Erratic
11.24.06 | I'd put Neil Peart on drums. |
Patrick
11.24.06 | I'd put David Gilmour on here. |
Bfhurricane
11.24.06 | You could just put in everyone from Dream Theater |
Angmar
11.24.06 | wut erratic said. |
phillramirez
11.24.06 | ^BFhurricane didn't see the prog metal part in your description. but I would go with Mr. Peart on drums. The other ones are too hard for me to decide at this moment. |
Rocksta71
11.24.06 | Fripp on guitar
Roger waters on Bass
Syd barret-Rhythym guitar vocals
the rest of Zepdudes list is fine. |
AmericnZero02
11.24.06 | Why on earth would you rather have Roger Waters than Geddy Lee on bass? |
Patrick
11.25.06 | Syd wasn't that proggy. |
Bfhurricane
11.25.06 | Excuse me, I didn't see the description. |
francesfarmer
11.25.06 | Syd was progressive in a sense, it was alot of psychedelic, but just because he didn't write songs that nobody will ever hear the damn end of doesn't signify strict psychedelia. |
IvortheEngineDriver
11.25.06 | Lead Vocals/Rhythum Guitar: Steven Wilson
Bass/Backup Vox: Geddy Lee
Lead Guitar: Robert Fripp
Drums: Bill Bruford
Keyboards: Rick Wakeman
There...perfect prog rock band |
freudianslipknot
12.02.06 | Martin Barre is great but most would agree that the pivotal member of Tull is Ian Anderson. I'm not sure who I would go for on guitar though. Similarly Greg Lake is great, but most would also agree that Keith Emerson was the key member of ELP and arguably the best virtuoso on the instrument. Also Neil Peart (good for song writing as well) would be a pretty awesome alternative on drums. |
LynchMobster
12.04.06 | vox: Jon Anderson(Yes, not Ian of Tull)
gtr: Alex Lifeson
bss: Geddy Lee(he would still sing too)
drums: Neil Peart
keyboards: Rick Wakeman(in Yes during Close To The Edge, and probly a couple others)
|
wakeupdead
12.04.06 | Geddy Lee is awesome. |
Altmer
02.14.07 | Geddy Lee kicks ass, but Gilmour has got to be on here. |