Tyler.
09.09.17 | sweet trip
glassjaw
off minor
city of caterpillar
elliott smith
slint
duster
elvis costello
|
rodrigo90
09.09.17 | Acrobatic tennament is bleh... |
CygnusX1
09.09.17 | 16 and 19 are pretty legit 5s tho. 8 is a 4.9 |
TheSonomaDude
09.09.17 | ^agreed |
SandwichBubble
09.09.17 | I would've 5'd everything at 16. The world of music seemed so fresh then. |
butcherboy
09.09.17 | 10 all the way |
neekafat
09.09.17 | Bold As Love is worst Hendrix |
Winesburgohio
09.09.17 | i don't disagree!! 16, 19 and 10 remain favourites to this day!!! as do many others!!!! clearly you haven't read "The Winesburg canon" pamphlets i sent you all smh |
luci
09.09.17 | nice list, that circle takes the square album goes from mindblowing to quite embarrassing when you mature. these are albums i 5'd as a sixteen year old:
sing the sorrow
siren song for the counter culture
in the aeroplane over the sea
( )
as the roots undo
jane doe |
Valkoor952
09.09.17 | A lot of great stuff.
Glad you like 33 but suprises you have Humbug and FWN at a 2 when they are just as good in quality as WPSIAIWIN. FWN especially is a very nice continuation and may even be better than the debut. |
LethalPaintball
09.09.17 | my 5s are what id 5 at 16 |
Ryus
09.09.17 | 11, 15, 20, and 22 are deserving in my eyes
yeah i'm curious how my taste will mature as i grow up. it's already changed significantly ever since i started truly loving music when i was about 10 |
Gwyn.
09.09.17 | 21 and 16 are the love of my life
Also why would a Beethoven symphony be embarrassing to like what |
Tunaboy45
09.09.17 | 11 will always be a 5 |
Relinquished
09.09.17 | 32 is still nice |
UpwardSpiral
09.10.17 | sing the sorrow
I wish I had known this at 16 |
AsleepInTheBack
09.10.17 | You sir had, and continue to have, some damn good taste in music |
Winesburgohio
09.10.17 | to clarify: lots of these are still my favourite albums, with Laughing Stock reigning supreme as my favourite ever ever ever, fwiw |
AsleepInTheBack
09.11.17 | just discovered Laughing Stock yesterday, what a beaut of a record |
Allergist
09.11.17 | Some of these still are my 5's, so you would've been a 16 year old with excellent taste :) |
DoofusWainwright
09.11.17 | The following current Doof 5's have remained 5's since I was 16 (or before). ~The year - 1996~
Radiohead 'The Bends'
The The 'Infected'
The Stranglers 'Greatest Hits: 1977-1990'
Therapy? 'Troublegum'
Metallica 'Master of Puppets'
NIN 'Downward Spiral'
Tricky 'Maxinquaye'
Nirvana 'Nevermind'
Nirvana 'In Utero'
Smashing Pumpkins 'Siamese Dream'
One's I would have 5'd then but not now:
Korn 'Korn' (Current Rating: 3.5)
Tool 'Aenima' (CR: 4)
Pumpkins 'Mellon Collie' (CR: 4.5)
Manics 'Holy Bible' (CR: 4.5)
Fear Factory 'Demanufacture' (CR: 4)
Sepultura 'Chaos AD' (CR: 4)
RATM 'RATM' (CR: 3.5)
FNM 'Angel Dust' (CR: 4.5)
FNM 'The Real Thing' (CR: 4)
Portishead 'Dummy' (CR: 4.5)
Pride & Glory 'Pride & Glory' (CR: 3.5)
AIC 'Jar of Flies' (CR: 4.5)
White Zombie 'Astro-Creep: 2000' (CR: 3)
Pearl Jam 'Vitalogy' (CR: 4.5)
STP 'Purple' (CR: 4.5)
So generally I still like my 16 year old taste for the most part. |
onionbubs
09.11.17 | my 5s from 16 are my current 5s
heh |
