widowslaugh123
04.22.22 | 4 is a slog |
IsisScript80
04.22.22 | 5. “i LOVE side one of this album but this lineup just hadn't mastered the long form improv, Fracture just isnt that great to me”
Yeah, tend to agree. Great album, but ‘Fracture’ is a self-indulgent wank-fest that I rarely tend to not skip over. |
DoofDoof
04.22.22 | yeah surprised at 10, Polaris is a great closer |
twlight
04.22.22 | 4 4 sure |
JokineAugustus
04.22.22 | First Fragment latest album. |
JohnnyoftheWell
04.22.22 | Sgt Peppers is full of silly faff, but idk if it's fair to accuse it of dragging - none of its many throwaways weigh it down that badly and it has diversity in its favour hm |
Cimnele
04.22.22 | disagree on S&BB, Fracture's one of their best tunes overall to me |
Tunaboy45
04.22.22 | when the payoff is A Day in the Life you kind of forget about/forgive the arsing about |
Pheromone
04.22.22 | a kill keep list |
JohnnyoftheWell
04.22.22 | KILL or KEEP: every list in the recently published panel |
ffs
04.22.22 | antennas to heaven is 5 but any of these albums drag ok my dude |
BillyBrill
04.22.22 | Yeah list isn't necessarily the closers that are bad, just tend towards lower quality near the end, especially the case for sgt peppers, A Day in The Life is beautiful but also Two Headed Boy Part Two and Polaris are great closers, they're just on the inferior half of the album |
JKing92
04.22.22 | Don't agree with 1, 2, and 10, but I will side with 9 being overhyped (though I wouldn't say it drags, necessarily -- it sounds fine while it's playing, I just don't think it's a masterpiece). |
pizzamachine
04.22.22 | How you gonna say 10 drags |
DoofDoof
04.22.22 | Sufjan Stevens 'Illinois' always dragged for me |
theBoneyKing
04.22.22 | Very much agreed with Illinois |
DoofDoof
04.22.22 | The ‘drag factor’ probably loses it a .5 on the rating for me (so ends up a 4 rather than a 4.5) but nothing in the last third is actively bad, plus it’s all in keeping sure, …it’s just all so much by that point and not really any massive highlights in that stretch |
rockarollacola
04.22.22 | 9 doesn't drag. It actually has to start out strong to drag, the whole thing is an overhyped wank-fest. |
DoofDoof
04.22.22 | Controversially I’d say every Modest Mouse album has a bit of drag factor
All long, all have better first halves imo (maybe not Long Drive), all have a few lesser songs second half
Still consider ‘Moon’ and ‘Lonesome’ classics despite that |
Ryus
04.22.22 | 9 best PF album
|
Drifter
04.22.22 | you're alone on songs in the key of life |
Ryus
04.22.22 | yeah fr no misses |
ReturnToRock
04.25.22 | Disagree on 1 and 2. How does a 40-minute, eight-song album drag exactly?
Nirvana - In Utero
The Clash - London Calling
AC/DC - Black Ice
Manu Chao - Clandestino
Iron Maiden - Senjutsu
Green Day - 21st Century Breakdown |
CottonSalad
04.25.22 | Based.
Except 6 and 9 - just wrong. |
