Cipieron
04.12.12 | dunno about 9, i think it deserves the praise it gets |
stabbler
04.12.12 | 6 for sure |
Tyrael
04.12.12 | how is 10 overrated |
climactic
04.12.12 | none of these really get massive amounts of praise besides 1,2,7 and maybe 6. and for the most part they deserve it |
SpiritCrusher2
04.12.12 | 10 is actually underrated IMO
and fuck off from MoP |
Parallels
04.12.12 | Definitely agree with 1
but not 2 no |
climactic
04.12.12 | 9 has some insanely good guitar playing |
Cipieron
04.12.12 | yeah, listening to 9 now.. no way it's overrated |
macadoolahicky
04.12.12 | I'm gonna have to say no.... |
RunOfTheMill
04.13.12 | Totally agree with 1 and 6, though a lot of people dislike 6 on this site. |
Irving
04.13.12 | How is 6 overrated? |
stabbler
04.13.12 | cause people talk about it in the same breathe as some of their actual classic stuff |
Scoot
04.13.12 | albums i do not like therefore overrated |
Shuyin
04.13.12 | albums i do not like therefore overrated [2] |
TheNotrap
04.13.12 |
|
AllGabrielsAreGlass
04.13.12 | Honestly? lists like these are getting annoying as all hell. |
Buccaneer
04.13.12 | 7, 5 and 2 are all great. I agree that 1 is a tad overrated, but it's still fucking awesome
|
thumbcrusher
04.13.12 | wtf who overrates 5? |
JohnnyoftheWell
04.13.12 | List is totally dumb, apart from maybe 1 |
thumbcrusher
04.13.12 | idk i see it as a classic so all the praise it gets is fine by me. |
AllGabrielsAreGlass
04.13.12 | lol |
blastOFFitsPARTYtime
04.13.12 | 1, 1, 1 and 1 are correct. |
SpiritCrusher2
04.13.12 | 1 is not overrated for the last time. if anything it's underrated on this site |
blastOFFitsPARTYtime
04.13.12 | 4.4 overall is underrated? |
SpiritCrusher2
04.13.12 | for that album - yes.
4.5 would be ok :D |
SpiritCrusher2
04.13.12 | but I'm a fanboy I guess, so nvm |
rockandmetaljunkie
04.13.12 | ok, so you throw this list but you don't care to explain why these are overrated. |
Venpts16
04.13.12 | I would like to first say that I'm surprised at how much this blew up; I expected some apprehension but not this much. That said, my only intention was to create a list of albums that I think are overrated compared to other material of the band's themselves; as I personally prefer a Paradise Lost compared to a Divine Wings of Tragedy, or Kill 'Em All to Master of Puppets, and so on and so forth. I do not consider these albums to be bad or awful at all; I just feel that they are overlooked compared to the other, sometimes better, material bands put out. I thank you all for your criticism of this list, and I'll keep them in mind for the next one I make. |
facupm
06.10.12 | Among The Living is not overrated, but perhaps a bit underrated.... |
YoYoMancuso
06.10.12 | no to 7, it's in their top 3 best albums |
