Drunk
11.02.10 | Check this stuff out if you havent yet |
ShadowRemains
11.02.10 | stone temple pilots |
MassiveAttack
11.02.10 | I do not like Hater at all, but the rest are great |
Spec
11.02.10 | Good list. |
MassiveAttack
11.02.10 | STP is so boring :(, everything except Purple isn't even worth getting tbh |
coneren
11.02.10 | god damnit |
bungy
11.02.10 | What the fuck is 10, and is there a good song on 6 besides the title track? |
Spec
11.02.10 | Haterz gonna hate. |
Dryden
11.02.10 | yeah |
fr33convict
11.02.10 | everything except Purple isn't even worth getting tbh
but Core is like just as good. |
bungy
11.02.10 | forgot to mention, good list |
bungy
11.02.10 | Except Badmotorfinger is the best grunge album ever. |
JWT155
11.02.10 | 9 should be higher. I think it has Chris's best vocal performance ever. |
bungy
11.02.10 | Love it when Chris just fucken wails |
MassiveAttack
11.02.10 | Core is sooo generic I can't stand it brah |
Josh D.
11.02.10 | 2 not being 1 is autofail. |
North0House
11.02.10 | Silverchair- Frogstomp? That stuff is good.
|
Josh D.
11.02.10 | What? Silverchair being in this conversation is massive lolworthy. |
North0House
11.02.10 | Lol, ah I love that album though. In a sense, it is grunge. But hey, nostalgia gets to me lol. |
Josh D.
11.02.10 | Frogstomp was actually the first album I ever bought, but I didn't know what it was. I just got it; I loved it while I had it around 12 years old. |
JWT155
11.02.10 | I still like it... don't judge me! |
North0House
11.02.10 | Ah for me, it was stupid Relient K, which is like my least favorite band now lol. It's pretty good stuff though, even if it's one of those starter bands/albums. Mainly just Sons of Israel. |
Josh D.
11.02.10 | I will judge you until you don't like it. |
qwe3
11.02.10 | 2 isnt even grunge wtf |
Josh D.
11.02.10 | Whatever anyone considers 2, it's the best thing here. |
Josh D.
11.02.10 | Lol A7X |
xfearbefore
11.02.10 | Good list, but lack of Nevermind is troubling. Should always be on these types of lists. |
Josh D.
11.02.10 | Nirvana sucks a fat dick, so the lack of them makes sense. |
Gmork89
11.02.10 | Dirt is #1 |
couldwinarabbit
11.02.10 | no #3 is #1. Nevermind is #2...the rest don't matter |
Emim
11.02.10 | couldwinamabbit |
qwe3
11.02.10 | "Good list, but lack of Nevermind is troubling. Should always be on these types of lists. "
but that album sucks ass
also pearl jam is great but aic is the best band on this list
or screaming trees |
DinoX
11.02.10 | Where is the Smashing Pumpkins? |
accompliceofmydeath
11.02.10 | Needs Green River. |
BigHans
11.02.10 | I agree with 1, 2, 5, 7, and 9 |
BigHans
11.02.10 | not if its a ranked list |
Josh D.
11.02.10 | Yeah, take that. |
BigHans
11.02.10 | He took it |
AliW1993
11.02.10 | Great list |
MasBarHigeuoris21
11.02.10 | Alice in Chains should be ranked higher especially considering they are among the only one of those bands (the other band being Pearl Jam, but not all of their albums have been good) still making good, new music. |
Josh D.
11.02.10 | It is NOT correct as a RANKED list. |
BigHans
11.02.10 | hes right, bc 2 is the greatest grunge album eva |
porch
11.02.10 | decent list but you're missing a lot of the best stuff. and pearl jam shouldn't be here. some proto-grunge/grunge/whatever the fuck you want to call it:
Melvins – Gluey Porch Treatments
Wipers – Youth of America
Green River – Come On Down
Steel Pole Bathtub – Lurch EP
The U-Men – Step On A Bug
The Fluid - Roadmouth
Mudhoney – Superfuzz Bigmuff EP
Mudhoney - S/T
Tad – 8-Way Santa
Tad - God's Balls
Soundgarden – Ultramega OK
Screaming Trees - Sweet Oblivion
Afghan Whigs - Gentlemen
Various Artists – Sub Pop 200
The Thrown Ups – Melancholy Girlhole
Skin Yard - 1000 Smiling Knuckles |
BigHans
11.02.10 | Torn like an Old Dollar Bill |
qwe3
11.02.10 | its not even grunge |
porch
11.02.10 | yeah its the opposite in a lot of ways |
qwe3
11.02.10 | 2 is a great album though |
KeithStone582
11.02.10 | Needs Nevermind and Vs. |
Cavs
11.02.10 | No Afghan Whigs = Invalid list |
yetanotherprofile
11.02.10 | Pumpkins? |
ShadowRemains
11.02.10 | "Needs Nevermind and Vs."
no it doesn't
|
TheSpirit
11.02.10 | Mother Love Bone isn't really grunge tbqh |
BisayaBoi
11.03.10 | Core by STP is SOO underrated. |
LepreCon
11.03.10 | 2
5
1
3
Can live without the rest |
Josh D.
11.03.10 | Nevermind, lol. |
LepreCon
11.03.10 | Nevermind is great but their other two albums are better |
ReturnToRock
11.03.10 | NO! No grunge list without Nevermind! Bad list! Bad, baaad list!
*smacks list over the snout with newspaper!* |
Josh D.
11.03.10 | Nevermind should only be on lists about shit. |
ReturnToRock
11.03.10 | How is Nevermind shit? I've been trying to understand you people and can't. Does one song being overplayed on the radio (a GREAT song BTW) invalidate the great riffs, the solid drumming, the memorable choruses, etc etc etc...?
Please explain. Also, please clarify why and how In Utero is BETTER than fucking Nevermind! If you wanna talk about underwhelming pieces of shit... |
Josh D.
11.03.10 | Great riffs? Try boring and amateur. Solid drumming? More like couldn't-be-more-run-of-the-mill-standard rock drumming. Memorable choruses? For what, Cobain's horrid voice? Etc, etc, etc... |
Cavs
11.03.10 | Steve Albini is why In Utero is better then Nevermind.
Although they both are not that good. |
ReturnToRock
11.03.10 | Excuse me?! Drum break at the beggining of Smells?! Massive boss?!
*thud ta-ta-thud ta-ta-thud ta-ta-thud ta-ta*
Quick, sing three choruses from Nevermind!! ......................See what I mean about memorable? |
Josh D.
11.03.10 | I don't know three choruses from Nevermind, but even if I did, catchiness doesn't make music good by itself. |
ReturnToRock
11.03.10 | 1 - "with the lights out, it's less dangerous!"
2 - "polly wants a cracker...."
3 - "heeee's the ooooone who likes all our pretty soooongs..." |
taroo
11.03.10 | Lower 3 to off the list and move 5 to like 2 |
qwe3
11.03.10 | "Also, please clarify why and how In Utero is BETTER than fucking Nevermind! If you wanna talk about underwhelming pieces of shit..."
the songs actually pack a punch
the production is much more interesting AND truer to the "grunge" aesthetic
lyrics are better
was not a piece of shit |
MassiveAttack
11.03.10 | ^lol agreed on every aspect. But Nevermind truly isn't a piece of shit, its just average when taking out its impact on the scene, which is purely objective and is warranted. |
Josh D.
11.03.10 | It obviously had impact, but that doesn't mean it's good of course. |
MassiveAttack
11.03.10 | That's what I'm saying. Its perfectly understandable to see why people bash it. Its completely over hyped where as both Bleach and In Utero are superior in more ways than one. |
eggsvonsatan
11.03.10 | Grunge is my most hated term in music. Its used to describe bands that sound nothing alike each other.
|
MassiveAttack
11.03.10 | It is a label just as indie is, Alternative would probably be better for "Grunge" artists to be called, but whatever. |
ReturnToRock
11.03.10 | Bleach better than Nevermind - HELLZ YEAH
In Utero better than Nevermind - HELLZ NO
Filler songs on Bleach: Swap Meet, Sifting, and Paper Cuts
Filler songs on In Utero: Milk It, Radio Friendly Unit Shifter, Very Ape, Pennyroyal Tea, Gallons Of Rubbing Alcohol Flowing Through The Strip, and one could add Scentless Apprentice, but I won't.
Filler songs on Nevermind: Something in The Way and Endless Nameless. PERIOD. And one is a HIDDEN TRACK. Arguably one could include Lounge Act, but that's fun. |
ReturnToRock
11.03.10 | The mid-section of In Utero is an absolute disgrace. |
DrunkBishyBoshy
11.03.10 | Great list. Most of the major bands are there although i might dispute a couple of your album choices. Would like to have seen some Green River or Mudhoney in there. Great call with 4, 7, and 9. |
qwe3
11.03.10 | returntorock you spent your life reviewing the kiss discography why is it you think you can have an opinion on anything ever again |
qwe3
11.04.10 | oh yeah and
"The mid-section of In Utero is an absolute disgrace."
fucking no |
ReturnToRock
11.04.10 | The Nostalgia Critic spends his life reviewing horrible movies and HIS opinion counts to some people.
And either way it's not like I graded the KISS albums with flying colours!
And fucking yes. Milk It? Pennyroyal Tea? Very Ape? Come on! The only usable song between Frances Farmer and Tourette's is Dumb. The rest sucks donkey balls. |
KILL
11.04.10 | f u rock f u |
qwe3
11.04.10 | "The Nostalgia Critic spends his life reviewing horrible movies and HIS opinion counts to some people."
RtR: The Justification King
|
ReturnToRock
11.04.10 | But I'm right though, so there.
And qwe, didn't we use to get along? When did we stop? |
Drunk
01.18.11 | Featured assholes. |
sonorirish
05.10.11 | 8 should be at 1
|
