Emeritus
Reviews 64 Approval 99%
Soundoffs 58 News Articles 1 Band Edits + Tags 47 Album Edits 43
Album Ratings 1244 Objectivity 75%
Last Active 01-11-23 2:53 am Joined 03-17-12
Review Comments 1,169
| A Non-Ranking of Isis
It's simple: for each album, I'll try to sell you on why it's the best one in the discography. | 1 | | Isis Celestial
In the words of a friend, this album is unnecessarily angry — and that’s why, within Isis’ discography, this alone satisfies the deep itch for something heavy. This is your go-to for your primal urges, but it’s far from mindless pots-and-pans bashing — “Swarm Reigns”, in all its fury and feedback, has its moments where the sandstorm abates and reveals a glistening desert. “Collapse and Crush” does the slow trudge with its desperation amped up to 11, and its every release of tension feels more hard-earned because of that. Celestial is Isis at their meanest and sludgiest; none of that wishy-washy atmospheric stuff. Take a stance and stand with the screeches, the pummels, the post-apocalyptic transitions. | 2 | | Isis Oceanic
Never again will you hear such austere beauty. Oceanic swells patiently, but not too patiently (cough Panopticon cough) — from the haunting murmurs of “The Beginning and the End” to “Weight” and its careful layering, Oceanic suspends you in waves that crest in slow motion. But when they do crash, they come down with more force than its peers will ever muster. It’s not brute strength, but rather an elegant calculus of push-pull, repeat-renew, and I daresay that after Oceanic, this calculus has never again been applied as well. Oceanic is opaque, twisting, and perhaps mostly importantly, seductive — not just because of the excellent use of female vocals to play the yin to Aaron Turner’s yang, but in the way that it never unfurls completely. With every listen you want to pull it apart; but it resists, and eventually you become further entangled within. | 3 | | Isis Panopticon
Panopticon is sagely, maybe even the Zen master of all Isis albums. Those who find it sleepy simply fail to grasp the purpose of its slow journey — it takes the long roads precisely because there’s more to actually see. “Wills Dissolve” almost seems to open on a fairy-tale note, such are its gentle, chiming 3-note motifs; behind the guitar hovers the pale light of synthesizers, illuminating the soundscape. Think of each minute as diving deeper into the waters, letting your mind shut up as all your sensory organs are overtaken by the surrounding environment. In the end, Panopticon, more than any other Isis album, induces serenity, perhaps even a sense of wholeness. It blooms from the bottom of your heart. | 4 | | Isis In the Absence of Truth
"Garden of Light" -- need I say more? In all seriousness, I think this album is at risk of being characterised as scatterbrained, when in reality it's more of an intrepid explorer trekking in a mysterious dimension. In the Absence of Truth moves cautiously, judiciously, testing out new ground only when it feels that it's safe; but as a whole it's enveloped by an unusual air, intriguingly foreign. There's a pensive quality to its harmonies, a question mark with every measure, and these little mysteries embedded within the sprawling framework are what makes this album so rewarding in the end. And "Garden of Light", well, it's just too damn gorgeous -- tinged with Arabic influences, it's propelled by a jubilant energy, a resolution to every question raised previously. | 5 | | Isis Wavering Radiant
Wavering Radiant is a coruscating night sky. It's more light-filled and the most optimistic of its siblings, often soaring rather than brooding. It asserts itself confidently, almost as if it bore a relaxed grin, though "Hand of the Host" shows how a descent into darker, eerier territory is also supremely satisfying. And "20 Minutes/40 Years" -- how it peaks in such a heavenly way, a chorus of angelic background vocals swirling alongside jubilant guitar chords and synths that seem to radiate golden light. Wavering Radiant is for the victorious -- it carries triumph. It's also up to you to decide which force within it, dark or light, ultimately wins. | |
dbizzles
04.15.18 | Dude. What a great idea. Haven't read yet, but I'm intrigued.
B R B | dbizzles
04.15.18 | While Celestial is probably my favorite case you made, each album feels very evenly represented and when we are looking at a band with as contentious discography as the almighty ISIS, that is fucking impressive.
Your Oceanic wordplay is nothing less than tidal, btw. | clavier
04.15.18 | thank you dbiz, I'm wondering if my own preferences can be evinced through this list | dbizzles
04.15.18 | I forget your favorite and this didn't do me any favors, so, congrats. | Astral Abortis
04.15.18 | Dont do it darius is just pushing his ear infected agenda | Assemblage
04.15.18 | Wow, well done and great idea. Much better than the shitty rankings I do. | clavier
04.15.18 | in the future I'm gonna do the reverse for another band - argue why each album is the worst | Frippertronics
04.15.18 | will read | dbizzles
04.15.18 | Will it be a band you enjoy as much as ISIS? Or a band you despise with a tortuous familiarity? | clavier
04.15.18 | Haven't decided yet - we'll see. | TheSpaceMan
04.15.18 | Found myself reading all of this despite not even being big on the band. I'm not sure on your use of the word calculus though | clavier
04.15.18 | I myself am sure enough - "A particular method or system of calculation or reasoning."
thanks for reading though : ) | TheSpaceMan
04.15.18 | wasnt saying youre wrong lol ive just never seen it used that way | clavier
04.15.18 | oh, well, that usage usually pops in pretty niche circumstances (utilitarian calculus being the most common one I've seen) | TheSpaceMan
04.15.18 | interesting, i thought you could have been implying a focus on rate of change or something, which sorta made sense in context, but thanks for arming me with new vocabulary | LouBreed
04.15.18 | Do this for Nickelback | Relinquished
04.15.18 | good shit | ThyCrossAwaits
04.15.18 | Much better than me just ranking them (3, 4, 5, 2, 1 for the record). Great idea, super well-written. | Papa Universe
04.15.18 | my ranking of Isis:
1) Raqqa
2) Mosul
3) al-Qaim
4) Aleppo
5) Deir al-Zour
also, great write-ups, as always | Ocean of Noise
04.15.18 | The way you describe Panopticon is more like how I would describe In The Absence Of Truth tbh. Panopticon isn't a "zen" album for me - it's more the kind of meditation you're forced into, looking down at your city from an airplane and realizing how insignificant you are. Absence, on the other hand, inspires profound, complete meditation in its greatest moments.
Nevertheless, amazing list. I love this band to death. | clavier
04.15.18 | Ocean, I definitely see where you're coming from - the latter feels less held down to me, if that makes sense | Dedes
04.15.18 | I'm gonna break all this big discussion and say Garden of Light slaps DICK | Relinquished
04.15.18 | "looking down at your city from an airplane and realizing how insignificant you are."
panopticon is the best plane record yes, something about putting it on an hour before landing makes flying feel sexy | teamster
04.15.18 | Great work. Made a case for each and every album and I share a lot of these sediments. I do feel you could have mentioned “the bonus tracks” omitted from Wavering Radiant. You know which ones I am talking about. | Confessed2005
04.15.18 | Brilliant idea for a list. Very well written. | Space Jester
04.15.18 | “Made a case for each and every album and I share a lot of these sediments.”
I like to share my rocks with people too | CaimanJesus
04.15.18 | Nice | ThyCrossAwaits
04.16.18 | Come on jester, the list great and written with mineral mistakes... | Casavir
04.16.18 | You guys are full of schist. | clavier
04.16.18 | this comment section is a bedrock of humour | Dewinged
04.16.18 | Nice read as always Claire, miss these guys. | Sevengill
04.16.18 | agreed: every Isis album is the best. | DamnVanne
04.18.18 | Isis exemplifies what i really like about Sput. Most of the truly masterful artists dont make it past the fine teeth of taste filter. Thanks yall; Isis is certainly the greatest of all the things you hath provided | Sinternet
04.18.18 | now do Sawblade | Stakaline
04.18.18 | Garden of light is indeed the best thing ever | DamnVanne
04.18.18 | Oh wait i found a cd of absence of truth at work. This place is trash | JohnnyoftheWell
06.21.19 | Somehow missed this list, but it makes me very happy. Must do a discog jam soon... | iglu
06.21.19 | rank them you coward | teamster
06.22.19 | Nice read. |
|