AsleepInTheBack
10.31.23 | we are doing this again apologies
MORT has 5 recs off the bat for REASONS (i promised these a lil while ago and didnt get to them opps) mort you are allowed to change these if on reflection you would recommend a different intro to the genre
Everyone else 1 rec give me your 1 rec i want 1 rec |
Avagantamos
10.31.23 | breach - it's me god |
AsleepInTheBack
10.31.23 | heard that one eek soz |
Sharenge
10.31.23 | quicksand - slip |
bighubbabuddha
10.31.23 | thrice - beggars |
JohnnyoftheWell
10.31.23 | 1 is a lil tenuous, but fucks hard so keep it ig. first two records will probably be the peak of this list, but looks like a fun month
gonna wait a few posts and see what other people cover before recing
|
Avagantamos
10.31.23 | ok how about venom, their 2nd album
(edit: 3rd album actually. didn't realise they had one before it's me god) |
Zac124
10.31.23 | Finch - Say Hello to Sunshine |
MoM
10.31.23 | Lync - These Are Not Fall Colors |
ashcrash9
10.31.23 | No Knife - Fire in the City of Automatons |
Sniff
10.31.23 | Drive like Jehu - Yank Crime |
SlothcoreSam
10.31.23 | Would it be Wrong if I submitted Wrong by NomeansNo, or is that just wrong? |
Hawks
10.31.23 | State Faults - Desolate Peaks |
SomeCallMeTim
10.31.23 | Husker Du - Zen Arcade |
ArsMoriendi
10.31.23 | Tragic Mulatto - Locos por el Sexo |
Mort.
10.31.23 | hello asleep
change 4 to Hot Cross - Cryonics pls
thank you very much
big loves |
AsleepInTheBack
10.31.23 | big loves fren
list look spicy thanks yall |
BitterJalapenoJr
10.31.23 | Treepeople - Guilt Regret Embarrassment |
Hawks
10.31.23 | Second list today that an album I rec'd will be jammed on November 14th which is my wedding anniversary THAT IS SO WEIRD. |
bellovddd
10.31.23 | beloved - failure on |
JohnnyoftheWell
10.31.23 | number girl - sappukei
someone rec jawbox, and then we'll have a decent showing of peak-era classics across this |
hesperus
10.31.23 | At the Drive-In - Relationship of Command |
Kompys2000
10.31.23 | Baby Gurl - Incompoop |
PotsyTater
10.31.23 | Jawbox for your own special sweetheart |
Emim
10.31.23 | O'Brother - Garden Window |
DadKungFu
10.31.23 | Double Nickels On the Dime is kinda sorta this enough to rec and also one of the GOAT albums |
Havey
10.31.23 | worst (non-?)genre ever made
it's not too late to delete this lsit |
JohnnyoftheWell
10.31.23 | go choke on your replica bartok toe collection |
Mort.
10.31.23 | does havey even listen to music or just pretend |
JohnnyoftheWell
10.31.23 | unsure which of the two is less uncomfortable to choose to believe |
Mort.
10.31.23 | i think havey is a psy-op to make me feel inferior and inadequate |
ConcubinaryCode
10.31.23 | Mort got 5 recs and not one was the always open mouth? (That's my rec btw) |
Mort.
11.01.23 | i decided to focus on more of the old stuff/different style
this was after asleep asked for a grounding
didnt think fear before was a good entry point |
artificialbox
11.01.23 | great recs so far. Emim is based for reccing O'Brother. I would add:
Hot Snakes - Suicide Invoice |
widowslaugh123
11.01.23 | Oh shit no idea Iāll goā¦
Plot To Blow Up The Eiffel Tower-Love in The Fascist Brothel |
porcupinetheater
11.01.23 | Lemme get that 88kasyo Junrei album, Iāll give you the name in a second itās weird shapes and shit |
someone
11.01.23 | Reserve me a spot, would you, darling? |
cylinder
11.01.23 | Fugazi - The Argument |
ConcubinaryCode
11.01.23 | Fair point Mort. |
Havey
11.01.23 | saccharine trust - paganicons
fucked n short n sweet "pre-""proto-""post-"hardcore
and i DO listen to music, all the time, (depending... heavily.... on your definition of music, i guess..... |
MeatSalad
11.01.23 | Reuben - In Nothing We Trust |
SandwichBubble
11.01.23 | I missed 11 months of rec lists, but I guess I'm here now.
Bitch Magnet - Umber
Edit: damn, I might be too late. |
Dewinged
11.01.23 | Am I late? Vision of Disorder - Imprint
Although I've seen this labelled this as metalcore, Idk, sounds like PostHC to me. |
Get Low
11.01.23 | Emanuel - Soundtrack to a Headrush |
Kompys2000
11.01.23 | I am changing my rec to super thief - stuck !
So much good stuff on here |
BitterJalapenoJr
11.01.23 | "Reuben - In Nothing We Trust"
Excellent pick MeatSalad š |
BlazinBlitzer
11.01.23 | mewithoutYou - Brother, Sister |
bellovddd
11.01.23 | Emanuel - Soundtrack to a Headrush
WOW. what an album. |
Get Low
11.01.23 | It's my go-to when giving post-hardcore recs. Absolutely GOATed album |
AsleepInTheBack
11.01.23 | ConcubinaryCode I have heard your rec you may pick another |
Get Low
11.01.23 | I'm gonna be sadge if my rec didn't make the cut |
AsleepInTheBack
11.01.23 | dont worry i am the master of space and time |
Get Low
11.01.23 | I look forward to the 34th. |
Uzumaki
11.01.23 | @MoM I just got that Lync album on vinyl like 2 weeks ago; got reissued and was able to nab one of the initial pressings for the reissue. |
artificialbox
11.01.23 | very jealous Uzumaki, that repress looks so beautiful. Woulda bought one but Iām dead broke rn |
Uzumaki
11.01.23 | I know that feeling all too well, artificialbox. Hope things turn around for you soon!
@Asleep, can I rec something for the 35th of November?
Thursday - War All the Time |
mryrtmrnfoxxxy
11.01.23 | i don't understand how it's pxhc but Killdozer - Snakeboy if you got room |
Deez
11.01.23 | Breach - Kollapse
fk Just seen breacch rec
NEW GRASS Scordatura_Perforations |
Sniff
11.01.23 | Solid list this |
SandwichBubble
11.01.23 | Thank you for manifesting more days in November. I stand in awe of your power. |
Hawks
11.01.23 | Lmao |
Leatherneck
11.01.23 | Glassjaw - Worship and Tribute
ofc
|
KTDB
11.01.23 | Garrison - a mile in cold water
Bear vs shark - terrorhawk |
Hawks
11.01.23 | November 35th is my fav day of the year. |
AsleepInTheBack
11.01.23 | 40 recs is probably too much we did it for psych month so lets see how we go
probs CLOSed for recs unless concubinary would like to submit a replacement rec |
Mort.
11.01.23 | be quick mr asleep
i want to know what u say about my recs
also
a lot of this list is on my other list! |
AsleepInTheBack
11.01.23 | i should have just speedran your list alas that would not have been very community engagement-y now would it!?!
first one up we cooking with gas |
Mort.
11.01.23 | 'Tilebreaker and Shiska'
literally my least fav tracks on the album so good take, i stan u |
JohnnyoftheWell
11.01.23 | Tilebreaker is a classic and everyone loves it apart from you to schmucks wtf. Huge chorus, arguably *the* definitive Polvo song
Time Isn't On My Side is the greatest song ever made though so at least one point was scored |
Mort.
11.01.23 | lol i still love tilebreaker, its just one of my least favs
and funnily enough it was the polvo song i heard and got me into them |
AsleepInTheBack
11.01.23 | rejamming tilebreaker now and the pieces are starting to fall into place. great start to list overall probably a 4 im just being CONSERVATIVE do you get me |
Colliiiin
11.02.23 | Post-hardcore GOAT album is Fear Before the March of Flames - Always Open Mouth. Would also highly recommend: Boilermaker-In Wallace's Shadow
The Blood Brothers - Young Machetes
Crime in Stereo - ...Is Dead
Funeral Dine - The Underdark |
naughtcturnal
11.02.23 | big black - songs about fucking |
Vinnymcscoop
11.02.23 | Lower Than Atlantis - World Record |
SandwichBubble
11.02.23 | Guys, he's already added 10 extra days to the month of November, his power only goes so far.
Seriously though, @AsleepInTheBack thanks for including me despite being late. |
Conmaniac
11.02.23 | I rec 5 and 26 yes nice work ppl |
AsleepInTheBack
11.02.23 | Ye ima have to cut off recs here because otherwise i will die sorry people (I have also heard Always Open Mouth and Songs About Fucking) |
ArsMoriendi
11.02.23 | I canāt believe Mort recād you the wrong Brainiac album tho |
Mort.
11.02.23 | who cares stinky |
AsleepInTheBack
11.02.23 | Provisional thoughts on 2 |
JohnnyoftheWell
11.02.23 | 2 is the peak of the genre you have one job |
Mort.
11.02.23 | yeah 2 is a 4.5 of mine that is incredibly close to a 5 and will probs get there one day |
DadKungFu
11.02.23 | Heartwarming love for NPI which I listen to way more than Leaves for some reason |
AsleepInTheBack
11.03.23 | Updates on 1 and 2 this is gonna take fucking ages lol |
Mort.
11.03.23 | 'Worked surprisingly well as a shower album blared out of phone speakers (mort dont hate me)'
lol luv u |
MeatSalad
11.03.23 | 'Worked surprisingly well as a shower album blared out of phone speakers (mort dont hate me)'
Ah that's a weird feeling, I just did the same thing with this album yesterday. Can confirm it was a quality shower jam |
AsleepInTheBack
11.03.23 | Dude they werenāt supposed to know about our secret shower jam sessions ffs, now everyone will wanna hop in with us |
Mort.
11.03.23 | 'If WEEN made post-hardcore.'
hahahaha no wonder Ars loves them |
ArsMoriendi
11.03.23 | Weenās debut has a few songs that could register as post hardcore not gonna lie
Especially āOld Queen Coleā and āYou Fucked Upā |
ArsMoriendi
11.03.23 | But yeah Brainiac is certified good goofy music |
KTDB
11.03.23 | Thanks bro, don't sleep on Garrison though x |
MeatSalad
11.03.23 | "now everyone will wanna hop in with us"
The more the merrier, hop in peeps |
Veldin
11.04.23 | Young Machetes - The Blood Brothers |
someone
11.04.23 | Since Sniff already beat me to Drive Like Jehu, here's Hot Snakes - Audit in Progress |
Sniff
11.04.23 | Should've driven faster my friend |
someone
11.04.23 | I drive fast
But you drive like jehu |
Mort.
11.04.23 | hot cross shared a member with off minor so that comparison is pretty good |
Mort.
11.04.23 | and yeah i always thought hot cross were the ogs of that super twiddly diddly intricate post hardcore style that the fall of troy and then dance gavin dance popularised |
AsleepInTheBack
11.04.23 | eyyyyy my reference points werenāt entirely incorrect. is their og band Saetia worth the hype it seems to have??? may peek/peak |
Mort.
11.04.23 | yeah saetia are cool but much more of a skramz/emo band and the vocalist really changes from saetia to hot cross (hes super shrill in saetia) |
Sniff
11.04.23 | Saetia is better than the hype |
AsleepInTheBack
11.04.23 | I do like me some skramz hmmmmm but I donāt like me shrill vox hmmmm |
MeatSalad
11.04.23 | "yeah i always thought hot cross were the ogs of that super twiddly diddly intricate post hardcore style that the fall of troy and then dance gavin dance popularised"
Can confirm, peeps who knew were saying similar things about hot cross 15 years back |
AsleepInTheBack
11.05.23 | 5 and 6 up
*avoiding eye contact while initiating bombastic side eye* |
JohnnyoftheWell
11.05.23 | list is starting to give a whiff of meatheaded aggro hardcore withdrawal
will there be a redemption arc will this month be the one ben's angels (hi) are praying for woah the stakes are rising |
Mort.
11.05.23 | ok if you dont like 5 then get ready to have no fun for the rest of your life you dour faced music nerd |
AsleepInTheBack
11.05.23 | praises 2 and 4 for their quieter moments over their louder ones
scolds 5 for being too noisy
headheaded aggro hardcore withdrawal
uuuuhhhhhhh |
AsleepInTheBack
11.05.23 | Fair point though I am now craving a prolonged return to my bread and butter once this year is over BUT this has also been the most rewarding musical experience/journey/thing Iāve done in the best part of 5 years so there are linings to the silver etc |
Mort.
11.05.23 | im glad you thoroughly enjoyed 4/5 of my recs |
AsleepInTheBack
11.05.23 | and thank you for rec-ing them! fully intend to do an unwound discog run next year and polvo was the grower I wasnāt expecting. time isnāt on my side truly is the greeting thing of all of the things. |
Jash
11.05.23 | I might be too late, but this list desperately needs Armchairpolititian - Seven Segment Decoder |
Veldin
11.06.23 | Oh damn I forgot about armchairpolitician |
JohnnyoftheWell
11.06.23 | LOUD but not BEATDOWN is always gonna set off more withdrawal than QUIET but not BEATDOWN yes |
AsleepInTheBack
11.06.23 | Fair point actually yeah
Also apologies the inn is full and has no more room |
bellovddd
11.06.23 | i gotta check out 6 sounds good. |
AsleepInTheBack
11.06.23 | you should it good
7 up 8 is currently in my ear holes how did i make it almost 8 years into music exploration listening without listening to Thrice |
JohnnyoftheWell
11.06.23 | top 3 Thrice records used to be a mandatory registration question for all new users wtf
Beggars is kinda the best Thrice record for people who've grown out of Thrice, so either the worst or best place to start |
Zorg
11.06.23 | June of 44 |
AsleepInTheBack
11.06.23 | Also apologies the inn is full and has no more room [2]
Tho I really do wanna hear that armchairpolitician record hmm |
JohnFire
11.06.23 | lol I love how this list is a total mess because essentially there is post-hardcore and post-post-hardcore and on top of that there's stuff that's on the fringes of both types of phx making this mess complete :D
Either way, how the fuck does this list not include Underoath yet? I'd vote for a back to back of Only Chasing Safety and Define The Great Line
PS Shoutout to widow and get low for their additions, didn't think anyone but me would think to add Emanuel or TPTBUTET |
AsleepInTheBack
11.06.23 | if a genre needs two post-s to articulate its existence it needs a new name
i am relatively familiar with underoath though my ratings suggest otherwise
i am more surprised this didn't get more in the La Dispute kinda vein, but tbh im happy with the saturation of apparent 80s/90s 'classics' feels like it sets this up better as a proper genre intro |
porcupinetheater
11.06.23 | Is Beggars still post hardcore? I was always under the impression it was just alt rock by a band that has also played post hardcore?
But is post-hardcore skramz with songs that regularly pass 7 minutes and have extended instrumentals?
Or is it buttrock that scored in the 90th percentile on its standardized tests?
Or is it alt rock that's trying its hardest to dodge Arcade Fire associations? |
JohnnyoftheWell
11.06.23 | Beggars has maybe three post hardcore songs tops (opener/At The Last/Talking Through Glass) and it is a top 5 Radiohead album not a genre rec wow this silly silly shit is making me hungry |
MoM
11.06.23 | @Porc all of the above. |
AsleepInTheBack
11.06.23 | I see thank god I thought i was getting the hang of the genre borders and got confused and am now mostly back to not being confused |
porcupinetheater
11.06.23 | Also want to proactively hitch my wagon to the Yank Crime rec, lots of other killer records on this list and Yank Crime smokes 'em |
ashcrash9
11.07.23 | Beggars being your introduction to Thrice isn't ideal from a post-hardcore exploration standpoint since as you've just heard they've largely shedded its skin by then but it is my favorite Thrice and imo their best and most concise display of rock songcraft so I'm kinda tickled it got the nod here and that you mostly dug it |
Demon of the Fall
11.07.23 | whoa, this looks good. Am intrigued as to what you think of many releases here. Some undoubtedly cool shit I haven't heard too.
Presumably this is now closed as you are already bending the very fabric of time itself |
Demon of the Fall
11.07.23 | 'Also want to proactively hitch my wagon to the Yank Crime rec, lots of other killer records on this list and Yank Crime smokes 'em' (2)
yeah, I was just thinking that honestly |
LightAndGlass
11.07.23 | Gonna throw in my rec for Coheed and Cambria - The Second Stage Turbine Blade |
AsleepInTheBack
11.07.23 | yāall shop at some weird calendar shops there are NOT 41 days is November jfc |
AsleepInTheBack
11.08.23 | I got Finch and Clutch confused as bands 9 was not quite as expected |
Zac124
11.08.23 | Glad to see that you enjoyed Finch. It is definitely a big grower and has become one of my favourite 2000s albums. Love the huge Patton/Dillinger influences on it as well. |
Emim
11.08.23 | That Finch album is ace |
AsleepInTheBack
11.08.23 | Apologies re dismissive tone of 10 I am tired and drunk and willing to be convinced otherwise. Really just not a fan of those washed out vox. |
DadKungFu
11.08.23 | Some of my absolute favorites over the next week or so can't wait |
AsleepInTheBack
11.08.23 | Donāt you give me stage fright I swear to god |
Valkoor952
11.08.23 | I'll rec something more unique
Girls Against Boys - House of GVSB |
Sharenge
11.08.23 | should have been Illusion of Safety |
JohnnyoftheWell
11.08.23 | no question about that |
artificialbox
11.08.23 | Lync rating finna make me cry :'( |
DadKungFu
11.08.23 | If they're not your thing I'll do my best to keep my seething to a minimum |
AsleepInTheBack
11.09.23 | danke
eleven |
ashcrash9
11.09.23 | happy you dug the no knife record! Iām so late to them- heard that one for the first time last winter and itās prob been my most replayed album this year. replay value on those hooks for days |
bighubbabuddha
11.09.23 | So happy Beggars was enjoyed. Hugs! |
ashcrash9
11.09.23 | oh and have a blast with Yank Crime, that shit is furious. Iād been listening to post-hardcore for a decade before I heard that (I know, my bad) and it floored me on first listen |
AsleepInTheBack
11.09.23 | Literally had a huge giddy smile through my back to back first 2 listens of Yank Crime I have almost certainly underrated I think itās a future 4.5+ possibly the best rec of the entire year fucking hell |
AsleepInTheBack
11.09.23 | Also yes thanks ash and Buddha both excellent recs, No Knife in particular snuck up on me I was like āye this is niceā and then suddenly Iād listened to it 4 times back to back and was humming along and realising how seamlessly it all fits together for such a subtlety odd rock album. |
Mort.
11.09.23 | you listening to the yank crime bonus tracks?
hand over fist is one of my favourites |
artificialbox
11.09.23 | damn Iām excited to hear what you think of that Hot Snakes record after seeing how much you enjoyed Drive Like Jehu. They have the same vocalist and guitar players and are like a more fun/bouncy version of DLJ. |
AsleepInTheBack
11.10.23 | 12 / 13 outrageous back to back wtf
Mort no not jammed them yet
Also v hyped for Hot Snakes now yeeeee |
Sniff
11.10.23 | So much good stuff on here |
Mort.
11.10.23 | 'skronking skree of riff'
the skronking skree of riff skranks swiftly on the shore |
DadKungFu
11.10.23 | The ratings for the past 2 days got me giddy |
Demon of the Fall
11.10.23 | Yep. We did try and warn him DLJ may render the rest of the list milquetoast by comparison, lol
that NoMeansNo album is absolute fire as well, satisfying results |
AsleepInTheBack
11.10.23 | (Slightly) more cogent thoughts on 13 now up best records ever literally |
Ryus
11.10.23 | 5 :[ |
AsleepInTheBack
11.10.23 | 5 has alluded me for years and will continue to do so it seems cri
Big Dick is where itās at |
mryrtmrnfoxxxy
11.10.23 | such a nice list. i screenshot it up to this point, just n case u hit (X) instead of Edit by accident. idk about yall but i wish that (X) had an ...Are Ya Sure Bud? prompt. makes me nervous to edit a list |
AsleepInTheBack
11.10.23 | Lol good point Iāve made it 10 months without such an incident but you never can tell with me and my fat thumbs |
ArsMoriendi
11.10.23 | When listening to mine, remember to listen closely to the opener's lyrics, they're so good |
SlothcoreSam
11.10.23 | Don't let him cum in your shoe
Don't let him cum in your poo
Don't let him cum on your boob |
BitterJalapenoJr
11.10.23 | "i wish that (X) had an ...Are Ya Sure Bud? prompt. makes me nervous to edit a list"
Couldn't agree more. Shite my pants every time I edit. |
artificialbox
11.10.23 | i also just realized no one recced Hoover and now Iām mad |
Kompys2000
11.11.23 | Damn you have 2 hot snakes albums here and it's the wrong 2 :/ HOWEVER audit in progress has some tip top shit and all 4 r big worth if u fuck with DLJ
Also yuh Wrong is the greatest I just 5ed it :] |
AsleepInTheBack
11.11.23 | I think this list struggles with albums flip flopping between VERY different limbs of the genre, not as easy to flit between them as usual. initial thoughts only on 14 for now. had the sheer bad luck to come after 2 of the best albums of the entire list series. |
Mort.
11.11.23 | yeah 14 is more skramz than straight up post hardcore and you should boo whoever recced it |
AsleepInTheBack
11.11.23 | Boo @hawks |
MeatSalad
11.11.23 | Never really thought of 15 as post hardcore either but it's a goodun |
AsleepInTheBack
11.12.23 | Shitgoddamn 15 |
mryrtmrnfoxxxy
11.12.23 | Asleep and posthardcore sitting in a tree |
AsleepInTheBack
11.12.23 | s h i t i n g |
Mort.
11.12.23 | so far seems like you prefer old school post hardcore to the newer trends
|
Zac124
11.12.23 | Mr. Bungle, Botch and Refuse being mentioned in 12 and 13 makes me want to check them ngl. |
AsleepInTheBack
11.12.23 | @mort seems so. the intersections with noise and trad hardcore but with immaculate songwriting/musicianship have impressed me the most. the ways it interacts with alt rock / emo / grunge / indie arenāt grabbing me as readily. That being said, I have returned to 11 more than anything else here and will probs bump rating soon. Also bout to bump that nomeansno rating Jesus what a good album. |
Colliiiin
11.12.23 | It was rec'd earlier but u certainly have to check Fear Before the March of Flames - The Always Open Mouth. Is the GOAT imo. |
Mort.
11.12.23 | he already has that album 4d
goat lp agreed tho |
DadKungFu
11.12.23 | Huskers the GOAT |
ArsMoriendi
11.13.23 | Iām so ready |
Tb1114
11.13.23 | Modern Life is War - Witness
Gospel - The Moon is a Dead World |
AsleepInTheBack
11.13.23 | Check your calendar
Ars I feel weird hold me |
ArsMoriendi
11.13.23 | Lmao glad you liked it |
AsleepInTheBack
11.14.23 | Award for best guitar solos of all time goes to 17 |
BitterJalapenoJr
11.14.23 | Yass! Borderline Mascis levels of guitarwork. |
AsleepInTheBack
11.14.23 | I need to check dinosaur jr am stupid for not having already done so |
BitterJalapenoJr
11.14.23 | I do not like to say negative things about people but in this case, yes, you are. |
DadKungFu
11.14.23 | Man this Treepeople thing is really really good big Mascis energy on the solos like bitterpepper said |
AsleepInTheBack
11.14.23 | Yaaaaaas dad good innit?
I feel bad shitting on the album by Beloved recommended by user Beloveddd but there you go 18 not quite my tempo apologies |
ArsMoriendi
11.14.23 | Make next month indie rock month and someone will rec you Dino jr prob |
JohnnyoftheWell
11.14.23 | wasn't Treepeople Doug Martsch's og band or am i getting that mixed up?
but if so, Martsch's guitar heroics were always a sentimental level up on Mascis' |
bellovddd
11.14.23 | Failure on was the album that basically got me into post hardcore at that time! Thanks for checking it yo! |
BitterJalapenoJr
11.14.23 | "wasn't Treepeople Doug Martsch's og band or am i getting that mixed up?"
Correct
"Martsch's guitar heroics were always a sentimental level up on Mascis'"
I do not actually know any other Martsch project but Mascis is God. |
JohnnyoftheWell
11.14.23 | you must have heard built to spill? |
MeatSalad
11.14.23 | Built to Spill is Martsch's main gig. Some of the best guitar work in all of indie rock |
BitterJalapenoJr
11.14.23 | I have unacceptable gaps in my indie rock consumption which I'm currently attempting to rectify. Built to Spill is one. |
AsleepInTheBack
11.14.23 | Drum tone / prod on 19 blowing my mind rn |
someone
11.14.23 | "Someoneās review is amazing and more seductive than mine"
you're seductive as is bb |
DaveTrane
11.14.23 | ojne - Prima Che Tutto Bruci |
JohnnyoftheWell
11.14.23 | "Drum tone / prod on 19 blowing my mind rn"
lmfao y e s, can't think of another drummer in the genre who packs as much force |
AsleepInTheBack
11.14.23 | @someone Merci mon saucisson
Also beloveddd thank you for recing it apologies I didnāt love it but appreciate you taking the 2.5 like a champ big hugs |
Emim
11.14.23 | 2.5
UNSUBSCRIBE |
Ryus
11.14.23 | this is mostly a rly good list, some classics still to come m/ |
AsleepInTheBack
11.15.23 | It has turned out surprisingly excellent for a genre Iāve intentionally avoided for half a decade oops
NINETEEN |
Sniff
11.15.23 | Let's goooo RoC |
cylinder
11.15.23 | NUM-HEAVYMETALLIC by Number Girl is also very good.
RoC LFG!!!! |
AsleepInTheBack
11.15.23 | im in danger |
Mort.
11.15.23 | did u just put shrill guitar skrees as a con?
listen here u little bitch |
AsleepInTheBack
11.15.23 | donāt you skronk me boi |
widowslaugh123
11.15.23 | When I was 12 I thought at the drive in sucked. Then my turned 13ā¦
Now im in my 30s and they alright I guess |
AsleepInTheBack
11.15.23 | i am 27 (i think) what does this mean for me. read my tea. |
DadKungFu
11.15.23 | I need to know your feelings on One Armed Scissor |
AsleepInTheBack
11.15.23 | It is the song that I remember being played on the airways and I did not find it as objectionable as I remember |
Mort.
11.15.23 | hey we are the same age
lets kiss under the music tree |
AsleepInTheBack
11.15.23 | sure, why not, just to break the tension |
Hawks
11.15.23 | 3 for State Faults???????? |
AsleepInTheBack
11.15.23 | 3 for state faults |
Hawks
11.15.23 | Blasphemy. |
Kompys2000
11.15.23 | "Cedric's complete inability to hit literally any musical notes"
Ur right and u should say it lol |
ashcrash9
11.15.23 | "if/when I learn the lyrics and can screm along this..." solves the "Cedric's complete inability to hit literally any musical notes" part. patience, ben |
sspedding
11.15.23 | Your opinion on Beloved is straight up dumb.
Putting that aside - Static Dress - Rouge Carpet Disaster |
hesperus
11.15.23 | you know what that's fair re:RoC. i'll take a 3.7 as a win |
AsleepInTheBack
11.16.23 | @sspedding id offer you one of my fucks but Iām afraid I donāt have any left to give, apologies
I figured being able to howl along with Cedric would probs be cathartic and breathless and fun we shall see innit and also thanks for the rec hesp, was hoping someone would rec it relatively late in the list to give with an opportunity to give it another go |
JohnnyoftheWell
11.16.23 | Tuneless rampage Cedric is definitely an acquired taste (and put me off for a long while - Thrice and Glassjaw were much bigger gateways) but the man channels adrenaline a treat when it clicks
Your intuition on Deloused was correct though, and you should hold that album to blame for all your bad ATDI takes past and future |
AsleepInTheBack
11.16.23 | Finding the adrenaline shot less of an irritant this morning when Iām not commuting to London the TUBE fucking SUCKS |
AsleepInTheBack
11.16.23 | Kompys my child gosh you legend 21 is insane |
artificialbox
11.17.23 | on the edge of my freakin seat waiting for 23. thats been a personal 5 of mine for a long time. |
AsleepInTheBack
11.17.23 | Have now heard 22 but uh no cogent thoughts have formed in brain after a shitshow at work please hold |
AsleepInTheBack
11.17.23 | Friendly reminder that 21 is amazeballs and only has 2 ratings and you all need to go and change that |
mryrtmrnfoxxxy
11.17.23 | i listened to super thief's latest ep last week and it was good / promising. found em digging thru noise rock threads on rym i think. im excited to check their album now. 21 |
mryrtmrnfoxxxy
11.17.23 | o nope it was the Texas Noise Rock list on there. Texas Noise Rock fucks |
mryrtmrnfoxxxy
11.17.23 | im back to confirm 21 kicks ass and here goes: yup 21 kicks ass. i bought it for $5 on their bandcamp |
JohnnyoftheWell
11.17.23 | next two (probably three but i still gotta peep 2xNickels) days are overpowered
and Suicide Invoice ain't no slouch either |
Kompys2000
11.18.23 | List is BIG even by the standards of this very big series loving ur writeups |
AsleepInTheBack
11.18.23 | Breathe is probs an actual genuine perfect song (22)
Still figuring out my true desires re the rest of the tracks none of these albums (bar the three 4.5s) and probs 21 have been easy to form views on idk why itās not as easy as noise month where it was like āyo yeah thatās noisy and coolā or psych month where it was like āoh yeah I feel stoned now sweeeeā itās like āoh fuck songwriting ima have to put these pieces togetherā I am tired |
Ryus
11.18.23 | savory is the perfect phxc song |
AsleepInTheBack
11.18.23 | Also currently terrified by the 40 plus tracks of x2 nickel jfc |
Emim
11.18.23 | Glad you dug 23, almost makes up for the Beloved slander |
AsleepInTheBack
11.18.23 | We have a suggestions box pls direct your grievances and gripes in its vicinity |
Emim
11.18.23 | *gestures toward a paper shredder in the corner* |
AsleepInTheBack
11.18.23 | *tries to avoid making eye contact while turning on paper shredder* |
Sniff
11.18.23 | LFG Doubles Nickles |
Mort.
11.18.23 | 22 better grow u silly goose |
AsleepInTheBack
11.18.23 | Mort 3.7 means I like it hush now |
Mort.
11.18.23 | yeah but its a 4.5 |
AsleepInTheBack
11.18.23 | No it is a 3.7 (see above) |
Mort.
11.18.23 | oh sorry |
AsleepInTheBack
11.19.23 | Prelim thoughts on 24 itās a hefty boi |
widowslaugh123
11.19.23 | Nickels is great but you gotta check some of the early minutemen stuff. What makes a man start fires is fire š„ |
DadKungFu
11.19.23 | Hell yeah minutemen is the sauce dusting off my copy of double nickels for a throwback jam now |
AsleepInTheBack
11.19.23 | Itās such a charming album jeeeeeez
Trying to listen to it in 4 portions as per the 4 sides and see if it makes it easier to digest |
AsleepInTheBack
11.20.23 | More cogent thoughts on 24 and a quickie for 25 now I have to go to work |
Mort.
11.20.23 | very dlj because they share members i think |
Demon of the Fall
11.20.23 | Hot Cross buns brings the junz...
well, not really, but it is pretty good regardless. Cool |
sonictheplumber
11.20.23 | its all crap. |
MeatSalad
11.20.23 | sonic bruh there's no fuckin way you don't at least dig Double Nickels |
AsleepInTheBack
11.20.23 | 26 I am fucking tired having a job should be illegal |
widowslaugh123
11.20.23 | Yeah I wasnāt like super overly impressed with the plot for awhile. I think I had it 2.5ād initially. Over the years tho itās become one of favorite records. SLC hunks has the catchiest chorus ever |
Mort.
11.20.23 | i love when they go 'wooo' on 26 |
AsleepInTheBack
11.20.23 | wooo
Is their debut worth a spin it seems to have more traction behind it at least here and on rym |
widowslaugh123
11.20.23 | Definitely worth a spin. Way less snotty and more jazzy and shit but still pretty ugly. It fucks. |
AsleepInTheBack
11.21.23 | ayayayayayayayayayaya 27 |
Drifter
11.21.23 | kolya - kolya |
AsleepInTheBack
11.21.23 | Drifter look at the time
28
Also
Up |
Mort.
11.21.23 | cant wait for you to finish this list so i can just ctrl + f 'skronk' and see whats what |
frozencarl
11.21.23 | commenting so i can czech some of these but also leaving my personal fave in case you keep going:
The Receiving End of Sirens - Between the Heart and the Synapse
|
Kompys2000
11.22.23 | Top 10 Froberg tunes rn
Psychoactive
Here Come the Rome Plows
If Credit's What Matters I'll Take Credit
Death Camp Fantasy
Super Unison
This Mystic Decade
Automatic Midnight
Death of a Sportsman
Braintrust
Our Work Fills the Pews |
bellovddd
11.22.23 | ooo my poor beloved. not the worst here though so far so thats something lol |
Demon of the Fall
11.22.23 | 3.5 'with upside' seems about right for Hot Cross, t'was a good check. The highs are rather satisfying
probably pick at a few more of these tasty morsels |
MeatSalad
11.22.23 | @Kompys I've only heard Yank Crime so far but I can't imagine Luau not making my top 10 |
mryrtmrnfoxxxy
11.22.23 | can't wait for killdozer day. everyone here oughta check killdozer |
MeatSalad
11.22.23 | Is Brother, Sister really post-hardcore? Eh sure why not |
AsleepInTheBack
11.22.23 | 29 and 30 we cooking with gas |
Mort.
11.22.23 | fugazi sick yeah
the argument one of their best yeah
4.5 right rating
|
Mort.
11.22.23 | also im not really sure what 33 is doing on this list
more of a metal album if i recall correctly |
AsleepInTheBack
11.22.23 | The more Iāve heard from this list the more Iām convinced either (a) post hard core is a complicated / overly broad genre label or (b) I am being recād a few s t r e t c h records. Keeps it interesting though, like leaving it a bit open to interpretation and minimal rec screening. |
JohnnyoftheWell
11.22.23 | 3 waves
3 waves |
Mort.
11.22.23 | 5 waves and a beach littered with dead emos |
AsleepInTheBack
11.22.23 | Explain the waves
Knowledge me
Thank |
JohnnyoftheWell
11.22.23 | 1st wave = 90s paintstripper (fugazi/jawbox/unwound/DLJ/80s proto shit)
2nd wave = 00s scenecore, sasscore, commercially adjacent stuff (glassjaw/ATDI/thursday/thrice/la dispute)
3rd wave = 10s helium-voiced dweedle skramz that rip off hot cross/the fall of troy and likely have their masters owned by a member of Dance Gavin Dance
nowadays 3rd wave is in the process of collapsing into a long overdue grave and 2nd wave is being periodically revived, but that's the scheme of it |
Mort.
11.22.23 | yeah that about covers all the bases
you could divide it up more but it would be a bit superfluous
(the 2nd wave was a real clusterfuck)
|
JohnnyoftheWell
11.22.23 | 2nd wave was a total fuckin mess and probably the main source of asleep's confusion, but the highs are as good as anything that 1st wave dished out even if the lows were catastrophic
3rd wave was where it all went to shit. grab those A Lot Like Birds records and run for the hills before they hit their use-by dates |
DadKungFu
11.22.23 | Oh shit how is nobody talking about Mclusky |
JohnnyoftheWell
11.22.23 | save that one for December of Bummy Garage Rock |
Kompys2000
11.23.23 | Top 5 2nd wave PxHxCx albums plz?? Im pretty sure I'm a filthy 1st wave truther for this genre prove me wrong |
JohnnyoftheWell
11.23.23 | worship and tribute and just a moment (top 2 by a reasonable distance)
catch for us the foxes
the illusion of safety
no devolucion
and then tick off the always open mouth, fall of troy s/t and 19, 23, revisit RoC, and you're just about done |
Mort.
11.23.23 | throw in some blood brothers or other sassy nonsense
|
MeatSalad
11.23.23 | thank fuck the dgd inspired wave is dying but also pls die faster |
JohnnyoftheWell
11.23.23 | yeah chase with a token blood brothers or these arms are snakes record for optics' sake |
DadKungFu
11.23.23 | And You Will Know Us By The Trail of Dead erasure, also Samuel Johnson quote about if you're tired of Mclusky you're tired of life |
Kompys2000
11.23.23 | Hmmm seeming like a mixed bag but fear before and mwY are both legit. The these arms are snakes EP I got the other day ain't too shabby either
Still gotta check worship and tribute in full sometime, like "mu empire" tho |
MeatSalad
11.23.23 | Never really thought of Trail of Dead as post hardcore, I guess some of their early stuff fits the bill |
AsleepInTheBack
11.23.23 | Cool thanks Johnny/Mort etc thatās helpful, seems like I prefer wave 1 to the others. |
AsleepInTheBack
11.23.23 | 31 innit |
Mort.
11.23.23 | propah british post hardcore innit |
MeatSalad
11.23.23 | Isn't it is it innit, |
GhandhiLion
11.23.23 | I heckin love zen arcade too |
GhandhiLion
11.23.23 | I never thought about wrong being pro ratm before. That's interesting |
MeatSalad
11.23.23 | Also yeah 31 is definitely inconsistent (Agony/Agatha bleh) but otherwise hits the right notez |
AsleepInTheBack
11.23.23 | @ghandi it may be a stretch comparison, as WRONG is so much more PUNK in tone than RATM, but thereās something in the bass-forward grooves and occasional rap-bar cadence to the vox on WRONG that made my brain go āooh a linkā
It is also the 32nd of November |
AsleepInTheBack
11.24.23 | And now the 33rd |
AsleepInTheBack
11.25.23 | And now the 34th |
artificialbox
11.25.23 | can't believe you've already fit 34 days into 25, you're a champ! |
AsleepInTheBack
11.26.23 | Gearing up for December but heck we got recs to jam first
I have achieved bingo on my sputcore card where is my prize |
SandwichBubble
11.27.23 | Late, but glad you liked bitch magnet |
AsleepInTheBack
11.27.23 | Thank you for rec-ing weird good record |
AsleepInTheBack
11.27.23 | 36 up |
JohnnyoftheWell
11.27.23 | unfortunately for you, Thursday are one of the only bands of the 2nd wave whose lyrics are worth deep diving, and AsleepInTheChapel is the upgrade you've been pushing for without realising it |
Ryus
11.27.23 | justice for thursday |
AsleepInTheBack
11.27.23 | *looks at shoes* |
AsleepInTheBack
11.28.23 | 37/38 two to go |
Emim
11.28.23 | By now I know you're gonna low rate every 00s band but it hurts just the same |
Mort.
11.28.23 | excited to see what you think of the last two, real classics there |
AsleepInTheBack
11.28.23 | I didnāt realise I was such a poser I do apologise.
38 is from 2021 and is fucking fire though you should all check |
AsleepInTheBack
11.28.23 | I have been dreading 39 just as I dreaded 20 but am hopeful |
DadKungFu
11.28.23 | DJUN DJUN DJUN DJUN DJUNANANA DJUN DJUN DJUN DJUN
DJUN DJUN DJUN DJUN DJUNANANA DJUN DJUN DJUN DJUN |
AsleepInTheBack
11.28.23 | Prelim thoughts on the djun djun djuns (39) |
Zac124
11.28.23 | 39 is a grower I think. Stuck Pig slaps so fucking hard though. |
bellovddd
11.28.23 | every time i see that 2.5 i feel very humbled. |
Uzumaki
11.28.23 | Shame to see the indifference on Thursday |
BlazinBlitzer
11.28.23 | Very well-written write-up on the Brother, Sister rec is much appreciated! |
cylinder
11.29.23 | Singing/screaming along was def always a huge part of my enjoyment of 20 and 39, so good intuition there. Those are prob two of my favorite vocal performances of all time. Hope they grow on ya man |
cylinder
11.29.23 | Also what a brilliant way to describe Darylās vocals, especially the ābouncy castleā part. You nailed it, and it made me chuckle haha |
AsleepInTheBack
11.29.23 | Youāre too kind I hope they both grow on me too I am experiencing FOMO re the adoration thrown their way and want to be a part of it arg
Also cheers blitzer
Also apologies for the low rates but I mean honesty is a policy that is good |
AsleepInTheBack
11.29.23 | Opinions? Completed em mate [40] |
widowslaugh123
11.29.23 | I always really liked the closer on terrorhawk |
mryrtmrnfoxxxy
11.29.23 | yeah this list rules thanks for takin the time
re:killdozer yeah idk why it's tagged pxhc on rym and last.fm. i did take advantage lol. maybe influence? they started rippin in 83 or 84. glad you dug it |
Emim
11.29.23 | Not sure if you're done with this for now (or forever) but I see you don't have As Cities Burn - Come Now Sleep rated. That one is a must listen imo |
AsleepInTheBack
11.29.23 | Technically we finished a day early, hmmmmmmm, could give it a go |
AsleepInTheBack
11.29.23 | Also ye surprised that killdozer are so early in the space time continuum but then again swans started 1983 so kinda fits |
MeatSalad
11.30.23 | Final thoughts? Are you enlightened or still confused as to what post hardcore even means? |
AsleepInTheBack
11.30.23 | I am enlightened (probably). Guitar music can do more things than I thought guitar music could do. Genre is still a hot mess - the fact it intersects with alt rock indie rock grunge math rock metalcore emo noise rock punk AND hardcore still hurts my head - but I at least understand what the first wave and second wave are now. Swancore still alludes me and maybe thatās a good thing as I donāt like DGD. |
Mort.
11.30.23 | *eludes xxx |
AsleepInTheBack
11.30.23 | Mort donāt be a pedant nobody likes pedants my primary school teacher told me I would never learn how to spell and she was write rite right |
Demon of the Fall
11.30.23 | 'post' does tend to be a vague genre descriptor generally, whatever you combine it with (for obvious reasons), but post-hxc is indeed confusing as hell.
I've been listening to (some) stuff like this on and off for what must be nearly two decades now, yet I still don't feel all that enlightened. |
Deez
11.30.23 | Yayyu glad you liked 38 bro, been trying to get mates to jam it since it dropped. |
AsleepInTheBack
11.30.23 | It is the brilliant uncut hidden gem of the list for sure - everyone jam 38!!!!! |
AsleepInTheBack
12.31.23 | Thanks for all the fish: https://www.sputnikmusic.com/list.php?listid=204937 |