KrazyKris: Ride The Lightning Vs. Master Of Puppets

KrazyKris 01.03.15	Expecting a bit hate for 10.
FlyheadMetal 01.03.15	Ride The Lightning easily
NeroCorleone80 01.03.15	RtL
chinesewhispers 01.03.15	MoP
thacoconut94 01.03.15	Ride the lightning 100% And justice for all >>>> though. 1 is defo 1
Artuma 01.03.15	mop 13 is 1, 12 is 2
KrazyKris 01.03.15	Yeah, thought that those two are too low for some. I'm just not too fond of instrumentals in general and while they are both really good work, I think they're too long for their own good.
JamieTwort 01.03.15	Prefer RTL these days but both a pretty similar in terms of quality. Both leagues ahead of Justice.
FlyheadMetal 01.03.15	Both leagues ahead of Justice. not really, AJFA is just as good
JamieTwort 01.03.15	Not really, it's not that good at all tbh.
DoctorDoom 01.03.15	Ride the Lightning by a mile.
FlyheadMetal 01.03.15	There is not a single bad song on AJFA
DoctorDoom 01.03.15	^^^^Agreed. Just jammed Blackened today.
Froot 01.03.15	MOP. Generally better paced and has more replay value.
CalculatingInfinity 01.03.15	Very happy to see some love for Trapped Under Ice, RTL is the winner for me.
Friday13th 01.03.15	I can't decide, love em both too much. I'd probably say RTL is a bit more consistent, but "Master" is my favorite song by them so it's not an easy choice.
KrazyKris 01.03.15	~Generally better paced and has more replay value.~ Don't know if I can agree with the first part. Both are amazing anyway, but I'd really say RTL seems more cohesive in it's raw energetic style. And it also has more of a flow (if that word fits any Metallica album) thanks to the more coherent themes and for me better placed songs. MOP seems way more thought through and is more precise, but somehow that track list is kind of weird. Also, thought of another question at hand: Best Metallica intro?
DoctorDoom 01.03.15	The riffs in RTL are their best and that is the deciding factor for me.
VinVal 01.03.15	i agree
Totengott 01.03.15	RtL easily. [2]
thacoconut94 01.03.15	Best Metallica intro goes to one
KrazyKris 01.03.15	The riffs in RTL are their best [2] Although I got to add, the almost universally perfect song lenghts are helpful too.
DoctorDoom 01.03.15	VinVal, I am Internet high hiving the shit out of you right now.
VinVal 01.03.15	followin all my posts bruh
DoctorDoom 01.03.15	Bruh, taste in music so hard I have to. YOU LEFT ME NO CHOICE.
TheSpirit 01.03.15	Ride the Lightning
Froot 01.03.15	Death Magnetic :^)
JohnTheSavage 01.03.15	I'd go with Ride the Lightning. Master of Puppets has a better track 5 and 6, making it superficially seem more consistent, but at least five of the tracks on Ride the Lightning are flawless, unimpeachable classics. Most of the tracks on Master of Puppets that aren't the first two are just very good.
KrazyKris 01.03.15	Can I disagree with "better track 5" please?????
JohnTheSavage 01.03.15	Well you clearly will because you put it as your number one song out of both albums : )
deathschool 01.03.15	Rust in Peace
AngryNeighbor 01.03.15	Master
Froot 01.03.15	Calculating Infinity
TalonsOfFire 01.03.15	I love RTL's dark atmosphere but MOP is slightly better because it's more progressive and some of the songs are slightly better than the RTL counterparts, namely Battery and Fire and Messiah and Escape. Their t/t, instrumentals, and ballads are about on par with each other.
forkliftjones 01.04.15	R.t.L all the way m/
tempest-- 01.04.15	puppetz
Supercoolguy64 01.04.15	mop > rtl imo
IronGiant 01.04.15	AJfA. but MoP i guess. Disposable Heroes stacks up against any RtL easily
FearThyEvil 01.04.15	RTL
Havey 01.07.15	mop is ass
Supercoolguy64 01.08.15	Disposable Heroes stacks up against any RtL easily [2]
KrazyKris 01.08.15	Nah
rockandmetaljunkie 01.08.15	RTL
hikingmetalpunk 01.08.15	rtl
VinVal 01.08.15	Rotfl