Muse
Black Holes and Revelations


3.0
good

Review

by Ed Watson USER (26 Reviews)
December 31st, 2006 | 20 replies | 4,118 views


Release Date: 2006 | Tracklist

Review Summary: Unfortunately, Matt Bellamy is mad as well as inspired, meaning this album is marred by excessiveness and potentially great songs become merely good.

6 of 6 thought this review was well written

Matt Bellamy is mad. There is simply no other explanation for it. I simply can't see any other reason for the end lyric to Knights of Cydonia, the whole of Exo Politics and the bizzareness of City of Delusion and Hoodoo. But does this madness create a classic which sane men could not even contemplete creating, or does it get in the way of what is striving to be good music, coming across as self indulgence?

Well, both in fact. The opener, Take a Bow, is a pretty good piece of evidence for both cases. The synth strains which open it are glorious, soaring out of the speakers and filling the room with the majestic. Bellamy's vocals are perfect, while Chris Wolestenhome and Dominic Howard support the case that they ashould get far more media attention for talent. Then, about the halfway mark, it just all goes up a level as far as insanity goes. Suddenly, the majestic synths are flying everywhere, theres a distorted guitar in the mix, the vocals sound demented, and come the final flourish, it just all feels a little bit too much.

This overkill almost wrecks some songs. Invincible is really rather touching and reassuring, until all those instruments (surf guitar, bass, organ, drums, vocals, some random noise I can't describe), which worked so well subdued, are made a little bit more prevalent and it all becomes a mess. The outro and solo are just ludicrous. Starlight works so unbelievably well on the simple level, it's intro sounding so clean and shimmering. Then the ridiculous piano parts come in and yet again it all seems a bit much.

That is not to say that the madness does not sometimes work superbly. Knights of Cydonia, despite containing enough evidence to have the band placed in an asylum (especially considering its a single), works brilliantly. Starting off with galloping horses and lasers, its first half is reminiscient of 'The Good the Bad and the Ugly,' theme tune, whilst the second half with its demented 'No one's going to take me alive,' refrain, is pretty rousing. Exo Politics reins in the madness just enough to make the subversive riff bearable and provide the most convincing political argument this century (all our leaders are all aliens!).

And there is one song on here, 4 minutes of absolutely inspired genius. If it is indeed history that decides who is mad and who is a genius, the Bellamy must pray the future remembers Map of the Problematique. A twisting and turning journey through the human psyche, it creates monochrome images of despair through the perfect melding of edgy instrumentals, soaring melodies and superbly bleak lyrics. The drumming in particular stands out for keeping the song thrilling (imagine it doesn't change at the half way mark like that to see what I mean). That haunting keyboard during the chorus is the icing on the cake, which is for me one of the best songs of the decade.

Unfortunately, most of the rest of the album, despite being inventive, is slightly dull. Soldiers Poem is just a mistake, and once you've got your head around the mad moments, they seem to be kind of pointless (Super Massive Black Hole is an excellent example here). Band performances are amazing, and these are clearly top class musicians with an understanding of music. If only they'd restrain their obvious creative genius/madness so that the songs could shine through, they'd truly be in buisiness. As it is, we have an album of half inspired, half indulgent songs and one which truly shines out as being an absolute classic.



Recent reviews by this author
Hexes White Noise/Black SoundBloc Party A Weekend in the City
Iron Maiden PowerslaveStone Sour Come What(ever) May
Iron Maiden Fear of the DarkIron Maiden Seventh Son of a Seventh Son
user ratings (3131)
Chart.
3.7
great
other reviews of this album
1 of

Comments:Add a Comment 
Electric City
Staff Reviewer
December 31st 2006



15727 Comments

Album Rating: 2.5

Pretty good review, you hit my beefs with this album. Some of it is ridiculous, and some of it is so ridiculous it works. You nailed KOC.

I would be so bold as to call this one of your best reviews.

Digging: Alvvays - Alvvays

mynameischan
Staff Reviewer
December 31st 2006



17920 Comments

Album Rating: 2.5

Yeah good review but this album kinda sucks.

Two-Headed Boy
December 31st 2006



4527 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Do you dare, Electric City?!?

Yeah same here. Though I like this a tad more than you guys do.

northerncomfort
December 31st 2006



106 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

Thanks Electric City. I feel like this ones alright, so its good to think someone agrees.

Thanks for comments.

iarescientists
December 31st 2006



5863 Comments


I would appreciate it if you would stop writing reviews, because then I could feel like less of a lazy asshole.

jk, keep writing because I really can't feel like any more of a lazy assholeThis Message Edited On 12.31.06

northerncomfort
December 31st 2006



106 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

I've got mild insomnia at the moment, so it keeps me entertained. I'll stop if you wish.

iarescientists
December 31st 2006



5863 Comments


No, don't let me hold you down. Do whatever you want.

Hatshepsut
December 31st 2006



1997 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

Yeah I agree with your rating. Solid review.

Two-Headed Boy
December 31st 2006



4527 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Review stuff that needs a review, though.

northerncomfort
December 31st 2006



106 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

There are a few aren't there. I felt that the other 3 one didn't really do that great a job, so i figured I'd try and profer this.

mynameischan
Staff Reviewer
December 31st 2006



17920 Comments

Album Rating: 2.5

The singles are great but everything else on this album is pretty lackluster. Everyone drools over Map of the Problematique but I never thought it was good.

MrKite
December 31st 2006



5020 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

This is a tad boring. I'm not sad I lost it.

Values Here
December 31st 2006



3 Comments

Album Rating: 2.0

Worse Muse album by far. The up tempo songs barely keep my attention and are decent but the slow ones are boring and crap.

Chilly-Bean-Bop
December 31st 2006



344 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

I dunno, I thought it was a good album. But their others are better.

kyle666
January 1st 2007



24 Comments


good review

Clunge
January 1st 2007



32 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

Good, well reasoned review, despite how much I disagree.

I'm a diehard Muse fan. They've been my favourite band for the last 5/6 years and it's only now that they've finally exploded with an album of outrageously over-the-top music.

Black Holes And Revelations is the album I've been waiting for from Muse, and seeing as it took three years to create their shortest album to date, they need to cram a lot of insanity inot a short space of time.

Take A Bow, Supermassive Black Hole, Map Of The Problematique, Assassin, City Of Delusion and Knights Of Cydonia are all extraordinary songs in my view though I will admit the album is let down by some real duff tracks (Invincible and Exo-Politics especially).

I just really hope Muse can continue creating 'sillier' music so to speak, rather than their more serious overblown work found on Absolution.

So yeah, great album, let down by a few blips (how Invincible made the cut, I do not know...).

And again, good review :].This Message Edited On 01.01.07This Message Edited On 01.01.07

wikuk
January 7th 2007



1110 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Your description of Map of the Problematique was awesome, and agreed, it is one of the best songs they ever made (for me, it stands at the second place, with Bliss just a tad higher)

Altmer
July 30th 2007



5652 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

I used to think the same thing, but this album is just amazing actually. It's unbelievable. Such a grower, this one.

Starlight is awesome, Map of the Problematique is just killer, Take A Bow is really cool, Assassin sounds like it came out of a Dream Theater jam session (which for me is bonus points ++), Exo-Politics, Knights of Cydonia... yeah. this album is a best.

astrel
July 30th 2007



2614 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Soldier's Poem alone drags this album down a bit.

Altmer
July 30th 2007



5652 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Yeah worst song on the album.



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





FAQ // STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2013 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Privacy Policy