GreyShadow
02.03.20 | love all of these to death. I really don't have even a minor problem with any of these songs at this point in my life. La Dispute's best work by and far. It's truly one of the greatest accomplishments in post-hardcore and musical storytelling
for context, Bitter Fruit and above are all 10/10 |
mynameischan
02.03.20 | i don't think i could take king park out of the 1 spot, and i'd definitely have st. paul higher, but this is a good ranking overall |
JohnnyoftheWell
02.03.20 | Disagree with a lot of this, especially a Departure and Hometown being that low and Bruised Bodies and Poem being as high as they are, but the album is gold and 4, 3 and 1 are all great so no real complaints ;] |
ian b
02.03.20 | 3 is still 1 for me but yeah those last two tracks are criminally underrated, also Edit Your Hometown and Bitter Fruit deserve better smh |
JohnnyoftheWell
02.04.20 | Edit Your Hometown is such a tasty banger |
ian b
02.04.20 | such a fun song to cover live, and the only LD song i'd ever play live except maybe "How I Feel" from the TA split |
GreyShadow
02.04.20 | Edit Your Hometown and Bitter Fruit are still 10/10.
St Paul admittedly does the least for me out of all of this but I still love it. |
Larkinhill
02.04.20 | Safer in the Forest, Edward Benz and King Park are my top 3. A Departure, St Paul Missionary and The Most Beautiful Bitter Fruit are up there too. |
Tikicobra
02.04.20 | I disagree with this ranking but agree that this album fucking rocks. One of my few high school album obsessions that I think still really holds up. |
cold
02.04.20 | 14. St. Paul Missionary Church Blues
13. A Broken Jar
12. A Departure
11. Harder Harmonies
10. Edit Your Hometown
9. A Letter
8. Safer In The Forest/Love Song For Poor Michigan
7. A Poem
6. All Our Bruised Bodies And The Whole Heart Shrinks
5. You And I In Unison
4. The Most Beautiful Bitter Fruit
3. Edward Benz, 27 Times
2. King Park
1. I See Everything |
NordicMindset
02.04.20 | St Paul is top 5 |
neekafat
02.04.20 | unpopular opinion but 6 is the only one i come back to here |
Sniff
02.04.20 | Too few DARLINGS on this |
SteakByrnes
02.04.20 | Can't stand this band, I could never get into the vocal delivery and the instrumental work bored me |
cold
02.04.20 | Then why comment, steakyboi |
SteakByrnes
02.04.20 | Because I WANT to like this band :[ |
cold
02.04.20 | Well then, just do. Can't go wrong with their Touche Amore split. |
widowslaugh123
02.04.20 | Can’t really listen to this band anymore but every 1-2 years I pop on King Park to remember what it’s like to feel |
Comatorium.
02.04.20 | 3 is 1 |
SlothcoreSam
02.09.20 | looks like fun |
ian b
06.16.20 | okay coming back to this list, the top 3 are absolutely spot on, but a Departure and Bitter Fruit deserved better fffffff especially over 6 and 5 imho |
GreyShadow
06.16.20 | i cannot stress this enough, Bitter Fruit is one of my favorite songs in the world. this album is just that good |
ian b
06.16.20 | yeah tbh i commend you heaps for making this list, i would do the same but copying would just be a lil grimey in my opinion, anyways good ranking nonetheless even if i dont agree with some placements ! |
GreyShadow
06.16.20 | thanks!!! and i love seeing other rankings so i'd be very cool with you making your own |
ian b
06.16.20 | hmm i would rank this album, but i mayhaps do what you did with La Dispute's discog and do that with their other half aka Touche Amore because i know their music like the back of my hand lol |
Snake.
06.16.20 | 11 is 1 |
furpa
06.16.20 | Solid list, despite me not agreeing with a number of picks here. Loved reading it either way though!
Edward Benz, 27 Times is an easy #1 for me though, and probably my favourite La Dispute song altogether to be honest. |
ian b
06.16.20 | ed benz deserves a top 5 at the very least, and 11 is far from 1 snake but i do agree it is one of the best here. the storytelling and progression is impeccable besides the fact that it becomes increasingly predictable as the song progresses |
Larkinhill
06.16.20 | Safer in the Forest, King Park and Edward Benz are top 3 |
cold
06.16.20 | Where's your Panorama list |
dedex
06.16.20 | St Paul Missionary Baptist Church Blues #14 wat |
Larkinhill
06.16.20 | St Paul Missionary Baptist Church Blues #14 wat (2)
Where's your Panorama list (2)
But I would personally have a really difficult time ranking that album as it’s incredibly consistent.
|
GreyShadow
06.16.20 | if i haven't yet stressed this enough, this is my favorite album of all time probably lol. If anything, I See Everything might have grown on me even harder recently and yeah, lemme do Panorma, I think I can confidently rank that now |
