WeepingBanana
11.15.20 | This list gave me a stomachache |
ArsMoriendi
11.15.20 | Sailing the Seas of Cheese > The Real Thing |
TheAntichrist
11.15.20 | seasons is great, but it ain't the best thrash album that's for damn sure. spicy picks otherwise tho \m/ |
Friday13th
11.15.20 | Fun list. I like that you have seven different sub-sub genres for thrash LOL |
charbyno
11.15.20 | Judas Priest is not NWOBHM in my opinion. They were around before the NWOBHM movement |
Pikazilla
11.15.20 | Seasons isn't even top 3 slayer lmao |
Emim
11.15.20 | Thought this was gonna just be 30 sub-subgenres of Thrash. |
TheAntichrist
11.15.20 | it is top 3 slayer tho |
Willie
11.15.20 | --Judas Priest is not NWOBHM in my opinion. They were around before the NWOBHM movement--
And Carcass' "Heartwork" album was around before Melodic Death Metal, but I'd definitely still call it that. ;)
Anyway, nice list. That Soilwork album for Melodeath is one of the only ones I felt strongly about disputing. Some of the others I didn't entirely agree with, but felt it was at least close. Nice to see Anacrusis on the list, too. |
BenThatsMyJamin
11.15.20 | 1 isn't even thrash
Also you really gonna pick Rising Force over Perpetual Burn for neoclassical? |
TheAntichrist
11.15.20 | how is slayer not thrash lol |
Pikazilla
11.15.20 | except the four albums that precede it are better :p |
TheAntichrist
11.15.20 | seasons > south of heaven anyday, and that's coming from an antichrist for fuck sake lol |
Pikazilla
11.15.20 | lmao crazy |
Flashmobba
11.15.20 | aw man no ISIS? :(
and how is the downward spiral industrial metal |
TheAntichrist
11.15.20 | i wanna fuck you like an animal!!!! |
DaveT0738
11.15.20 | This list it's all about cheating lol |
DaveT0738
11.15.20 | Beneath, South and Among are the thrash albums i could think of for the #1 spot |
BenThatsMyJamin
11.15.20 | "how is slayer not thrash lol"
Slayer is thrash, but seasons is too mid-paced to be THE thrash album. Also it kinda sucks so there's that. Should be RiB. |
Space Jester
11.15.20 | This list gave me a stroke |
Motiv3
11.15.20 | This list is absolutely hilarious. |
DaveT0738
11.15.20 | Subgenres pulled out of the arse |
JustJoe.
11.15.20 | i vibe with some of this |
Egarran
11.15.20 | Amazing list |
GhandhiLion
11.15.20 | I Lold at grind and grindcore |
Shemson
11.15.20 | Some great albums here tbf, love for Adultery coming out of nowhere too, but Rust In Peace is always best thrash and Reign is best Slayer |
TheAntichrist
11.15.20 | "Slayer is thrash, but seasons is too mid-paced to be THE thrash album. Also it kinda sucks so there's that. Should be RiB."
half the album maybe, but it still rules. rib is definitely better though and a more worthy candidate of best thrash album |
90470n573r01d5
11.15.20 | i guess list is alright, but it seems obvious that op isn't very familiar with some of the genres. option paralysis for mathcore? c'mon, it's not even tdep's best. |
Egarran
11.16.20 | ok nerd |
Allergist
11.16.20 | Where’s OvDeath to tell you half of these arent real and that you should kill yourself? |
Morningrise767
11.16.20 | good shit |
TheAntichrist
11.16.20 | correct |
combustion07
11.16.20 | Damn son |
MrSirLordGentleman
11.16.20 | "Judas Priest is not NWOBHM in my opinion. They were around before the NWOBHM movement"
They were around before but Screaming and Defenders certainly follow the sound that's usually associated with NWOBHM. Same thing happens with Sabbath and H&H and Mob Rules |
evilford
11.16.20 | WOW ALL CAPS WOW |
DaveT0738
11.16.20 | Someone explain the difference between grind and grindcore please |
evilford
11.16.20 | even if u disagree with some picks this still deserved a feature |
DaveT0738
11.16.20 | Fun list, i actually took a name or two from bands to check out |
Dwap
11.16.20 | How can this list exist without Kyuss? |
Senetrix666
11.16.20 | scrap that we lost the sea record and just change Through Silver in Blood's description to post metal. oh and change nine inch nails to ministry |
DaveT0738
11.16.20 | "and just change Through Silver in Blood's description to post metal"
[2] |
Cormano
11.16.20 | so how is post hardcore a metal subgenre? not to mention grind lmao |
sixdegrees
11.16.20 | a tour de force |
el_newg
11.16.20 | thanks for including my favourite genre, Christian :) |
budgie
11.16.20 | bad
list |
JeremiahBullfrog
11.16.20 | bad
list [2] |
ReturnToRock
11.16.20 | Just to point out, 35 and 36 are technically both NWOBHM albums. AND they're both 'traditional' heavy metal albums. So really you only need one.
Also, where's epic (i.e. Manowar, etc)?
Oh yeah, and Paranoid/Master of Reality over S/T for Sabbath. |
Egarran
11.16.20 | Just a warning: People who seriously argue with this list are gonna be first against the wall. |
DDDeftoneDDD
11.16.20 | Pretty cool fuckin list, pretty awesome 12 pick |
DDDeftoneDDD
11.16.20 | Where's BDM and its Akercocke - Rennaiscence in Extremis? |
DDDeftoneDDD
11.16.20 | also hell no for PROGRESSIVE SLUDGE - Its Mastodon - Blood Mountain |
Egarran
11.16.20 | omfg |
DDDeftoneDDD
11.16.20 | is that a way to agree or disagree Ega? |
Egarran
11.16.20 | I'm sure he's going to change the list now to accommodate your corrections |
DDDeftoneDDD
11.16.20 | ahah that's the least I could hope for...being the correct thing to do a side note with an apology to me.
I still don't see a BDM pick, so I'll wait for something to change... |
ChoccyPhilly
11.16.20 | basic |
Egarran
11.16.20 | 3D he calls it blackened death |
DDDeftoneDDD
11.16.20 | oh shit...I missed that one...disagree even its the best Necrophobic. Definitely a relevant pick though. |
TheAntichrist
11.16.20 | funny how celtic frost isn't celtic lol |
Tomstein
11.16.20 | Cool list man |
DaveT0738
11.16.20 | There's a new one bois, EPIC |
Aberf
11.16.20 | no post-black metal? 0/10 list. |
BladeRunner
11.16.20 | Ensiferum > Slania |
TheSpirit
11.16.20 | are death/doom & funeral doom not essentially the same thing |
GerardOz
11.16.20 | More subgenres than notes in a regular song |
GerardOz
11.16.20 | Does NSBM exist? |
Lord(e)Po)))ts
11.17.20 | there are at least seven too many types of thrash here |
aydross121
11.17.20 | Manowar and Helloween are so bad lol.
That Primordial pick is based though. |
JS19
11.17.20 | if only half of these were actual genres |
garas
11.17.20 | Pretty good list. Only 33 and 74 seems a bit overconfident.
Noone else had any chance against Ace Of Spades in speed metal, hahahaha! |
Josh D.
11.17.20 | technical thrash |
Flugmorph
11.17.20 | >post
>we lost the sea
LMAO |
cylinder
11.17.20 | 31 like really really sucks |
Grimlin
11.18.20 | ^lol |
botb
11.18.20 | I’m gonna say you made up half of these |
Egarran
11.19.20 | So you admit ignorance |
DaveT0738
11.19.20 | "I’m gonna say you made up half of these"
No shit
|
Egarran
11.19.20 | 77 is a classic genre |
alamo
11.19.20 | where katy perry |
Grungil
01.04.21 | 82 records to listen in 2021. Im not a big Metal fan so i think i´ll become one by the end of year. |
aydross121
01.05.21 | @Grungil just replace pagan with Moonsorrow - Verisakeet and you are good to go. |
Boognish79
06.28.21 | Faith No More isn’t funk, metal, or funk-metal. They’re Faith No More. |
Muzz79
06.28.21 | They were known as funk metal tho. And even RHCP were too at the time of BSSM |
Snake.
06.28.21 | post-hardcore being a metal subgenre l m a o |
budgie
06.28.21 | this is embarrassing |
Egarran
06.28.21 | I bet the CELTIC tag triggered you |
Demon of the Fall
06.28.21 | This list contains a more than acceptable amount of good music, which is all that really matters.
I doubt the 'genre tags' are completely serious. Also the one most definitely not metal subgenre here is the most based of picks, so whatever I guess. |
Egarran
06.28.21 | What, this list is obv 100% serious and frankly it's an ugly attack on budgie's very person. |
VlacDrac
10.06.23 | Acktually, the best Progressive Sludge album ever made is What One Becomes. |
Hawks
10.06.23 | this is embarrassing [2] |
