Reel Big Fish
Our Live Album Is Better Than Your Live


4.0
excellent

Review

by Richard Craig USER (120 Reviews)
April 14th, 2007 | 40 replies


Release Date: 2006 | Tracklist


Reel Big Fish are a great live band. They are fun to watch, they get the audience involved, their songs are easy to sing along to and fun to dance and in some cases, mosh to. They are a great band and they know it. This is shown by the confidence they display right from the start of their show with comments like "We're kicking your asses!" Instead of giving us, the fans, just one CD to show this fact; they have kindly given us 2 CD's and a DVD filled with live tracks. All their albums are well represented as the Fish fire out the 'hits' from their own career as well as assorted covers of A-Ha, Operation Ivy and The Cure. Reel Big Fish are not only a great live band, they are also a great ska/pop-punk band; so if you're looking for awesome musicianship then you're probably best off leaving this album well alone. However, if you're looking for fun, this triple-disc collection is definitely for you.

To say that this album doesn't have excellent musicianship makes it seem like Reel Big Fish are a bunch of talentless losers. That is simply untrue. Both CD's and the DVD have some great guitar solos scattered among the songs. An example of this is in the fan favourite 'Beer' which has some nice little solos between verses to make the song more lively and exciting and the crowd go wild for it. Immediately preceeding it are 'Take On Me' and S.R. (Many Versions Of). The first is a song that many will remember Reel Big Fish for even though it was originally recorded by A-Ha. This is simply because they make it their own. The synth riff sounds great being blasted out by the brass section and the verses work excellently with the typical ska style guitars on the upstroke. Closing the first disc is the many versions of 'Suburban Rhythms'. Normally it is a fairly boring song about the break up of a band. It is enjoyable and easy to sing to but has only 4 lines and lasts under a minute. However, this leaves a lot of room to improvise around it and on this album we hear it played in the styles of: reggae, country, death metal, punk rock and 'emo' (apparently). All of this is hilarious to listen to if not for the banter between each variation, but for the vocal stylings done on each variation. This track is a great oppurtunity for frontman Aaron Barrett to get animated with his voice and he makes full use of it. This is something that stands out on the whole album-he has a great voice. Whereas some vocalists voices waver throughout a live show his remains solid. There are no bad songs on disc one, there are some mediocre ones but for every time that this happens there is another great song to make up for it. For example a fairly average song like 'She's Famous Now', which is about a girlfriend leaving someone because she has gained lots of fame suddenly (Aaron claims it is about Gwen Stefani-he wishes) is preceeded by the excellent 'Ban The Tube Top' which sounds even better than on a studio recording and is received rapturously.

Disc Two starts with an 80's cover ("A ska cover of an 80's song-how original") in the form of ’Kiss Me Deadly’ which is thoroughably enjoyable for both us the listener at home and the kids at the show who pick up the lyrics quickly due to it's simplicity. After a 'song' made up on the spot about ’The 90's’ is another hit- 'She Has A Girlfriend Now'. The theme of being unlucky in love is common to a lot of Reel Big Fish songs, and it is always fun to listen to bitter lyrics being sung over very happy music. Although most songs on the album are similar, in that they are fast and in the ska-punk style, occasionally there is a more laid back, more traditional ska song, and 'A Little Doubt Goes a Long Way' is a great example of this as it keeps a steady pace throughout unlike most of the songs here. It is a relaxing break from the speedy ska, but chances are if you go to see Reel Big Fish you are expecting and/or wanting to hear fast, fist-pumping ska. This is provided by 'Turn The Radio Off' and dynamics are used very well to make the transition from breakdown to chorus even more exciting. It is followed by the more subdued, melancholy even 'Where Have You Been?' which on this live recording has it's length doubled due to it's calmig breakdown being extended. It creates a very jazzy feel with it's basswork and less-is-more approach. Aaron encourages the crowd to "Close your eyes and feel the magic" before yelling angrily "I CAN SEE YOUR EYES OPEN!" with tongue firmly in cheek. The banter accompanying the tracks on this album is all funny, often self-depreciating, tongue-in-cheek humour; and this makes for a very good live show as when you're not dancing or moshing along you're laughing. Predictably they close with their "big hit from the 90's"- 'Sell Out' which receives the loudest cheers out of all the songs on the album and is played with great energy that is common to all the songs here.

Although 2 CD's and a DVD for only £18 is undeniably great value for money, the vast quantity of live material is also a downside to this album. There is little variation from the fast ska-punk template. Aside from the odd slower (or at least less energetic) song, most of the tracks will sound the same to the casual listener. However, what matters is that this is a fun, enjoyable album. The album is called Our Live album Is Better Than Your Live Album this is certainly true here as it is definitely better than most live albums. This is because RBF are all about having a good time and this live album certainly displays that attitude.



Recent reviews by this author
leer SPRINGBREAKNOPARENTSThe Lawrence Arms Metropole
You Blew It! Keep Doing What You’re DoingHammock Oblivion Hymns
Warpaint The FoolThe Gaslight Anthem Handwritten
user ratings (157)
Chart.
4.3
superb

Comments:Add a Comment 
Mr_Coffee
April 14th 2007


631 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Great job, dude ;)

This album is terrific. I've never had the chance to see them live, because I live in South America and this album makes me wonder when the hell this guys are coming here.

JAD
April 14th 2007


200 Comments


Great review, I really, really want to get this album and see RBF live. I'm pissed I missed them when they were with Streetlight Manifesto.

Intransit
April 14th 2007


2797 Comments


I cannot imagine this being good. Saying Reel Big Fish is a great live band is the biggest mistruth told on the site. They do nothing but talk incessantly about stupid crap between songs and I dunno who gave these douches the idea that they were funny, but someone needs to tell them otherwise.

Good review, although I don't think it is really an accurate reflection of the album.

Jom
Staff Reviewer
April 14th 2007


2688 Comments


Nice review, dude. I've only heard Why Do They Rock So Hard? and liked a few songs off that, but that's the extent of my RBF knowledge so far.

craigy2
April 14th 2007


551 Comments


I wouldn't say Reel Big Fish talk incessantly between songs. True, they do talk a lot, more than most bands but not so much that it starts to detract from the music.

Intransit
April 14th 2007


2797 Comments


I found myself wickedly bored when I was waiting for MXPX to come on because they just sat there trying to make decent segues into songs and failing miserably. And not a single damn one of them can tell an honestly funny joke.

Zebra
Moderator
April 14th 2007


2647 Comments


When I saw them live they played five different versions of "S.R." Reel Big Fish played for about an hour and a half while Streetlight only played about six songs.
Your review was good however I just happen to disagree with it.


Intransit
April 14th 2007


2797 Comments


yeah, Streetlight barely played anything which was dissappointing. Sucks that they are touring again this summer with RBF, but with Less than Jake and Against All Authority supporting.

magicfidi
May 31st 2007


3 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

@intransit
just because it´s not your kind of humour doesn´t mean that they´re actually not funny!

and yes, they ARE a damn good live band for anyone who is interested in ska!

Intransit
August 6th 2007


2797 Comments


No, they fucking suck. It's okay though, you can be wrong.

descendents1
August 6th 2007


702 Comments


They kept me moderately entertained. I thought Less Than Jake was sensational.

tinathefatlard
August 6th 2007


1600 Comments


Actually, she's famous now is refering Gwen Stefani's relationship with No Doubt's bassist and how he broke it off, but now "she's famous".

craigy2
August 7th 2007


551 Comments


okay, i didn't know that but on the album aaron does try to claim that it was about him having a relationship with gwen

PhoenixRising
August 7th 2007


277 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

Good album. Good live band IMO too. If you're that pissed off because they're making jokes between song you might be a little high strung. Have another drink next time.This Message Edited On 08.07.07

Tacofish
February 6th 2008


4 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

I think this is the redeeming album for them to me. I never really liked them until I heard this, great album.

PanasonicYouth
October 7th 2008


7412 Comments


Their cover of Unity is freaking awesome. Just saying.

upagainstthewall
October 8th 2008


838 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

I love this! It makes me happy
I need more of this "schtick" or wateva

This Message Edited On 02.24.09

AmbassadorGold
May 10th 2010


9 Comments


@intransit
Pompous blowhards like you are what bring down the credibility of of sites like sputnikmusic. Like a lot of other users on this site, you cannot even make a real argument; you like to throw around conclusions like "this band is unoriginal" without any valid premises to back them. However, in this thread you do have the premise "I found myself wickedly bored" to back up the conclusion "they fucking suck." Assuming that your personal opinion is fact commits the fallacy of hasty generalization, making the validity of your argument the biggest mistruth on this page. You say nothing about the actual music, which is actually quite good. The vocal and guitar harmonies are great, Aaron's training as a metal guitarist shines through the usual ska/punk monotony, and Matt is an awesome bassist. Lastly, their self-critical satire about being a one hit wonder is high comedy. I'd expect such an active user to notice this, but you've convinced me you know nothing about music.

JWT155
September 5th 2010


9300 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

Seeing RBF live for free here at college in about 2 weeks, can't wait.

cwmetalguy1986
September 7th 2010


185 Comments


I thought I was the only one with an Evil Dead avatar!



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





FAQ // STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2014 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Privacy Policy