Si1v3RfaNg
05.13.09 | some of these arent true metalcore... but close enough |
redskyformiles
05.13.09 | you really BOTCHed this list.
3/15 |
withALMONDS
05.13.09 | messengers by august burns red isnt up here
neither is killing with a smile by parkway drive
but underoath IS up here
what the hell |
Hawks10Pec
05.13.09 | Where the hell is Misery Signals? |
redskyformiles
05.13.09 | ^ because its a list for the "best" metalcore albums. not the best albums for 14 year olds to windmill kick and pick up change too. |
redskyformiles
05.13.09 | that was to withAlmonds |
withALMONDS
05.13.09 | but
it's underoath
are you honestly saying that underoath is better than those two groups |
Si1v3RfaNg
05.13.09 | they are wayyy better |
redskyformiles
05.13.09 | much |
Si1v3RfaNg
05.13.09 | also i dont really like botch that much... dont know why... |
withALMONDS
05.13.09 | also, please note that i do mean better
not more mainstream accessible |
someguest
05.13.09 | If you don't like Botch then you shouldn't like any metalcore. |
SlightlyEpic
05.13.09 | Yes, Underoath are better than both those bands.
And list needs more Knut/The Secret/Misery Signals/7A7P. |
kitsch
05.13.09 | 15 would be my 1. |
Phantom
05.13.09 | "because its a list for the "best" metalcore albums. not the best albums for 14 year olds to windmill kick and pick up change too. "
Winner. |
Si1v3RfaNg
05.13.09 | that was a winning statement haha |
withALMONDS
05.13.09 | you know what
yes it was |
ninjuice
05.13.09 | Messengers could definitely replace 4 and/or 11. |
Si1v3RfaNg
05.13.09 | nah messengers isnt really THAT good |
BallsToTheWall
05.13.09 | Every asshole needs Prayer For Cleansing, Earth Crisis, and maybe even a little Bleeding Through thrown in for good measure. |
ninjuice
05.13.09 | It's better than an average metalcore album (SAS) and an extremely poor man's PTH (Nocturne) |
ninjuice
05.13.09 | also I'd say BTA are death metal |
Si1v3RfaNg
05.13.09 | nah they have too many breakdowns... but SAS def isnt average metalcore... |
ThyCrossAwaits
05.13.09 | Becoming the Archetype is prog-death
Dillinger Escape Plan i can't really classify, but it's not metalcore. Otherwise this is ok. |
bloc
05.13.09 | oh come on, calling sikth metalcore is insulting. |
Bleak
05.13.09 | 15 rules. |
DBlitz
05.13.09 | 1 2 13 are amazing
8 10 and 15 are cool |
Phantom
05.13.09 | If Becoming The Archetype is prog death then i'm fucking god |
YouAreMySilence
05.13.09 | Where's Oh, Sleeper? |
ziroth
05.13.09 | "If Becoming The Archetype is prog death then i'm fucking god"
I guess you're God? |
Phantom
05.13.09 | Nope, try again |
ziroth
05.13.09 | Dichotomy isn't that prog but their others are |
ManicDemise
05.18.09 | Dillinger...metalcore? No.
SikTh...metalcore? No. |
Hollier
05.23.09 | where the fuck is misery signals? |
po0ty
05.23.09 | I need to start listening to converge..lots of people seem to like them.
I'd put Messengers on this too but hey it's your list ;) |
iwinyoulose
05.23.09 | profile pic ftw |
iwinyoulose
05.23.09 | as i lay dying |
Stumble
Digg
Del.icio.us