|Made this list last week, but I totally spaced and forgot Machina II and Pisces (Pisces isn't technically an album, it's a compilation, but it's too good not to include)|
|ive always felt 3 was better than 1 but other than that i agree|
|only have 1 and 3, and 3 is def better.|
|1 is right|
|1 is pretty epic but a chore to listen to in one sitting. I'd say switch 3 and 1. aaaand...4 and 2 for that matter. I really cant stand listening to 5-7. and yes...zeitgeist will never count. |
|3 has always been my favorite.|
|The age-old Siamese Dream vs. Mellon Collie debate. I choose MellonCollie as I feel it ranks with other double-album classics like the Beatles'' White Album. Mellon COllie is such a complete vision. 26 songs with no filler. A cohesive sound despite tons of experimentation.... yeah. |
As for Pisces over Siamese, it's close, but Pisces gets it because of "Starla"