and Drew’s twin vocal battering, a whirlwind of screaming, chants, whispered ambience and warbling spoken poetry, only add to the already heaped layers of intricacies that make up the album. While the lyrics are mostly indecipherable, occasional words and verses rear their prose from the murky depths of the music like flashes of brilliant sunlight from smoke, dripping with excess absurdity but nevertheless begging to be sung along with. ‘Kill the Switch’ is perhaps one of the more sing-friendly songs here (which doesn’t say much), with lines like

Now my head is locked in the direction of the sun... Life is lowly, lowly anonymity, in death a noble pose, a Marat David. Tell me who wouldn't give their lives for such a soap box to leave behind. Life is lowly, lowly anonymity. I know its all been done before, I want to do it again. I WANT TO DO IT AGAIN!

Yeah, it sounds ridiculous on paper, but this sort of fantasy and absurdity fits flawlessly with everything that the album carves itself out to be. And there of course lies the majesty of As The Roots Undo. It is, to be completely damn honest, pretty much perfect. Every element and facet of the album falls into place like an elegantly constructed mosaic, some sort of magical tapestry of unbreakable material, with songs flowing into each other seamlessly and each playing a vital role in creating the album’s amazing sound creating a unity that is unmatched by any album released in recent memory.

It’s an album that is explosive in every sense of the word, blazing with breathtaking power and shattering fragility, putrid with the fumes of its own desperation. It echoes and calls with clarity and chaos, a mess of the indecipherable and the beautiful, with every sound, every ivory touch of the piano, every pitch of the gospel choir, every whisper and whistle, guitar line and drum beat, played out with the lucidity of the blast of a bomb, creating a pulsing energy which soars beyond the sum of its parts. If there is one album whose shockwaves of influence will resound in it’s genre for a long time coming, this is it.

5/5



Recent reviews by this author
Finch EpilogueThe Saddest Landscape You Will Not Survive
How to Dress Well Love RemainsLydia Assailants
Danger Mouse and Sparklehorse Dark Night of the SoulM.I.A. Maya
user ratings (1830)
Chart.
4.1
excellent
other reviews of this album
1 of

Comments:Add a Comment 
StreetlightRock
Emeritus
November 8th 2007



3752 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

Yay! Happy review from me! I’m sorry, I had to do it. With Dfel’s review not seeming to ever be coming back, I felt this was really needed. Oh and, I stole your ‘spheric’ description because I couldn’t think of a damn thing else that described it so perfectly. Much love to you for introducing me to this album as well. Also had to make up for my last shitty review which i put 0 effort in. I really just indulged myself with writing gone overboard here but I couldn’t care less. Its one of my top three favorite records of all time, so I’m gonna have fun with it, dammit

Digging: Pharoahe Monch - PTSD

francesfarmer
November 8th 2007



1477 Comments


The compositions here are some of the most complicated and elegantly crafted pieces of noise to be ever set on record,

lol

You should have noticed that alot of the melodies off this album can be played on a single guitar string.This Message Edited On 11.08.07

StreetlightRock
Emeritus
November 8th 2007



3752 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

Ohshi! That reminds me. Hold on.

TY, i knew i forgot something.This Message Edited On 11.08.07

cbmartinez
November 8th 2007



2525 Comments


wow a five, on a review for As The Roots Undo, this place never fails to surprise me

francesfarmer
November 8th 2007



1477 Comments


Still though, why noise?

Confessed2005
November 8th 2007



3314 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

This will never be a classic album.

For me anyway.

StreetlightRock
Emeritus
November 8th 2007



3752 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

Mostly because i used the word music in the sentence just before it. I have a nasty habit of trying to use interesting words and to try and not repeat them. I could replace 'noise' with 'art' if you like, like i originally did, but decided to tone it down =P

Intransit
November 8th 2007



2797 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

Stop giving him shit. It's a better review than any of the other ones. And CB is just pissy because apparently anyone who isn't a regular of h/e is just some faggot trying to be "cr00sh" . Normal people can't have opinions on things that are far too hXc for them!This Message Edited On 11.08.07

cbmartinez
November 8th 2007



2525 Comments


Yes, that sentence makes sense.

plane
Staff Reviewer
November 8th 2007



6073 Comments


There's a lot of claims that I don't necessarily agree with (the whole first sentences are the first that come to mind), but it's still nicely written. I'd like to see a review for this album that didn't reduce it to a mess of overexaggerated metaphors in the end.

DWittisarockstar
November 8th 2007



1501 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

This is a tad overrated.

Confessed2005
November 8th 2007



3314 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

Still, it's a great album. But if I want to listen to a classic album, I'll stick Converge's Jane Doe on.

IsItLuck?
Emeritus
November 8th 2007



4925 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

I'll listen to both.

iamrockzorz
November 8th 2007



1028 Comments


CD SUCKS


just kiddddin

Classics = the shape of punk to come, jane doe...
this is close though

Aficionado
November 8th 2007



1027 Comments

Album Rating: 2.5

Damn good review. When I was reading this, I imagined crazy intergalactic fights in space which speaks volumes for the imagery.

I'm really interested in this album now.

tuff
November 8th 2007



62 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

some parts bore me too much for me to give this a 5.

Still an awesome album.

lunchforthesky
November 8th 2007



1039 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

Best review of the album. Great job. Makes up for you're Kid A review.

NortherlyNanook
November 8th 2007



1285 Comments


It's good to see a review for this that's actually quite thorough. Good work. I'm not sure what to rate this, as I'm just getting into it, though I'm enjoying it immensely.

funhouse
November 8th 2007



28 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

Great review, awesome fucking album.

Aficionado
November 8th 2007



1027 Comments

Album Rating: 2.5

Best review of the album. Great job. Makes up for you're Daydream Nation review


Fixed.This Message Edited On 11.08.07



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





FAQ // STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2013 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Privacy Policy