splinter: most overrated bands of all time

splinter 07.14.19	I don't say that these bands are shit (most of them are) but at least they are all overrated af
Ambrosian 07.14.19	I really don't see Linkin Park or Blink-182 getting undeserved praise, or much praise at all really
Skoop 07.14.19	"This band wouldn't survive these days" What is the use of a statement like this?
rxthebandit 07.14.19	"these days" would be ENTIRELY different if they werent around, soo.......
Egarran 07.14.19	So... you think The Rolling Stones aren't overrated. This invalidates the list.
GhandhiLion 07.14.19	"This band wouldn't survive these days" Wow! who would kill them?
TheNotrap 07.14.19	So Ride is overrated.. Let me guess, Trump is the most underrated US president ever
DoofDoof 07.14.19	Beatle population facing an extinction event confirmed
Pikazilla 07.14.19	You forgot The Story So Far, Brand New, Mountain Goats and Modest Mouse.
DoofDoof 07.14.19	'Their first both albums were good' I think you've given too much away with this statement
TheNotrap 07.14.19	Darwinism is a myth, we're all god angels.
Thalassic 07.14.19	Such a novel idea for a list! Feature this pls!
Deez 07.14.19	As much as I don't like the beatles or metallica theyre 2 of the most influential bands of all time.
TheNotrap 07.14.19	Feature this and lets make Trump KING!!!
fogza 07.14.19	The Beatles, Radiohead and Fugazi pretty much deserve their praise. The rest I'm not really invested in.
Alastor 07.14.19	"This band wouldn't survive these days" has anyone here seen Yesterday? I'm thinking about going but I'm not sure yet.
kalkwiese 07.14.19	Jane Dough
garas 07.14.19	"I really don't see Linkin Park or Blink-182 getting undeserved praise, or much praise at all really" [2] And I'm not a Beatles fan either (I like The Rolling Stones much better actually), but unarguably that's one of the most important bands ever.
RadioSuicide 07.14.19	No ACDC but you got Metallica, LP, and Rammstein so gj. Hard disagree on the rest
PunchforPunch 07.14.19	uhh where's tool
Sharkattack 07.14.19	Minus fugazi which makes no sense at all I’m down with this list
DoofDoof 07.14.19	The author of this list has 5'd Killswitch Engage and Dance Gavin Dance if people are struggling for context
PunchforPunch 07.14.19	Ah, that makes sense.
JohnnyoftheWell 07.14.19	"has anyone here seen Yesterday? I'm thinking about going but I'm not sure yet." Worth seeing for the hell of it but don't expect anything more than cheap dumb entertainment
Thalassic 07.14.19	"uhh where's tool" This is the one thing that really puzzles me about this list. Mostly lists like these GOTTA have Tool on it, but they're strangely absent here.
Viriathus 07.14.19	Well at least you got it right with 3, 5, 6, 7, and 8
JohnnyoftheWell 07.14.19	"The author of this list has 5'd Killswitch Engage and Dance Gavin Dance if people are struggling for context" Never mind them (I guess the hype can be justified within their style) when we have Explosions In the Sky as exhibit A for overatedcore
Viriathus 07.14.19	KSE and DGD are not somewhat deservingly hyped in their style. Even if they are "better" than their contemporaries they dont really have anything on the bands they shamelessly take influence from.
InFlamesWeThrash666 07.14.19	"uhh where's tool" in the goat list
naughtcturnal 07.14.19	Led Zep
kalkwiese 07.14.19	Tool are the underrated though. Men.
JohnnyoftheWell 07.14.19	@Moog meant that primarily in reference to DCD having so many second-rate imitators at this point that their original sources of influence are virtually moot
NordicMindset 07.14.19	Where’s Nirvana
Viriathus 07.14.19	@Johnny Fair enough.
Source 07.14.19	naughtcturnal bringin out the big guns
kalkwiese 07.14.19	This list is missing Guns n Roses
alamo 07.14.19	not sure about 12 vocals but they do have the worst album covers ive ever seen
splinter 07.14.19	had to add Korn because they fit so well here
Source 07.14.19	I thought Korn are pretty hated overall
alamo 07.14.19	post-2000 in flames is also really hated
splinter 07.14.19	hated by the elitists, loved by the masses
Pikazilla 07.14.19	But Brand New
Calc 07.14.19	every time I see these lists on the front page I check and see if it was made in 2009
naughtcturnal 07.14.19	i kinda like 8 tho (aside from Anders' vocals and laughable lyrics). I've re-jammed it recently and Touch of Red is probably still my favorite post-2000 In Flames song (aside from "Watch Them Feed" from "Trigger" ep)
Dedes 07.14.19	But this is just, like, your opinion man
naughtcturnal 07.14.19	Yea
kalkwiese 07.14.19	7 is good wtf
TheNotrap 07.14.19	I feel a Trump love on this thread
splinter 07.14.19	blink-182 is not good
kalkwiese 07.14.19	B182 is gre4t lmao noop
Pikazilla 07.14.19	I feel a Trump love on this thread Thank fuck I don't live in America.
splinter 07.14.19	blink is not and was never and will never be more than garbage
splinter 07.14.19	just like me - and I can live with that
rockandmetaljunkie 07.14.19	being overrated is better than being unoriginal. And this is the most unoriginal list ever
splinter 07.14.19	@rockandmetaljunkie ty mate you just made this list more original than before
Arditi 07.14.19	Agree with 6,8, and 10.
ian b 07.14.19	agree with a lot of this list, but if you're dissing the album on number 5, you gettin SMOKED
GhandhiLion 07.14.19	being overrated is better than being unoriginal. [2]
samwise2000 07.14.19	being overrated is better than being unoriginal. And this is the most unoriginal list ever [3]
splinter 07.14.19	@ianbisntdeadyet I don't disslike this album, I just choosed randomly some albums I think they are in general overrated
Sinternet 07.14.19	why do people even make these lists? just screams "I don't have any personality other than being negative towards everything" also irony of this list then 5ing a while she sleeps record
hansoloshotfirst 07.14.19	haven't seen this list idea before...
Lucman 07.14.19	You put the wrong album for 3. Now the new album I completely agree with. It's rubbish.
Egarran 07.14.19	Considering their once popularity, it's funny how U2 are now considered so terrible they don't even make these lists.
kalkwiese 07.15.19	"blink is not and was never and will never be more than garbage" LOL stfu That's a poop opinion You're poopy, sir lmao lololololol
worthlessscab 07.15.19	you clearly haven't checked fugazi
JokineAugustus 07.15.19	Well Dillinger was the best band ever, though I agree with some of these and would add Slayer and Tool.
Confessed2005 07.15.19	Dillinger are most certainly not overrated. They are quality in every regard.
climactic 07.15.19	what a dum list
Viriathus 07.15.19	Blink-182 were good on Cheshire Cat and Buddha. Everything else is not good.
naughtcturnal 07.15.19	Dude Ranch rules u nerd
Viriathus 07.15.19	Dude Ranch is okay ill admit. But Cheshire Cat has far better guitarwork.
rabidfish 07.15.19	i'm not sayin these bands are shit but they are
ArsMoriendi 07.15.19	The Beatles would totally survive They have 1,000 imitators
JokineAugustus 07.15.19	Radiohead are basically the modern beatles
ArsMoriendi 07.15.19	They also have 1000 imitators, true Though I'd probably call them more the modern Pink Floyd since they're the "entry level" college kid "I like full albums now! and this is deep stuff bro" band
LebowskiRams 07.15.19	I get why people may not like The Beatles, but they changed all music forever, the music landscape would look so much different without them. Same for Radiohead
dctarga 07.15.19	Wrong on Deftones although DE itself is a tad over-rated, but I wouldn't say your off on any other ones. But why is Volbeat on this list? They just suck out loud and always have, never seen them get any undue praise Oh and yeah Silent Planet is bad agreed, throw Erra up there with them
naughtcturnal 07.15.19	My friend's older brother is huuuuge into Volbeat and A7X lol
dctarga 07.15.19	Sounds like a cool guy lol
kalkwiese 07.15.19	Blink is the best band out of these tbh no joking
splinter 07.15.19	@kalkwiese you fckn fanboy!
iglu 07.15.19	thrice
splinter 07.15.19	@iglu stfu men
iglu 07.15.19	hehe
Asdfp277 07.15.19	thrice [2]
sixdegrees 07.15.19	the beetles won't survive the winter
splinter 07.16.19	@sixdegrees I laughed way more than I should
SCREAMorphine 07.16.19	Keep it to yourself Clearly the people who 'overrate' any band find enjoyment in it which you can't
Deez 07.16.19	Wheres foo fighters?
Egarran 07.16.19	Good list Prancer. Didn't disagree with one name.
Faenrir 07.16.19	I'd replace Korn with Slipknot, remove Rammstein (wtf is wrong with you lol). And add Limp Bizkit. aand... "Where’s Nirvana" [2]
Egarran 07.16.19	>wtf is wrong with you lol. He probably thinks they are nazis and he's making a political statement.
splinter 07.16.19	People who like Rammstein just doesn't understand their lyrics..
Faenrir 07.16.19	^ Huh...no. I guess YOU don't understand the lyrics and assume it's nazi stuff lol.
Egarran 07.16.19	Tell us more about that new and interesting theory, Splinter.
splinter 07.16.19	It's sadly my fucking native language and this band and their lyrics are the worst shit ever
Egarran 07.16.19	Why do you think the lyrics are so bad?
kalkwiese 07.16.19	I'm a native speaker as well and I would call them inconsistent tbh. Some lyrics are amazing, songs like Pussy suck
splinter 07.16.19	"Rammstein Ein Mensch brennt Rammstein Fleischgeruch liegt in der Luft Rammstein Ein Kind stirbt Rammstein Die Sonne scheint"
Faenrir 07.16.19	^ What's wrong with those lyrics, exactly ? You do realize the contrast between the rest of the lyrics and "die Sonne scheint" is there on purpose, right ? That it might just be to denunciate the current state of the world ? Oh and this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ramstein_air_show_disaster
Faenrir 07.16.19	But yeah, keep dissing Rammstein while bringing into light your ignorance lmao.
splinter 07.16.19	This band is shit
Egarran 07.16.19	Splinter why do you think the lyrics are so bad?
Faenrir 07.16.19	"This band is shit" Hahaha...that's some real nice argument there, mate. Admit you're wrong and move on.
Egarran 07.16.19	I like to read his thoughts on this though. You learn something important.
splinter 07.16.19	@Egarran I gave you already an answer
Prancer 07.16.19	you can delete my comment but you can't delete the truth
splinter 07.16.19	@Prancer it was just too long, you can post it again with the names in one row
Egarran 07.16.19	>I gave you already an answer Nein you didn't. You posted some lyrics and it seemed likely you didn't get the point of them.
splinter 07.16.19	it's fine if you consider them as good I consider them as bad, even tho they have some deeper meaning this band could have the best lyrics ever, they would still sound like shit
Faenrir 07.16.19	^ Lmao You're just a clueless hater
hansoloshotfirst 07.16.19	shit like A Day to Remember, Brand New and Dance Gavin Dance needs to be on this list.
splinter 07.16.19	@hansoloshotfirst Brand New was a really great band Dance Gavin Dance was a really great band, now they are indeed overrated No one is listening ADTR anymore, so idk why they should be overrated
Faenrir 07.16.19	Rename this list to "Bands i hate for no reason" xD
Aerisavion 07.17.19	Linkin Park really haven’t been “overrated” since Meteora dropped. Minutes to Midnight saw to that pretty fucking effectively...
naughtcturnal 07.17.19	ulcerate is the greatest band of all time ur fucking crazy
splinter 07.17.19	@naughtcturnal yes
SacredSerenity 07.17.19	Dillinger and Converge is just wrong
Egarran 07.17.19	Ulcerate are filed with DSO under 'Bands I would probably love if I made an effort'. Oh, bye fchan cu l8r.
TheClansman95 07.17.19	Dillinger and Converge are awesome tbh
DamnVanne 07.17.19	Aerisavion I’ll second that point about minutes to midnight. Even worse than hearing buckcherry, volbeat and hinder for the first time, that was the single biggest blow to my love of rock and roll. Absolutely devastating
rellik009 12.08.19	Who said Five Finger Death Punch was good? Especially here, I mean, on top of this they're literally one of the most hated bands of all time, right after Nickelback! Only thing good about them is that they're a musical gateway for army men(and women), whom their music speaks to. And yes, with Deftones, I agree, but they're still one hell of a band.
rellik009 12.08.19	And also, literally no one praises Korn or A7X to the point of overrating them anymore. More importantly, where is Limp Bizkit, Slipknot, Beyonce, Queen(just my opinion don't get triggered), Coldplay, etc... They would have made good choices as well.
kalkwiese 12.08.19	Queen can't be rated high enough tbh T R I G G E R E D
naughtcturnal 12.08.19	most of these bands have released material that deserves universal praise
Aerisavion 12.08.19	Considering how much hate they generally accumulated over the years, I don’t think Linkin Park qualifies as overrated.
Morningrise767 12.08.19	1 and 4 are great
Cimnele 12.08.19	i said some dumb stuff today at dinner and pissed off my boyfriend
rellik009 12.09.19	naughtcturnal maybe, but that material is pushed constantly on people, which is more relevant to overplay, but regardless, they get excessive praise when a myriad of other bands/artists have also released good - fantastic material. It's only because of influence, most of the time, which is not equal to quality.
neekafat 12.09.19	a7x rule wtf
rellik009 12.09.19	not at all wtf A7X is one of the worst and most overrated bands in modern metal, especially now that the Rev is dead
VincenzoAureo 01.20.20	Puts Metallica but not Queen fuck off
kalkwiese 01.20.20	Because Queen are just that good lul
Dewinged 01.20.20	Great bands honestly. 17 though...
manosg 01.20.20	I don't like a band/album as much as other guys, so it's overrated.
splinter 01.20.20	manosg which one isn't overrated?
pjquinones747 01.20.20	7 yea
manosg 01.21.20	I'm just not a big fan of claiming that x or y band/album is overrated, splinter dude. If people like something, just let them be. Also, these things change all the time. When I was 16, I just couldn't understand why The Dark Side of the Moon was so popular, and now it's one of my favorite albums. Lastly, judging by your ratings, it's perfectly natural to consider The Beatles overrated but that doesn't mean that they actually are.
Dewinged 01.21.20	Manosg speaks wisdom. As usual.
rellik009 01.21.20	well manosg, maybe splinter's problem is that some of these album receive praise that should be given to other bands too. The problem is that he does it clumsily, which led to him losing a pointless argument over Rammstein
manosg 01.21.20	For sure, there are a lot of amazing bands/albums out there who fly under the radar or for some reason don't receive enough praise. That's why I enjoy much more checking "underrated" lists haha.
rellik009 01.21.20	high five me too
zakalwe 01.21.20	Queen