ArsMoriendi
08.31.14 | 3 is way too high in my opinion and 4 kind of sucks. 6, 10 and 11 are way too low... |
ExplosiveOranges
08.31.14 | 7 is too low |
adr
08.31.14 | worst ranking ever |
deathschool
08.31.14 | Whoa son. This is wrong. |
Royl123
08.31.14 | My top 5 would be 1, 7, 6, 3, 10 but unique list nonetheless... |
danielcardoso
08.31.14 | who else is stoked for the endless river? |
YakNips
08.31.14 | 2 is 1 tbh |
BMDrummer
08.31.14 | @danielcardoso i'm dreading it |
Artuma
08.31.14 | "who else is stoked for the endless river?"
already forgot about it |
MeatSalad
08.31.14 | 7 and 6 are just way too high |
danielcardoso
08.31.14 | 7 is too high? |
TalonsOfFire
08.31.14 | 2 and 4? Is this a joke? |
Veldin
08.31.14 | 3 is way too high, but otherwise good list. I really love Ummagumma too. |
Artuma
08.31.14 | 3 is the only one here i wouldn't place completely differently |
InFlamesWeThrash666
08.31.14 | Well,i didn't see that comin' |
MyNameIsPencil
08.31.14 | 3 is too high
7 is 1 |
jtswope
08.31.14 | Well our rankings would be almost nothing alike but hey it's Floyd so all's well. |
eddie95
08.31.14 | 8 > 9
agreed |
Torontonian
08.31.14 | i highly disagree with basically all of this. |
Avagantamos
08.31.14 | really bad list |
Jasdevi087
08.31.14 | Agreed, More is unrankable. But I think we can all agree that my list wins. |
Artuma
08.31.14 | "I think we can all agree that my list wins."
>"14 Pink Floyd
Obscured By Clouds"
eh |
emester
08.31.14 | No
just fucking no |
Jasdevi087
09.01.14 | Hey, it's still only 11 on this one. |
erizen826
09.01.14 | First off 7 is 1. This ranking is all types of fucked up. |
TheShining1980
09.01.14 | I liked the Final Cut for songs like, The Hero's Return, Not Now John, and the Final Cut. Also, I thought Ummagumma was really unique, with songs like Several Species of Small Furry Animals and the Grand Viser's Garden Party. Fill free to disagree, I can see why people don't like those two albums in particular, but to be honest, numbers 1-7 are what I consider to be Pink Floyd's best albums, 8-10 to be the good, but not great albums, 11, to be meh, and 12 and 13 sucked. |
Artuma
09.01.14 | "13 sucked." |
TheShining1980
09.01.14 | I take it you liked the Division Bell? |
Artuma
09.01.14 | it's a great album why wouldn't i? |
Torontonian
09.01.14 | ^i agree DB and MLOR are very underrated. |
TheShining1980
09.01.14 | Huh. I have actually never met someone who liked the Division Bell. |
Torontonian
09.01.14 | Its a good album. Doesn't even come close to the floyd classics but its gr8 and very enjoyable. nonetheless |
Artuma
09.01.14 | "I have actually never met someone who liked the Division Bell."
i assume you haven't met too many people |
TheShining1980
09.01.14 | Really? Perhaps I need to listen to it again. Did you like Momentary Lapse? |
Torontonian
09.01.14 | ^I enjoy lapse a lot. Not as good as DB but still gr8. |
frigyourgenre
09.01.14 | eww 4 |
Xar
09.01.14 | 7 is 1
10 is 2
3 is awful |
wwf
09.01.14 | Pink Floyd is probably one of the few bands I've heard like seven albums from and I still feel like I'm sleeping on most of their discog |
TheShining1980
09.01.14 | I am surprised The Wall seems to getting a lot of hate. I was under the impression it was their most loved (or one of the) seeing it had its own movie (which I love) and it has a 5.0 classic rating on the review page. Can people please tell me why The Wall (and Final Cut) are hated (on here anyways). |
wwf
09.01.14 | The wall isnt as innovative sound wise throughout as some or their other albums
The concept is really great and really well executed though |
Jasdevi087
09.02.14 | theshining DB is my 1. |
MeatSalad
09.02.14 | i appreciate how high you put 5 |
facupm
09.02.14 | interesting ranking, although 2 seems way too high and 7 way too low |
TheSpaceMan
09.02.14 | "8 > 9"
the math part of me is cringing right now |
facupm
09.02.14 | lol imo its 9>8 so im good at maths |
