Yoko Ono
Yes, I'm A Witch


4.0
excellent

Review

by Nick Butler EMERITUS
February 21st, 2007 | 20 replies | 7,109 views


Release Date: 2007 | Tracklist

Review Summary: Yoko Ono's new effort, early front-runner for 2007's best album? You better believe it.

Let's turn the clock back 5 years. Imagine I've just told you that the new Yoko Ono album has recieved a lot of critical acclaim. Imagine I've told you that it features such cult heroes as Cat Power, DJ Spooky, Steven Wilson, and members of The Flaming Lips, Public Enemy, The Apples In Stereo, and Spiritualized. And imagine I've told you that it's an electronica album that is genuinely funky and sexy.

LET'S SEND FOR THE FUNNY FARM GUYS

Amazingly, it's 2007, and Yoko Ono is suddenly hot property. There's something beautiful about that for me personally; I've long maintained the opinion that Yoko Ono was just about the best thing that happened to John Lennon, save Paul McCartney, and that the hate aimed at her by the masses is ignorant bull***. Now, it seems, the tide is turning, and people are beginning to agree with me. Or, at the very least, they're giving Yoko a chance.

Yes, I'm A Witch (what a title!) is a remix album, with a twist. While the essential premise is typical, in that artists have been called in to remix old Yoko Ono songs, Ono has been involved in every stage of the process, so it's actually more along the lines of a duets album. So it's only natural to expect that this will sound much like another Ono studio album, and that it will probably be as inconsistent and frustrating as most remix albums (and most duets albums, for that matter). The truth is much the opposite.

While much has been made of the fact that Ono's had control over the project, it's undeniable that each of these remixes bears the imprint of the artist making the guest appearance. In fact, in nearly every case, these songs could have slipped easily into studio albums by the artists in question; a feeling helped by the fact that nearly every remix here uses only the vocals from the original. Observe Le Tigre's low-budget electro take on the feminist tract "Sisters O Sisters", or Steven Wilson's atosmpheric, mostly acoustic "Death of Samantha", which sounds like a Blackfield track, and it even uses the same vocal filter Wilson's so fond of using on Porcupine Tree material. The Peaches take on "Kiss Kiss Kiss" is as spastic and agressively sexual as the rest of her stuff (only it's better). DJ Spooky renders "Rising" as a bass-heavy dubby funk workout, using Ono's original avant-garde vocal almost as he might use a theremin riff, making the entire thing little short of a trip-hop masterpiece. "Toy Boat" features the unmistakable vocals of Antony Hegarty, and has the same sense of grace and gentle melody as he's become famous for, even if the music - more electronic that Antony & The Johnsons fans will be used to from him - does vaguely suggest Enya. And so on. The Flaming Lips even slap their trademark distorted drums behind a melody they've described as 'Ornette Coleman-esque' on "Cambridge 1969/2007", and used a bass ostinato reminiscent of "It Overtakes Me", from 2006's At War With The Mystics. In her collaboration with The Brother Brothers (never heard of them before, sadly), she's even created a stomping, swaggering hard rock beast of a song that re-interprets her vocal from 1974's A Story as a statement of intent as persuasive as any, as Ono casually states her case thusly:

Yes, I'm a witch,
I'm a bitch
I dont care what you say,
My voice is real.
My voice speaks truth,
I dont fit in your ways.

Im not gonna die for you,
You might as well face the truth,
Im gonna stick around for quite a while.

Perhaps annoying to read in print, but you'd better believe it's convincing on record.

Even I, an Ono supporter who enjoys the stuff he's heard of her catalogue of work, am shocked by how good this record is. It's just about everything you could ask for from an album - diverse, cohesive, and without a single weak point. If anything here does slip in quality, it's Jason Pierce's "Walking On Thin Ice" - a track that doesn't bode well for the new Spiritualized album. Still, it almost slips by un-noticed. Nobody here is phoning their performance in, and at times you really get the feeling that everybody involved thinks that they're part of something special here. Perhaps, that's where Ono's control over the project manifests itself most tellingly. Hopefully, the results here will lead to a re-assessment of Ono's work, or at least the acknowledgement that her own half of Plastic Ono Band was a watershed moment in the history of female artists in rock music.

Ono fans need it, fans of any of these artists need it, and anyone with an interest with electronica should be compelled to track it down too, content in the knowledge that the album strikes an impressive balance between eradicating the avant-garde tendencies of the original material and making it accessible for a new audience, without sacrificing the sense of wide-eyed experimentation that makes the best avant-garde music so thrilling. It's a wonderful album, what more can I say?



Recent reviews by this author
Krzysztof Penderecki and Jonny Greenwood Krzysztof Penderecki / Jonny GreenwoodLana Del Rey Paradise
Scott Walker Bish BoschEmilie Autumn Fight Like A Girl
Susanne Sundfor The Silicone VeilPepe Deluxe Queen of the Wave
user ratings (15)
Chart.
3.1
good

Comments:Add a Comment 
La Revolucion
February 21st 2007



1060 Comments


I ate a really gross tasting thing the first time I listened to Yoko, so now every time I hear her I taste that gross thing again. So yeah. Good review.

Iai
Emeritus
February 21st 2007



3553 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

I did the same thing with Diamanda Galas. Weird, isn't it?

Iluvatar
Staff Reviewer
February 21st 2007



16088 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

Good review etc, I usually hate Yoko but this is pleasantly cool. One of the better remix albums I've heard.

La Revolucion
February 21st 2007



1060 Comments


I did the same thing with Diamanda Galas. Weird, isn't it?

Yeah it creeps me out. I think I'll listen to this sometime.

Iai
Emeritus
February 21st 2007



3553 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

What was your thing? Mine was some Stilton cheese that I didn't realise had gone off. It caused to spend a fairly long time telling people her voice had the ability to curdle milk.

Doonothing
February 21st 2007



121 Comments


this sounds reasonably tight. It's cool that it has the apples in stereo and flaming lips on it.

La Revolucion
February 21st 2007



1060 Comments


A fast food breakfast sandwich that wasn't fully cooked.

Iai
Emeritus
February 21st 2007



3553 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

The Apples in Stereo track is deliciously psychedelic.

Kaleid
February 22nd 2007



711 Comments


I've read loads of reviews on this (though of course I only trust Sputnik's) ;) and they all agree that this a very accomplished, sexy record.

Yoko Ono was just about the best thing that happened to John Lennon

I think the reason loads of people would disagree with that is because they look at it from a domestic rather than musical viewpoint (which is stupid). I'll definitely get this. Brill review :thumb:

The Jungler
February 22nd 2007



4827 Comments


This sounds pretty cool and I think I have similar enough tastes with you that I may end up liking this as well. If I ever listen to it, that is.
Good job on the review.

Cesar
February 22nd 2007



2732 Comments


I might get flamed for this, but I swear the human on the cover of this album has a striking resemblance to Michael Jackson.

Sepstrup
February 22nd 2007



1563 Comments


Nah, just the glasses.

Neoteric
February 22nd 2007



3243 Comments


I think of fried rice when I listen to Modest Mouse.

Exquisite review sir.

Iai
Emeritus
February 22nd 2007



3553 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

I can see the Jacko thing. But could you imagine him releasing an album called Yes, I'm a Noseless Freak? Eh?

Kaleid
February 22nd 2007



711 Comments


:lol: That could be a b-side

MrKite
February 22nd 2007



5020 Comments


striking resemblance to Michael Jackson.

At first glance that's who I thought it was.

sgrevs
February 23rd 2007



698 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

Wow, I can't believe she's done tracks with the Sleepy Jackson, Polyphonic Spree, Anthony Hegarty, etc. Impressive lineup, maybe I should check this out. The only Yoko Ono song I've currently heard is the original 'Walking On Thin Ice', which to be honest, downright sucks, yet is still hilarious. Maybe I'll check this.

Hebrew Hammer
February 23rd 2007



37 Comments


"Perhaps annoying to read in print, but you'd better believe it's convincing on record."

Somehow I'm not convinced.

emerson2
February 23rd 2007



31 Comments


Wow I was definitely thinking the exact same thing about Michael Jackson.

Doppelganger
February 25th 2007



3124 Comments


Good review.

I'm not really interested in the album, but I must get the track with Steven Wilson. Immediately.



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





FAQ // STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2014 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Privacy Policy