JamieTwort
07.21.13 | Top 3 are pretty much interchangeable. |
Keyblade
07.21.13 | damn nice top 10 man. great to see love for 10 |
JamieTwort
07.21.13 | In before "where the fuck is The Moor?", "no BWP = fail" etc. |
JamieTwort
07.21.13 | Thanks Key. |
Keyblade
07.21.13 | no but seriously where's The Moor :D |
JamieTwort
07.21.13 | Somewhere outside my top 10 :D |
NeroCorleone80
07.21.13 | These would all be on mine except 2,6 and 10 |
Keyblade
07.21.13 | 6 would make a top 15-20 for me |
thumbcrusher
07.21.13 | where's Demon of the Fall :D :D
be if i'm honest that would be my no. 1 |
Tyrael
07.21.13 | Black Rose Immortal is my definite n.1 but it's nice to see people catching onto how amazing 2 is |
Artuma
07.21.13 | where the fuck is The Moor?
no BWP = fail
:D |
JamieTwort
07.21.13 | lol |
JamieTwort
07.21.13 | @thumb: Demon is probably only my 5th favourite on MAYH.
@Tyrael: I love Black Rose Immortal but I definitely prefer the 3 Morningrise tracks on here. Black Rose has some amazing parts but feels quite disjointed at some points. |
thumbcrusher
07.21.13 | well i guess 5th on MAYH isn't so bad, it's a pretty good album... |
Artuma
07.21.13 | tbh none of these would be on my top 10 except maybe 1 |
JamieTwort
07.21.13 | "well i guess 5th on MAYH isn't so bad, it's a pretty good album..."
No it's not bad at all. It would still easily make my top 20. |
geasoftime
07.21.13 | no In The Mist She Was Standing? I just don't know if I can sign off on this list without that song |
JamieTwort
07.21.13 | @Art: Yeah I excepted quite a few people to feel that way about this list. |
JamieTwort
07.21.13 | "no In The Mist She Was Standing? I just don't know if I can sign off on this list without that song"
In The Mist narrowly missed out, that song's probably my 3rd favourite on Orchid. |
Nagrarok
07.21.13 | First three albums win, nice list. Ghost Reveries and Heritage are both great but I've never really gotten into them as much as most of their other work. The majority of this would make my own top 10 or 15; I agree Black Rose is disjointed in places but it's probably still my number 2 off Morningrise, after Advent. And yeah, I'd also include The Moor and Blackwater Park ;) |
JamieTwort
07.21.13 | Their first three albums are the best, agreed. Personally I prefer both Ghost Reveries (partly for sentimental reasons) and Heritage over everything from Still Life - Damnation, although this particular list is about the songs of course, not the albums. I've never liked The Moor or BWP (song) as much as everyone else seems to for some reason, same goes for their respective albums. |
Permabanned
07.21.13 | agree with a lot of this but needs more orchid, forest of october hard, also nectar |
JohnnyoftheWell
07.21.13 | I agree with 9 and 3, and it's nice to be reminded that at least someone on the site has a distinctive opinion |
BigPleb
07.21.13 | HARD props for 6. |
Vakarian12
07.21.13 | nice choices |
JamieTwort
07.21.13 | Thanks guys.
"agree with a lot of this but needs more orchid, forest of october hard, also nectar"
Both Forest of October and In the Mist narrowly missed out. Nectar rules as well but is my least favourite on Morningrise. |
Paracletus96
07.21.13 | April Ethereal [123412] |
Mike08
07.21.13 | 1, 5, 8 would be on my list too.
- I like Godhead's Lament more than The Moor |
JamieTwort
07.21.13 | ^Me too actually. |
ProfessorVeerappan
07.21.13 | fucking crazy indeed the songs give above are indeed quiet crazy good list
...
after ages again someone came back home to Opeth.... |
Avagantamos
07.21.13 | Blackwater Park is not even on here at all. April Ethereal rules though |
somnolence
07.21.13 | when'ss |
JamieTwort
07.21.13 | "Blackwater Park is not even on here at all."
Well observed. |
Instez
07.21.13 | April Ethereal yesssssss |
Permabanned
07.21.13 | Blackwater Park is not even on here at all [3]
hail truth |
NeroCorleone80
07.21.13 | The title track is the only song from BWP thats worthy of top 10 |
JamieTwort
07.21.13 | And even that's not worthy. |
MikeC26
07.21.13 | The Leper Afinity m/ |
MikeC26
07.21.13 | Pretty bad list imo |
JamieTwort
07.21.13 | lol, The Leper Affinity bores the hell out of me if I'm honest. |
InfamousGrouse
07.21.13 | major props for including beneath the mire, such an underrated track.
and for rating advent so highly m/ |
NeroCorleone80
07.21.13 | Survey the Slooooooooopes |
TheSpaceMan
07.21.13 | Drapery Falls? |
Underflow
07.21.13 | Any Heritage song in a top 10 Opeth list |
Avagantamos
07.21.13 | "The title track is the only song from BWP thats worthy of top 10"
exactly what I meant |
Permabanned
07.21.13 | No devious queefwhines in your list |
facupm
01.02.14 | yeah april ethereal dude but where's the moor??? |
jtswope
01.02.14 | Yeah man where's the Moor?? :D
But seriously haha |
jtswope
01.02.14 | Good list though |
JamieTwort
01.02.14 | The Moor drags :/ |
Solaire
01.02.14 | Glad Morningrise is getting hard love on this list. |
Shuyin
01.02.14 | yea, wheres the fucking moor?? |
Solaire
01.02.14 | I would have included Wreath. |
facupm
01.02.14 | still april ethereal is awesome so cant complain, but i would include the moor and leper affinity |
jmnewcomer18
01.02.14 | No Still Life jamz? :( Good list tho |
JamieTwort
01.02.14 | "I would have included Wreath."
This is top 10 best not worst ;) |
JamieTwort
01.02.14 | I don't like Still Life anywhere near as much as most people seem to. |
Artuma
01.02.14 | it's their best (pretty easily imo) but i know your taste and every opeth song is good (except wreath, seriously their weakest song) so i'm fine with the list |
Hawks
01.02.14 | Still Life is an easy 4.5, but it's like 4th best Opeth for me. |
ButteryBiscuitBass
01.02.14 | I pretty much agree with this apart from 6. As much as I enjoy heritage nothing off that album is top tier opeth imo. |
JamieTwort
01.02.14 | Damn dude, Haxprocess might even be top 5 material for me now, gets better everytime. |
ButteryBiscuitBass
01.02.14 | Def loving the inclusion of 9 tho. Not enough love for that one round these parts. |
JamieTwort
01.02.14 | Morningrise is so good. |
Necrotica
01.02.14 | Fuckyeah, props for putting To Bid You Farewell on here |
JamieTwort
01.02.14 | m/ |
facupm
01.02.14 | damn forgot bwp thats top5 too |
Necrotica
01.02.14 | That's 'cause he isn't a big fan of Still Life and onward, with the exception of Ghost Reveries and Heritage. At least from what I remember. Leper Affinity's still my favorite Opeth song though, but I'm glad that there's nothing from Damnation or Deliverance here; very refreshing |
demigod!
01.02.14 | 9 5 3 m/
dont get the love for 1 though |
facupm
01.02.14 | leper affinity rules yeah
as far as i know pre-still life opeth era is jamie's favorite so that explains |
Underflow
01.02.14 | Not at all how I'd rank it, but interesting. |
Cal665
01.19.14 | Good to see opeth's earlier work being appreciated but I would have like to have seen something from Still life or Blackwater park at least the leper affinity |
Emyay
03.19.14 | 5 9 and 10 m/
better than your pt list at least |
mandan
04.08.14 | 7 is becoming one of my personal faves.
Bump because list rules. |
NeroCorleone80
04.08.14 | 7 is the best song on Orchid |
L4titudes
04.08.14 | that's a good number 1 to have |