|i just know its one or the other|
|I tend to disagree with 1, 4, and 7 and agree with most of the others. Except 9: that is a terrible album and there is good reason it is not well-liked. Props on an interesting list tho|
|2 is good, although i'm yet to see anyone enjoy it.|
3 IS my all time favourite album so grrr!
and 4 is definitley up there with my favourites.
"Smells Like Teen Spirit the only good Nirvana song ever."
Kurt is rolling in his grave...
|kurt is dead. you know what he's probably doing? being dead.|
|"Smells Like Teen Spirit" is no where near the best Nirvana song, it was just the first single from their breakthrough.|
#3 is overrated, perhaps, but it's still great.
#7 should be "Dark Side of the Moon," because it generally overshadows "Wish You Were Here" when it shouldn't.
|I know what you mean about 2, but I think it's kinda average. Also 3 and 4 are awsome, and SLTS is nowhere near the best Nirvana song, infact it's one of my least favourites.|
|1 - You forgot to mention that Abbey Road's like the best album ever. Yeah.|
2 - Ehhh... depends on who you talk to. It's pretty good imo, but I'm basically the only person that seems to like it where I live.
3 - Nahh, it's damn good. Extraordinary Girl isn't all that great, but apart from that it's my favourite Green Day album.
4 - LIES LIES LIES LIES LIES alright the album's not that good, but Smells Like Teen Spirit the only good Nirvana song? I don't like you :(
5 - Hell yeah. Amazing album.
6 - Only heard a couple of their songs, but they seemed good. I might just get that album.
7 - Nooo way. Every song's at least 4 stars from me, probably at least 4.5.
8 - Haven't heard it, can't judge.
9 - Good, but nothing more than that.
10 - Only heard a couple of songs but it wasn't up to scratch by usual Waters standards.
|Smells like Teen spirit isnt even in my top 20 Nirvana songs|
|You should be slapped for 7.|
|7 is one of the most blasphemous statements I've ever read. There are just these albums that cannot be anything short of classic. Wish You Were Here is one of them.|
|3 isn't overrated it just sucks.|
|You should be castrated for 6 and 7. |
But I totally agree on 4. Except there's one other song on there that I kind of liek but can't remember the name of because I never take the time to listen to it.
|7 is one of the greatest PF albums along with Animals. Dark Side of the Moon and The Wall are the albums that tend to be praised the most when theyre clearly not the best (but still awesome)|
|It's cause of morrons like you that Kurt shot himself... or maybe the drugs... still that's a pretty stupid thing to say.|
Agree with 3, it is not only overrated but should be burnt and buried in the desert.
but then with 7 you lost me.
|"You forgot to mention that Abbey Road's like the best album ever."|
Abbey Road is actually my least favorite Beatles album >_>;;
apart from Beatles For Sale.
|I was just about to make a list just like this. Wish You |
Were Here is my fav album ever, but I have to admit it is overrated. I've been acused of being a Pink Floyd fanboy, but my whole family is one giant Metallica+The Beatles+Pink Floyd fan family.9 is my avatar.
|Nevermind is awesome. I may say it's overrated, but it's nothing like you imply. Lounge Act, Lithium, and Drain You rule.|
Great list though.
I agree that WYWH flows awkwardly and is over rated, but I'm really not sure where you are coming from calling wywh, the song, the best song on the album, bleh....
and have you listened to the Final Cut? Its like Roger Waters broke free from his leash and just started whining and whining and whining and...
good calls on 8 and 9!
|Animals-Pink Floyd's best work.Beatles can't be overated.Nirvava is completely overated.Speaking of overated,anything by Converge.Underrated ?Anything by Katatonia |
|well we agree on Nirvana!|
|Agree on nearly everything except 7 cos imo its one of the best albums of all time. |
I really like 2 aswell, not as good as Appetite but still a good album
4 is overrated but I still enjoy it even though Teen Spirit isn't the only good Nirvana song
I really enjoy 1 too !!
Good list though dude