Titan50
11.18.09 | Go cry about the lack of metal |
Athom
11.18.09 | mmm foals ;) |
Phrike
11.18.09 | A heap of fantastic albums, but a lot of stinkers as well imo |
greg84
11.18.09 | Muse? Really? They aren't that great. Other than that, a pretty solid list. |
TRMshadow
11.18.09 | Quite a few good ones, but many that just make me go "meh"
I think I saw the whole Radiohead Discography on here. |
Titan50
11.18.09 | I don't have In Rainbows on there... |
EVedder27
11.18.09 | a lot of good and a lot that I haven't heard |
SeaAnemone
11.18.09 | 62? eeewwwww |
robertsona
11.18.09 | a lot of these are shitty tbh but some are good |
AliW1993
11.18.09 | great list, about half of these would probably be on mine |
klap
11.18.09 | list is fairly awesome in regards to best-of-decade lists....really can't say someone's decade list is "shitty" per se because, well, most people here haven't been listening to music the entire decade and don't have the kind of perspective to accurately grade a whole decade. see my rant in streetlight's list for more info |
scotish
11.18.09 | good: very 2, kinda 5, 10, 14, 16, 53, 83
meh: 29
ugh: 46, 59
lol: 84
one that I'm curious about cos I've been rec'd it before: 19 |
Inveigh
11.18.09 | pretty decent list, although 2 Brand New albums in the top 5 is pretty questionable (and I love both of those). I've been seriously listening to music since about 1998 so I think I'd be able to make one of these, although I don't claim to have heard even close to everything on this list. I'm just not sure I have the time to sort one out.. |
klap
11.18.09 | right, plenty of people have been listening to music since before the decade, but one's breadth of knowledge is generally not wide enough to compile a really accurate best-of list....for example, i've been buying CDs since about 1999, but i wasn't listening/reviewing dozens of CDs until 2006/07 and wasn't downloading hundreds on a yearly basis until 2008. thus, my knowledge of the first half of the decade is very personalized and would hardly be a good barometer of what was actually the "best-of"....although there's nothing wrong with one's opinion. |
Titan50
11.18.09 | Thought it would be obvious that in this sense Best Of =/= Fact
And yes, I love Brand New, jus sayin |
klap
11.18.09 | yeah clearly best of is opinionated, i just feel like i couldn't write a legitimate best-of the decade because i haven't listened to enough albums in the early part of the decade |
Inveigh
11.18.09 | ^way to summarize my point better than I could myself. |
kitsch
11.18.09 | wow list sucks |
robertsona
11.18.09 | whats with you being overanalytical klap yo
shitty means i dont like the albums on the list
|
Inveigh
11.18.09 | my ^ comment was directed at klap's longer comment. |
MrHotMoms
11.19.09 | id put 67 and 98 wayy higher but otherwise good list |
Chewie
11.19.09 | not bad sweetlips |
BSX
11.19.09 | BJORK!!!! |
