BlackwaterPork
06.16.18 | Top notch shit this is twats |
theBoneyKing
06.16.18 | 3 > 4 > 2 > 5 > 1 |
BlackwaterPork
06.16.18 | No |
BlackwaterPork
06.16.18 | Cheers ma boi |
Casavir
06.16.18 | 2 and 4 are the only truly essential albums. |
teamster
06.16.18 | Kodama 4? Nice knowing you ... |
Rik VII
06.16.18 | I didn't think an Alcest ranking could feel wrong, but yeah.
1 is 5, 4 is 2. None of them are weaker than "awesome" though. |
Mongi123
06.16.18 | 2>4>5>3>1
Even so 5, 3 and 1 are hard 4s |
theBoneyKing
06.16.18 | Still don’t get why the site at large prefers Ecailles and Kodama to Souvenirs. Everywhere else on the Internet I’ve seen people mostly consider Souvenirs the peak or at least tied with Ecailles as the best. |
kalkwiese
06.16.18 | And I don't get how Souvenirs is considered one of their best. It's top 5 Alcest though |
Mongi123
06.16.18 | Well it’s widely regarded to be groundbreaking and unique for its time that’s why. It’s awesome but Ecallies took away all the cheese of it and made it an astoundingly emotional experience. |
theBoneyKing
06.16.18 | See I feel the opposite, to me Souvenirs is the most genuinely emotional and transportive of them all. Ecailles is amazing but it feels a tad too measured. |
Mongi123
06.16.18 | The final track of the debut makes me feel all warm and fuzzy inside with a smile but it’s damn cheesy haha. Whereas pt2 of the t/t of Ecallies brings genuine tears all the time. It’s just a testament with what you can do with the guitar without it having to sound technical and wanky. It’s just pure atmosphere and vast. |
BlackwaterPork
06.16.18 | I have kodama as a 4.5 so shut up you fucking cretinous swines |
Dmax28
06.16.18 | I do not understand the love for Kodama. I'd rather listen to 2, 3, and 5 before that. I haven't given Shelter much of a go tbh. And my favorite lately is actually Voyages lol |
Mongi123
06.16.18 | But Kodama is beautiful and magical and they kinda just do they’re own thing on it. |
BlackwaterPork
06.16.18 | It's beautiful, but not as good as the other three in front of it imo |
Meridiu5
12.18.18 | 1 is hated because it is not the troo mettles |
DungeonBoy
12.18.18 | Going out on a limb but I don't think most people who dig Alcest hate 1 because it's not metal. Souvenirs is 0% metal but fans adore that record, and for good reason. |
Meridiu5
12.18.18 | in 2007 fans had no expectations. in 2014 they were expecting ecailles pt II |
DungeonBoy
12.18.18 | Interesting opinion! |
Keyblade
12.18.18 | Ecailles was barely metal itself too but go off
like which Alcest fan is listening for trve metal lmao |
Keyblade
12.18.18 | still laughing at that dumb ass take |
tastepolice
12.18.18 | "ranking a pile of turds" |
sixdegrees
12.18.18 | quality bump |
Meridiu5
12.18.18 | watch out guys its a multi named taste police |
