DaisyHill
08.24.11 | Albums are ones that filled the first two catagorys but i just cant connect with so they stay at 4.5 |
AngelofDeath
08.24.11 | it has to be gud |
MO
08.24.11 | and br00tal |
Relinquished
08.24.11 | and with lyrics as deep as her throat |
Divine
08.24.11 | An album that sounds just as good backwards |
Trebor.
08.24.11 | It has to be better than a 4.5 |
rockandmetaljunkie
08.24.11 | It must have an impact of awesomeness in you. |
MountainDewMe
08.24.11 | An album that I can listen to over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and not get bored of it. I only have two 5's. |
AliW1993
08.24.11 | If it feels right, simple as that
Must be better than amazing |
DominionMM1
08.24.11 | "They are: every track must standout as an amazing song, the album must also have several saongs that stand out even greater than the rest of the songs on the album, most importantly i must form and emotional connection"
^This. And it has to be a landmark album in a specific genre, where the effects can be heard in subsequent bands years later.
|
DaisyHill
08.24.11 | @Dominion
Alexisonfie's 'Watch Out!' fits every one of those catagorys including yours |
WeepingBanana
08.24.11 | if i put the album on and i make love to a woman and it takes her less than 3 minutes to cum, it's a 5 |
DominionMM1
08.24.11 | @Dominion
Alexisonfie's 'Watch Out!' fits every one of those catagorys including yours
Yeah, except the whole amazing song thing. |
lucasjcockcroft
08.24.11 | how many time i listen to it. if i find myself wanting to listen to it over and over, then its a 5 |
Megadeth
08.24.11 | if it has good riffs and trems then its a 5 |
Eko
08.24.11 | actually how you define a 5 is startlingly close to how I define a 5, so I'd just stick with what you said originally. |
Sowing
08.24.11 | i don't have a definition for my 5's
i just rate stuff a 5 when it obviously is |
Emim
08.24.11 | i just 5 things indiscriminately. |
foreverendeared
08.24.11 | yeah |
Romulus
08.24.11 | 2 and 3 |
Mewcopa0
08.24.11 | fuck romulus. i was just gonna post that |
Romulus
08.24.11 | you can have 1 and 4 if you like |
Skweetis
08.24.11 | If every track is great and memorable. Or if the music transcends the genre. |
luschlotz
08.24.11 | Gotta be:
Unique
FLow as an album
EMotional connection
You cant decide your favorites cause theyre all awesome
Time test
|
Antipunk
08.24.11 | I seriously believe that emotional connection is not required. Hard to connect to most metal when its about satan and dragons. however, it can still be a 5. Just has to take over your life for a month and its a 5. |
Trebor.
08.24.11 | Hard to connect to most metal when its about satan and dragons
Not cool man |
FromDaHood
08.24.11 | If I like it a lot more than other music, it's a 5 |
Trebor.
08.24.11 | My favorite albums are my 5s
It's that simple |
luschlotz
08.24.11 | "I seriously believe that emotional connection is not required. Hard to connect to most metal when its about satan and dragons. however, it can still be a 5. Just has to take over your life for a month and its a 5."
An emotional connection doesnt mean just lyrically, it means as if the album was your friend, and you understand it perfectly |
Eko
08.24.11 | every track must standout as an amazing song, the album must also have several saongs that stand out even greater than the rest of the songs on the album, most importantly you must form and emotional connection or the album as without this the album is 4.5 |
singthewordhope
08.24.11 | an album is a 5 if its awesome
why worry about a criteria or validity when no one cares about your ratings but you |
Josh D.
08.24.11 | "What Realy Makes A '5'?"
One horizontal line, one vertical line, and a backwards "c".
Not what you were looking for? |
