Circle Takes the Square
As the Roots Undo


5.0
classic

Review

by Fort23 USER (29 Reviews)
August 10th, 2007 | 94 replies


Release Date: 2004 | Tracklist


My favorite albums are albums that have done something, something that has touched me emotionally, given my mind a different atmosphere (?), or has just hit a chord in my head that makes me feel good. Circle takes the square's As the Roots Undo has definitely accomplished this. This a record that just shifts through melody and chaos so perfectly it's almost hard to listen to.

So I know what you're thinking. "Yeah, and every other hyped up emo-screamo-post hardcore band". That's definitely what you would think in this scene that we've been delivered, but it's wrong. Only few bands accomplish this the way Circle takes the Square does it. Off Minor, Saetia, and Envy can go beside the band in this category, but they're a selection of the selection. Unlike most bands, Circle can make a gorgeous ambience with their own pedal driven guitar, low drums, whispered vocals regularity. This is smacked together with some of the most brutal, and chaotic hardcore imaginable. The guitar work is heavy as it is technical, and the rhythm section is like a bulldog running kilometers a minute. Drew Speziale was the only guitar playre on the record, but both rhythm and lead work flow seamlessly together to dynamically form the heavy and melodic side of the band. The bass work is not often at the main stage of attention, but it keeps the music driving. The drum work, however is key. When the band goes full throttle the drums go head first. Whether they're playing simply or complexly, drummer Jay Wynne works hard to drive the chaos, at any tempo.

But what realy drives the music (chaos and beauty) of this band is the two vocalists, guitarist Drew Speziale, and bassist, Kathy Coppola. The male and female system gives the band variety even when smacked together, and in call and response sequence. Drew's vocals tend to be the most guttural and grind driven, while kathy's are usually like frantic yells trying to break free of some type of mold. The production wasn't a charm for her; she is often barely audible behind the roar of guitars. But her spitfire energy shines through most of the record. While being experts at blood thirsty screams, the vocalists could still whisper and mutter during the slow-paced, easy tempoed tracks. The breathtaking whisper of Wade in the Water, Wade in the Water, during the seemingly blistering opening track Same Shade as Concrete, shows how easily they can switch from heavy to calm in a matter of seconds.

Lyrically, the album definitely breaks the normal emo mold. A well thought out concept of a journey of self realization, that takes the protagonist exactly were he started. With lines like Whispers invoke the artists of this tragically seemless, ill fated tapestry, blistered fingers are tending their loom. She collects the strands to braid into life., and "Which compulsion with this miniature death tributize? From behind the walls of my broken coughing tent, a formal vision, but I allude to my helpless passion for the obtuse When will this night end?", the record can show emotion, while telling a poetic story. What makes this special, however, is how the lyrics can represent the music perfectly. The enlightment is represented by the electronically constructed ambience, and on tracks like A Crater to Cough In, some of the most well constructed yet beautiful bass and guitar interplay imaginable. The distraught hopeless side is represented by, of course, the brutal hardcore.

The bands best moments are when they derive from post-rock, and begin with almost nothing, and puts you into a musical trance, and before you know it, you’re in a incredible grind section. This is represented on my favorite track n the record, Non Objective Portrait of Karma. It begins with incredible ambient guitar work, that sets the mood for the song. For a minute or two, this carries on with more guitars to create a slightly eerie mood. Then, bass and a guitar some in. The guitar is amplified, and the simple riff sounds epic. Then the vocalists begin to whisper until it gets louder and louder until before you know it, the drums kick in and they’re screaming heavily, over power chord guitars, lines like Bored as *** with this street corner-cover. study of a face in a figure. surveying this language as a game surveilence of this language as the plague.. No matter how they're playing, the band is always focused and always dead on together no matter what.

Categorizing the album is a challenge. The only band that has come close to the innovation that is represented on this record is Off Minor, but in an entirely different factor of mixing jazz and hardcore. And since experimental-progressive-emoscreamo-ambient hardcore isn't very catchy, the categorization is pointless. After listening to such a masterpiece, categorization is impossible; your mind will be at a blank mode.



Recent reviews by this author
Lil Herb Welcome To FazolandToro Y Moi Causers of This
MellowHype NumbersSpaceGhostPurrp The NASA Tape
Tyler the Creator BastardGtuk Illusion to The Max
user ratings (1869)
Chart.
4.1
excellent
other reviews of this album
1 of

Comments:Add a Comment 
Abaddon2005
August 10th 2007


684 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

Drew Speziale is the only guitarist on this record. David didn't join until recently.

Hatshepsut
August 10th 2007


1997 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0 | Sound Off

What about Kill the Switch??
Of course, this album has no flaws. Good review too.

Confessed2005
August 10th 2007


3314 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

Great review. Very impressive album but again, I do think it is a tad overrated.

chimera908
August 10th 2007


713 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

I really need to get this album. Good review too.

Hatshepsut
August 10th 2007


1997 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0 | Sound Off

Just keep listening to it, it'll probably be a 5 for you sooner or later.

Fort23
August 10th 2007


2475 Comments


Thats what lots of people had to do. Its not an easy record to get into.

astrel
August 10th 2007


2614 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

I will admit that I hated it at first.

Digging: Jessie Ware - Tough Love

Shadius
August 10th 2007


203 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

I know it's all been done before, I wanna do it again, I WANNA DO IT AGAIN.

class.

blackmilk
August 10th 2007


584 Comments


It begins with a wonderful, synth and strings opening


It's guitar.

Fort23
August 10th 2007


2475 Comments


Realy? Alright. This Message Edited On 08.10.07

711
August 10th 2007


1341 Comments


Good ol delay pedal

SynGates
August 10th 2007


2467 Comments


I'll get this today. Great review.

Fort23
August 10th 2007


2475 Comments


Its a good choice for people that are into metal, to get into the whole emo-screamo deal.
EDIT:It could work vice-versa too, I guess.This Message Edited On 08.10.07

astrel
August 10th 2007


2614 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

It was actually vise-versa for me fort.

La Revolucion
August 10th 2007


1060 Comments


On this whole album, the only instrument used other than bass, guitar and drums is a sampler towards the end of ''Same Shade Of Concrete." There's no electronically constructed ambience, strings, or synths anywhere.

[quote=Review]A well thought out concept of a journey of self realization, that takes the protagonist exactly were he started.[/quote]
You should probably say that this description is from the liner notes.

blackmilk
August 10th 2007


584 Comments


don't forget piano

La Revolucion
August 10th 2007


1060 Comments


Fort23 have you ever listened to this album?

iarescientists
August 10th 2007


5863 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0 | Sound Off

Fort has never actually listened to an album in his life :/

Dulcinea
August 10th 2007


181 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

His reviews are hilarious because it seems fairly obvious that he just reads what other people have written about the album and puts it together for a review, only with worse grammar.

Angmar
August 10th 2007


2689 Comments


Whoever negged this review better have a good reason because it was pretty well written.



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





FAQ // STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2014 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Privacy Policy