SeaAnemone
05.16.10 | if you're gonna be a good-for-nothing attention-whore, at least back your arguments up a little and try to come off as semi-intelligent. list is null. |
SeaAnemone
05.16.10 | yeah because even the ones I totally agree with just sound dumb as it is now. |
AliW1993
05.16.10 | what SeaAnemone said |
WithHorsesInHerEyes
05.16.10 | Most of these albums ARE, but there is a reason they are. It's because they're good. And Ozzy sucks? You must be musically retarded. |
Prolapse
05.16.10 | You might as well say every bit of music ever is over rated. List sucks. You suck cock. Deal with it. And what's with the Enrique Iglesias picture? |
WithHorsesInHerEyes
05.16.10 | You ranked Brokencyde as a 5. Lawl. |
maidenpmcc
05.16.10 | Some guy has guts lol. |
Prolapse
05.16.10 | He's just a douche troll |
PearlDrummer20
05.16.10 | I only agree with you on 5 and 6. 1, 4, 11, 13, 14, and 19 deserve the praise. Just because something is popular doesn't mean it's overrated. |
Prophet178
05.16.10 | You fail at trolling. |
Dryden
05.16.10 | agree with 1 |
robertsona
05.16.10 | 10 and 5 are fairly amazing
i love 2 to death
1 is great |
MUNGOLOID
05.16.10 | shitty list
shitty troll |
PearlDrummer20
05.16.10 | Obvious troll is obvious. Proof: look at his ratings pie chart. |
AnotherBrick
05.16.10 | ya dude you suck |
Motiv3
05.16.10 | agreed with 10,14 and 19. Korn isnt even overrated on this site lolwut. |
AnotherBrick
05.16.10 | you should just delete this m/ |
greg84
05.16.10 | Hmm. This list is a complete failure. |
Prolapse
05.16.10 | bleep bleep bloop blop bleep bleep bleep bleep bleep bloop blop bleep blop bleep bleep bleep bloop blop bleep bleep bleep bleep bleep bloop blop bleep blop bleep bleep bleep bloop blop bleep bleep bleep bleep bleep bloop blop bleep blop bleep bleep bleep bloop blop bleep bleep bleep bloop blop bleep bleep bleep bleep bleep bloop blop bleep blop bleep bleep bleep bleep bloop blop bleep blop bleep bleep bleep bloop blop bleep bleep bleep bleep bleep bloop blop bleep blop bleep bleep bleep bloop blop bleep bleep bleep bleep bleep bloop blop bleep blop bleep bleep bleep bloop blop bleep bleep bleep bleep bleep bloop blop bleep blop bleep bleep bleep bloop blop bleep bleep bleep bloop blop bleep bleep bleep bleep bleep bloop blop bleep blop bleep bleep bleep bleep bloop blop bleep blop bleep bleep bleep bloop blop bleep bleep bleep bleep bleep bloop blop bleep blop bleep bleep bleep bloop blop bleep bleep bleep bleep bleep bloop blop bleep blop bleep bleep bleep bloop blop bleep bleep bleep bleep bleep bloop blop bleep blop bleep bleep bleep bloop blop bleep bleep bleep bloop blop bleep bleep bleep bleep bleep bloop blop bleep blop bleep bleep bleep bleep bloop blop bleep blop bleep |
Prophet178
05.16.10 | So most of these are not overrated, they're just not as good as the band's other releases (in your opinion) is what I'm getting out of this.
And rofl @ calling Weezer emo. |
SeaAnemone
05.16.10 | honestly can't tell if you're a troll or not (I'm gullible), but there's really no excuse for lists like this. 'Overrated' is such a misused and trite word, it's not even funny. I have no problem with people expressing dissent from popular opinion, but there's more intelligent ways of doing it. This really tells us nothing, it's worthless-- other than the fact that you were looking for attention and probably will get it.
To future commenters on this list--- if your comment says basically the same thing as mine and all the ones already here, don't comment. let's not give this the attention it was clearly just dying for. |
Prolapse
05.16.10 | bleep bloop |
PearlDrummer20
05.16.10 | @johnny10 are those the lyrics to Treefingers? |
Enotron
05.16.10 | Calling something pretentious is an awful argument for something being overrated.
In other words this list makes you an awful person and you should leave sputnik. |
WithHorsesInHerEyes
05.16.10 | I like 'Overrated' better, as I the new title has too many big words. |
PearlDrummer20
05.16.10 | the new title for this list has almost more fail then the old one. |
Counterfeit
05.16.10 | hahaha. no. and yes. It's a mix. |
Bfhurricane
05.16.10 | Blizzard of Ozz doesn't have a single bad song, has a couple classics too. Randy Rhoads is godly. |
porch
05.16.10 | almost as much fail as your review of The Bends |
PearlDrummer20
05.16.10 | I thought we had a silent agreement never to speak of it again
but thanks for reminding me, still gotta fix it. In fact, gonna do that now. |
PearlDrummer20
05.16.10 | and plus there have been way worse reviews. |
porch
05.16.10 | yeah yeah its cool i was only being half serious |
Schizophrenik
05.16.10 | i don't see how anyone can not love the blue album |
PearlDrummer20
05.16.10 | Just fixed my The Bends review. Yay. Feel so much better. |
PearlDrummer20
05.16.10 | Pinkerton > Blue Album |
PaperTigers
05.16.10 | The word "overrated" isn't the problem. It's the idea that some nitwit on Sputnik that is incapable of capitalizing the first word in a sentence somehow knows the proper level of praise that albums should receive, while everyone else is wrong. |
SeaAnemone
05.16.10 | ^right.
it's just that 'overrated' is used so often by kids like this, and often others known when to stop using it. |
BallsToTheWall
05.16.10 | I can be your hero baby... |
Baphomet
05.16.10 | agree with 1, 2, 5 and 12. But who the fuck gives Korn praise? |
PaperTigers
05.16.10 | Ah, then thank you for showing us the error in our ways. You are clearly wiser than I thought. I'll stop enjoying Tool and Radiohead now. |
Lucian
05.16.10 | Tool? I'm not going to argue against the rest of the list... But Tool?! They're a great band that brings so much incredibility and ambiance to their scene. |
Lucian
05.16.10 | I didn't realize this person was a troll... -_-
Heads up for everyone else then. |
kvltelite
05.17.10 | i agree becuase im a tool with a shitty taste in muisc |
couldwinarabbit
05.17.10 | ...you completely misunderstand the the word "Glorified", no one with and IQ over 90 likes Tool, Ozzy, Rise Against, Korn, RATM or Muse, cause they suck.
I do agree with about half of these.
I completely disagree with Kid A being on here but it can defend itself.
However, GFY for saying In the Aeroplane Over the Sea sucks. |
zarquan99
05.17.10 | are you talking about glorified albums on Sputnik or out? You don't really make any sense... As the Roots Undo and Frances don't get that much acclaim out of Sputnik. As the Roots Undo is just amazing and as far as the Mars Volta I couldn't give less of a fuck. De-loused sucked, and as far as I'm concerned so does Frances. I couldn't agree with you more on 1, 2, 5, 11, and 12 though. They are all just kind of shitty. I love 9 though. They hadn't lost their creativity then. Now they have with The Resistance but I absolutely love Black Holes. |
rhatrz
05.17.10 | you lost me with KID A, KID A?!!!?? |
R6Rider
05.17.10 | All it takes is a few good songs. |
Valle
05.17.10 | I'm pretty sure Kid A was more than bleep and bloops. In fact, I think it had a lot more instruments in it than their previous albums before it. |
couldwinarabbit
05.17.10 | ...Just take Kid A and ITAOTS off and people will be happy. |
Lucian
05.17.10 | @couldwinarabbit
I didn't realize you had the ability to make the subjective into a factual objective. My god, you're a fucking idiot >:D |
Idnuf
05.17.10 | Even if he is trying to be a troll or whatever, this list happens to be true. Suspicious absence of Jane Doe though. |
Idnuf
05.17.10 | Also lol at the guy saying As the Roots Undo doesn't get that much praise on Sputnik. |
Idnuf
05.17.10 | That would be lovely. I think Jane Doe is much more overrated than some of the albums on this list. Honorable mentions would have to include Relationship of Command I believe. Good night and good luck. |
couldwinarabbit
05.17.10 | @Lucian lol. My opinion IS fact, you can disagree but as my opinion is fact and yours is not you don't have much of a case. |
Idnuf
05.17.10 | @ couldwinarabbit
Can't argue with that immaculate logic. |
shindip
05.17.10 | agree with 1 3 6 8 9 10 15 17 to some extent. never enjoyed 20 at all |
Romulus
05.17.10 | I'm surprised no one's come after the emo comment yet |
Sowing
05.17.10 | so much for this not getting attention, huh sea? |
crazyblinddude
05.17.10 | I agree with a lot of these. Defintely 1,6,11,12,18 but 9 wasnt really THAT overrated
And yeah i dont really think weezer can be considered emo. i gotta wikipedia it. |
couldwinarabbit
05.17.10 | Excellent Troll is excellent |
couldwinarabbit
05.17.10 | I'm NOT a troll. Sputnikers are just, in general, idiots. |
Sowing
05.17.10 | as a sputnik user, i take offense |
crazyblinddude
05.17.10 | yeah its kinda ambiguous whether weezer is emo. idk really. when i think emo i think american football. |
couldwinarabbit
05.17.10 | Exactly I'm just an asshole. |
Sowing
05.17.10 | proving your point by making an example of yourself...true brilliance |
Sowing
05.17.10 | no haha, im talking to couldwinarabbit. but even to him i was joking. |
ProdigalSon16
05.17.10 | your right, nevermind sucks |
JulesWin
05.17.10 | "says the guy who practically pioneered trolling"
couldwinarabbit?
c'mon killer9 must be rolling over in his grave |
Sowing
05.17.10 | i remeber the good old days of killer9...i almost miss it |
Sowing
05.17.10 | not sure if you are a troll or not, but you are at l;east someone's alt. |
JulesWin
05.17.10 | "i dont.... i made a troll once though"
what was it? |
Sowing
05.17.10 | lakes, are you tinkrbell |
JulesWin
05.17.10 | "lakes, are you tinkrbell"
nah because that's me |
theacademy
05.17.10 | "nu-metal just kinda sucks, as does korn... but many claim that this album helped save the declining of rock at the time, when really it was an acceptable release at the time ,and muscial tastes were already shifting elsewhere (not for the better of course). really it should just be a bit lower in rating."
lol str8 up ignorance |
JulesWin
05.17.10 | "you have like 3 limp bizkit albums rated as 5's"
ooops!
haha |
royscoop19
05.17.10 | Pretty solid list |
Baphomet
05.18.10 | I can't get mad at any troll using an Enrique Iglesias avatar. It like those eyes... look into my soul... |
SpaceisGolden
05.18.10 | Siren Song was wayyyy to well received. Honestly, it didn't deserve any of the praise it got.
The Blue Album is like every other Weezer album: pick and choose. |
JamieTwort
05.20.10 | This list has pissed me off, paticualrly the inclusion of 6,15 & 20 lol |
BigHans
05.20.10 | He's right about 3,4,7,10, and 17. The rest is a flat out fucking fail. |
Yellowangel
06.18.10 | The songs on Mellon Collie are all great some you need to listen to more then like 5 times to understand, I think you have to be a big fan to dig it |
Jonathan10
06.19.10 | Enrique can do whatever he wants although i love SP |
Jonathan10
06.19.10 | It's def in my top 5 for the 90's |
Phantom
06.19.10 | 50% yes 50% no
Bailamos - let the rhythm take you over, bailamos . |
jesusjuice1179
06.19.10 | how bout we don't bump lists that are over a month old and completely irrelavent anymore |
Phantom
06.19.10 | bump |
Maniac!
06.19.10 | youre an idiot for 6 and 14. |
Ire
06.19.10 | 7 means you lose |