ReefaJones: Top 25 Greatest Discographies of all Time

ReefaJones 03.30.21	Discuss
wham49 03.30.21	no BS, IM, LZ, Bob DYlan, Radiohead, Rolling Stones, Yes
ReefaJones 03.30.21	Radiohead is here. Yes and Black Sabbath almost made it. Not a fan of Led Zeppelin, Iron Maiden or Bob Dylan
DoofDoof 03.30.21	Bowie probably 1 Tindersticks and Lambchop are up there, each have 12+ great albums
ReefaJones 03.30.21	Bowie's can definitely be argued to be 1. Ultimately Waits edged him out for me. Not sure about Tindersticks and Lambchop though.
GhandhiLion 03.30.21	Nice list. Can's discography sucks.
ReefaJones 03.30.21	nice bait
chemicalmarriage 03.30.21	Meshuggah Love tom waits good pick
GhandhiLion 03.30.21	It wasn't. Half of their albums are forgettable :[
zakalwe 03.30.21	Beatles are 1
ReefaJones 03.30.21	Beatles can't be 1 when Waits and Bowie have twice as many amazing albums
zakalwe 03.30.21	With a sixth of the tunes.
ReefaJones 03.30.21	that's an opinion I guess
GhandhiLion 03.30.21	I just realised I haven't even listened to half of Neil Youngs work. I should fix that eventually.
ReefaJones 03.30.21	"It wasn't. Half of their albums are forgettable :[" Good thing that the other half is amazing then right?
GhandhiLion 03.30.21	3 of the best albums ever and half poor does not a good discography make.
ReefaJones 03.30.21	Yes it does. Most bands don't even have one "best album ever". In your own words, Can has three of those. That's enough to get the 24th spot on here
ReefaJones 03.30.21	In terms of consistency I can see what you mean though but I didn't necessarily go for consistency here rather than the number of quality releases
Senetrix666 03.30.21	Death, Thou, Cult of Luna, Isis, Neurosis, Converge, Type O Negative, Unwound, Amenra
AmericanFlagAsh 03.30.21	Lmao excluding The Bends and A Moon Shaped Pool from Radiohead...
GhandhiLion 03.30.21	none of your favourite albums are dogshit
chemicalmarriage 03.30.21	Maybe fabius really fucking loves dogshit and the comment is a compliment
ReefaJones 03.30.21	heresy!
ReturnToRock 03.30.21	According to your rules: GREEN DAY Kerplunk! Dookie Insomniac American Idiot RAMONES Ramones Leave Home Rocket to Russia End of the Century Animal Boy Mondo Bizarro CINDERELLA Night Songs Long Cold Winter Still Climbing BON JOVI New Jersey Slippery When Wet Keep the Faith THE WHO Who's Next The Who Sell Out Tommy POISON Look What the Cat Dragged In Open Up and Say...Aah! Flesh and Blood SEPULTURA Beneath the Remains Arise Chaos AD Roots ANTHRAX Spreading the Disease Among the Living State of Euphoria Attack of the Killer B's AC/DC High Voltage Let There Be Rock Highway to Hell Back in Black The Razors Edge PANTERA Cowboys From Hell Vulgar Display of Power The Great Southern Trendkill AEROSMITH Get Your Wings Permanent Vacation Pump Get a Grip SOULFLY S/T Primitive 3 Prophecy IRON MAIDEN Killers Number of the Beast Piece of Mind Powerslave Seventh Son of a Seventh Son Fear of the Dark PIXIES Surfer Rosa Come On Pilgrim Doolittle Trompe Le Monde NIRVANA Bleach Nevermind Incesticide DEFTONES Adrenaline Around the Fur White Pony I could go on, but you get the point. Your criteria are a little too lax lol
Couteau 03.30.21	Tool, Isis
ReefaJones 03.30.21	Tool lmao
ArsMoriendi 03.30.21	Are you counting Mothers of Invention Separately from Zappa? Cuz: We're Only in It for the Money Over-Nite Sensation One Size Fits All Absolutely Free "Lmao excluding The Bends and A Moon Shaped Pool from Radiohead..." is a good choice, yes
ReefaJones 03.30.21	"Are you counting Mothers of Invention Separately from Zappa?" I seperated them, yes. I wanted to avoid having to defend counting them together. Thankfully Zappa doesn't even need The Mother's discog to make it.
EyesWideShut 03.30.21	Black Sabbath needs to be here but you can go with Fiona Apple and Outkast too.
Drifter 03.30.21	where's snoop dogg?
ReefaJones 03.30.21	Damn I had Outkast on my draft and then completely forgot to put them on here
ReefaJones 03.30.21	Ok Can you are out
EyesWideShut 03.30.21	Sonic Youth !!
ReefaJones 03.30.21	nah
EyesWideShut 03.30.21	:cry: but why ? lol
ReefaJones 03.30.21	Because I'm not a huge fan of them. There are still like 50 bands I would put in here before them
EyesWideShut 03.30.21	i hear ya broski
chemicalmarriage 03.30.21	Cinderella lmfao
ReturnToRock 03.30.21	^I wish that band had picked literally any other name/logo. Seriously. They're such a good band, but that name just ruins it.
WeepingBanana 03.30.21	As much as I love The Kinks, as in they’re probably my favorite band, they have a tonnnnnnn of bad albums
LeddSledd 03.30.21	very nice Gentle Giant and Bob Marley mentions in this list
DDDeftoneDDD 03.30.21	this is a Reefa sealed list. All Reefa's readers were waiting for this list. Reefa knows a lot when it comes to Reefa's taste. Great list!
ReefaJones 03.30.21	@WeepingBanana Who gives a fuck about the bad albums when you have 7 amazing albums.
WeepingBanana 03.30.21	You didn’t even list Muswell Hillbillies
WeepingBanana 03.30.21	Also for Neil you GOTTA recognize Ragged Glory
ReefaJones 03.30.21	I didn't list a lot of albums if you haven't noticed
ReefaJones 03.30.21	If you have over 20 albums and unless your name is David Bowie or Tom Waits, there are going to be stinkers in there.
ReefaJones 03.30.21	Now that I think about it even Bowie has a couple of stinkers.
WeepingBanana 03.30.21	Man I can still enjoy some Tom Waits from a nostalgic perspective but I think if I were to listen to him now for the first time I’d think it was utter dogshit. Terrible vibes. Similar to how I never really listened to Nick Cave in my formative years so when I listen now I’m like “lmao people like this??”
ReefaJones 03.30.21	that's a cool story
WeepingBanana 03.30.21	Thanks it’s a hit at parties
ReefaJones 03.30.21	I'm sure it is.
Titan 03.30.21	Rush belongs here. Like them or not, their 19 album discography has overall ratings that speak for themselves.
ReefaJones 03.30.21	doesn't speak for me
Titan 03.30.21	'Top 25 Greatest Discographies of all Time' yes, it does
ReefaJones 03.30.21	nope
wham49 03.30.21	"Thankfully Zappa doesn't even need The Mother's discog to make it." WHAT!!! I love ZAppa, but the MOI albums are absolutely classics
Jethro42 03.30.21	yes, no yes
HYPERVIOLET 03.30.21	Needs asking alexandria
ReefaJones 03.30.21	"WHAT!!! I love ZAppa, but the MOI albums are absolutely classics" Did I say anything different?
JDubb 03.30.21	Still stuck in classic rock (has beens) I see. Lot of good music since the 1990's out there.
Slugboiiii 03.30.21	Needs more Kanye West.
Deez 03.30.21	Neurosis Kayo Dot Ulcerate Motorpsycho Portishead Sabbath Fly Lo Coltrane
Doibhin69 03.30.21	great list
Emim 03.30.21	Opeth
ReefaJones 03.31.21	"Lot of good music since the 1990's out there" There's Bjork, Radiohead, Kendrick, Outkast and Nick Cave on here. What are you talking about, goof
extract 03.31.21	Porcupine Tree
aydross121 03.31.21	hell yes the kinks
aydross121 03.31.21	also elvis costello has like 7-8 pretty good albums
Evreaia 03.31.21	Paysage D'Hiver should be on here. None of his albums drop below a 4
alamo 03.31.21	Lana Del Rey
alamo 03.31.21	Normani
ReefaJones 03.31.21	^no
DocSportello 03.31.21	good list. i would personally add spoon and (arguably) the avalanches
Deez 03.31.21	Deathspell
DDDeftoneDDD 03.31.21	Reefa does not approve. Neither Death. In fact no metal is deserving of such Reefa prize. Metal is for losers amirite?
DoofDoof 03.31.21	most metal bands keep going past their shelf life Slayer, Metallica and Sepultura hang up their guitars six albums in and we're looking at some of the tightest discogs ever As is there's almost as many mediocre or worse albums to contend with
GhandhiLion 03.31.21	@DDD for the most part yeah. This list isn't about complete discographies though Doof so they could qualify.
DDDeftoneDDD 03.31.21	hehe what I'm trying to say is that this is a great Reefa's list, don't know why ppl are trying to apply other bands/artists here, just get a "no" or "nah". the fact he says "of all Time" should be completely indifferent to us XD
DDDeftoneDDD 03.31.21	list is true History being made tho
OSEL 03.31.21	list is reasonable, 2 much prog
ReefaJones 03.31.21	4 prog bands out of 25 entries = too much prog I guess @DDDeftoneDDD Are you ok? You seem unhinged
NorthernSkylark 03.31.21	Great century for music.
Boognish79 06.10.21	Stones, Zeppelin, Dylan, Radiohead,Sabbath?
BaselineOOO 06.10.21	Too safe of a ranking. Don't you listen to something else than rock? That's kind of sad... to listen to that amount of music only to be stuck forever in the comfort of the same genre.