User
Reviews 22 Approval 81%
Soundoffs 334 News Articles 5 Band Edits + Tags 348 Album Edits 248
Album Ratings 5648 Objectivity 81%
Last Active 03-22-22 12:57 am Joined 11-04-12
Review Comments 11,372
| Most Overrated Album Ever Round 4 [VOTING CLOSED]
Randomized. Just pick the most logical choices ffs. | 1 | | Green Day Dookie
WINNER. Defeated: Nirvana - Nevermind by 3 votes (17 vs 20) | 2 | | Arctic Monkeys Whatever People Say I Am, That's What...
WINNER. Defeated: Deafheaven - Sunbather by 3 votes (15 vs 12) | 3 | | AC/DC Back in Black
WINNER. Defeated: Gn'R - Appetite for Fans' Money by 5 votes (11 vs 16) | 4 | | The Strokes Is This It
WINNER. Defeated: Weezer's most overrated album by 7 votes (13 vs 6) | 5 | | Tool Lateralus
Lmao
PistolPete, Yotimi, DoofusWainwright, guitarded_chuck, 731 | 6 | | Radiohead Kid A
Pretty much
TheMrAlexK, worthlessscab | 7 | | Hello Kitty Suicide Club ^_^
The idea of electronic meets grindcore sounds badass but nothing can beat the badassery of Agoraphobic Nosebleed's second disc of Altered States of America so yeah this probably is overrated
ArsMoriendi, onionbubs, trve -5x | |
claygurnz
04.06.16 | 2 4 5 7 | Jasdevi087
04.06.16 | "I don't think I could bring myself to vote anymore..."
I'll take one for the team then, 2 3 6 8 | CaimanJesus
04.06.16 | 2 | ArsMoriendi
04.06.16 | 8 | porcupinetheater
04.06.16 | 1, 3, 6, 7 | wtferrothorn
04.07.16 | 6, 7 | Ryus
04.07.16 | dookie
sunbather
back in black | AlexKzillion
04.07.16 | Dookie
Sunbather
Back In Black | PistolPete
04.07.16 | None, it's Lateralus. | AlexKzillion
04.07.16 | Dookie
Sunbather
Back In Black
Kid A | Supercoolguy64
04.07.16 | nevermind
dookie
pink
never listened to the rest | wham49
04.07.16 | it is hard to decide because some of these are terrible, and I think not high enough regarded to be overrated, however I will stick to Nevermind being the most overrated piece of shit of all time, man does it sound dated, and I listen to mostly 70's and earlier music | riffariffic7
04.07.16 | Dookie is easily the most overrated of these 8 selections. One of the most irritating albums I've ever endured listening to. Never understood the immediate universal praise that and American Idiot got (American Idiot is much worse than Dookie though IMO). | Danred97
04.07.16 | 2, 5, 6, 8 | Titan
04.07.16 | lol wham i may agree with you bro | ChoccyPhilly
04.07.16 | 1, 5 | wham49
04.07.16 | riff you are mostly right, but dookie was never thought of as the next coming of the Beatles, I will never forget the day cobain kicked it, kurt lauder (loder sorry)had the audacity to compare him to john lennon, I hate lennon, but cobain cant wipe lennon's ass | AngryJohnny
04.07.16 | 2, 3, 8 | letme69johndarnielle
04.07.16 | 1 3 5 7
really hard to choose between acdc and gnr, they both suck so fkin bad | Muisc4Life26
04.07.16 | 6,7,3,2
| ScuroFantasma
04.07.16 | I vote 1 | PattBraderson
04.07.16 | 2, 4, 6, 7 | PattBraderson
04.07.16 | 2, 4, 6, 7 | SharkTooth
04.07.16 | 4, 5, and 7 | lz41
04.07.16 | 8, 2
| Yotimi
04.07.16 | Back in Black
Lateralus | Supercoolguy64
04.07.16 | oh shit sorry didnt realize
nevermind | ArsMoriendi
04.07.16 | Can I vote for ^_^ by Hello Kitty Suicide Club? | Artuma
04.07.16 | dookie
arctic monkeys
ugh both kinda suck but appetite
is this it | hal1ax
04.07.16 | every opeth album | Cimnele
04.07.16 | 2 4 6 7
im impressed Sunbather is hanging with these heavyweight fave albums for people who don't like music | onionbubs
04.07.16 | 3 6 (though i'd want to vote for 5 as well honestly)
"Can I vote for ^_^ by Hello Kitty Suicide Club?" [2] | Avagantamos
04.08.16 | 1 3 5 7 | trve
04.08.16 | minus 5 votes for 11 | NordicMindset
04.08.16 | nevermind, back in black, appetite, is this it | Trebor.
04.08.16 | "I will stick to Nevermind being the most overrated piece of shit of all time, man does it sound dated, and I listen to mostly 70's and earlier music"
lol | Greem
04.08.16 | 3 | Asdfp277
04.08.16 | 1 and 5 | wham49
04.08.16 | totally get Ac/Dc, but not Dookie or Is This it, they are not a good albums, agreed, but who ever said they were | CaimanJesus
04.08.16 | The people who gave them a 4 and 4.2 average | wham49
04.08.16 | stupidity does not count as hype | Artuma
04.08.16 | i don't even know what sounds more stupid than ac/dc, tbqh | eaglefan1998
04.08.16 | Dookie
Sunbather
Appetite For Destruction | BenThatsMyJamin
04.08.16 | 3 | DoofusWainwright
04.08.16 | Competition has failed. None of these are that overrated lol
I'll say Arctic Monkeys and Tool as I don't really know the Kitty thing | guitarded_chuck
04.08.16 | Nevermind, Sunbather, Tool | doomjitsu
04.08.16 | 4
comment too short what the fuck sputnik | doomjitsu
04.08.16 | how the fuck BenThatsMyJamin's comment isn't too short then | BenThatsMyJamin
04.08.16 | ;) | BenThatsMyJamin
04.08.16 | You have much to learn | Zig
04.08.16 | 6 | Evreaia
04.08.16 | how the fuck did metallica not make this round? | Snowdog808
04.08.16 | 5
Also, Metallica doesn't become seriously overrated until the Black Album. | zakalwe
04.08.16 | If you slags actually had an ounce of rock 'n roll in your soul, could listen to music loud as fuck without mother telling you to turn it down and could have more than a slurp of whiskey without making a face like someone's pissing in your eyes you'd understand that 6 is classic. | wham49
04.08.16 | the black album is up there with nevermind as the most overrated in history.
anybody notice the period of time many of these have been made
black album
dookie
nevermind
appitite
radiohead
weezer
tool
| guitarded_chuck
04.08.16 | where do you see the black album
you mean back in black? | wham49
04.08.16 | in general, it was out there in discussion | zakalwe
04.08.16 | He's old dude it's his cataracts playing up | wham49
04.08.16 | it is Holden, i agree, but I have grown tired of it myself, definitely earns its acclaim | guitarded_chuck
04.08.16 | [883621891] | teamster
04.08.16 | 1 , 4 , 6 | NordicMindset
04.09.16 | Never mind, whatever people, back in black, is this it | Artuma
04.09.16 | you didn't count my votes | worthlessscab
04.09.16 | 1, 3, 6, 7, 10 | someguest
04.09.16 | dumbest list ever
LPFTW - Most Overrated Album Ever ∞ | H61
04.09.16 | Dookie
Appetite | Shuyin
04.09.16 | 1, 4 | jagride
04.09.16 |
| onionbubs
04.09.16 | nevermind | danielcardoso
04.09.16 | 3
6 | 731
04.09.16 | 24689 | LotusFlower
04.09.16 | 1 2 3 5 | someguest
04.09.16 | "You don't say someguest?"
*type | ArsMoriendi
04.09.16 | I'll vote for Dookie if it means ending this round | MercuryToHell
04.09.16 | I'm gonna stick my vote on Dookie, most of Green Day's discography is disproportionately looked on... | onionbubs
04.09.16 | neverminds more overrated than dookie | LotusFlower
04.09.16 | Oooh, my choice is on 1 then. |
|