Trifolium
09.23.20 | In no particular order. |
Storm In A Teacup
09.23.20 | oh, gotcha. is this a grandpa band? |
Pangea
09.23.20 | Vali is my 5.0 artist. Granted he only has two albums but they are both perfect < 3 |
Zeuzo
09.23.20 | No bands with perfect discogs but by number of 5βs probably Neurosis or Deftones |
Trifolium
09.23.20 | @Teacup: Mega young grandpa's with mega young teenage parent child maybe?
Let's say grandpa is from the 70s or so (since Portishead was mostly active in the 90s, so he got to know them as a teen/in his early 20s). Then he got a child in the late 90s, early 00s; who again got a child in the late 10s, then it would work!
@Pangea&Zeuzo: Yes yes yes sounds good! |
JesperL
09.23.20 | at one point i would've 5'ed brand news entire discog, excluding your favourite weapon
don't think i have any full 5 discog bands rn, but i feel like i'm always one step removed from 5'ing every album emma ruth rundle is involved with |
JohnnyoftheWell
09.23.20 | Only have one 5 per artists, but the 5/5 bands are Unwound, mewithoutYou, Seiko Oomori, Melt-Banana and maybe Cocteau Twins and Sonic Youth on a very good day |
theBoneyKing
09.23.20 | Sunhouse ;-P |
Trifolium
09.23.20 | Haha, I knew that was a one-album band before checking their page B.King! Nice!
Also Jesper and Johnny nice yes! This is my first and only 5.0-band. Never thought it would happen but Third is just undeniably good so I had to 5.0 in the end. |
JeremiahBullfrog
09.23.20 | the fucking smithssssss |
fogza
09.23.20 | Thanks for the rec Jesper, I'm actually quite liking this Emma Ruth Rundle you speak of. |
Icebloom
09.23.20 | Hmm, I don't have any 'perfect' bands. The National and ISIS would be the closest, with three 5's out of eight albums and two 5's out of five albums respectively. Also, there's this one-off Mark Kozelek collaboration project with Jimmy Lavalle that I have at a 5, but I don't think that really counts. |
Trifolium
09.23.20 | Good, good and good.
Agreed Icebloom, you pulled a BoneyKing with that last one! |
Scheumke
09.23.20 | Hmm don't really have any 5 bands either, but if I had to pick one it would be either Cult of Luna or Ne Obliviscaris. |
Rowhaus
09.23.20 | Nick Drake |
JoyfulPlatypus
09.23.20 | Just purely judging off of my 5's then I'd say Talking Heads are pretty damn near perfect (just pretend those last two albums don't exist) |
Colton
09.23.20 | Talking Heads [2] |
widowslaugh123
09.23.20 | Sex Pistols |
Trifolium
09.23.20 | Some other nice ones!
It seems not many bands are 5.0s throughout their whole careers. And the ones who are have relatively small discogs (Portishead of course fall into this category too). |
Deez
09.23.20 | As much as i ADORE Portishead. Its an unfair game with just 3 studio albums.
Theres bands with more than 3 5's in their whole discog.
Neurosis/Kayo dot/Ulcerate/Gorguts/Isis/Godspeed/Crimson/Motorspyscho
|
Ryus
09.23.20 | the closest for me are probably
joanna newsom
orchid
my bloody valentine
burial
boards of canada
the smiths
|
DopeFiend
09.23.20 | Thou
Cult of Luna
Isis
Acid bath |
encomium
09.23.20 | Nick Cave and the Bad Seeds
Everything Everything |
bloodshy
09.23.20 | The only band I've heard so far without any 4.9 songs, all are 5.0, is Spiritbox. |
Sniff
09.23.20 | Hmm was expecting this to be Ulcerate. |
asanisimasa
09.23.20 | I cant give them all 5.0s but I think Gorguts has one of the most consistent discographies |
Storm In A Teacup
09.23.20 | Definitely hopesfall for me, every album and song is a 5
Currently one of my other 5 artists for me is electronic artist Mimosa but he just released the single for his next record and I fucking hate it and it's a remix of one of his older hits and comparing it to the old version is trash. it's also a sequel album to that album which makes me worry more.
Coheed used to be that band up until a couple albums ago they hit a couple curbs in the road
Emery has slightly lost their 5 band status for me as well with their newest album :/
iamthemorning is still a 5 band for me even when they keep remaking old songs they still get all 5s
Thrice comes close but not quite, same with a couple other bands like Youth Group, The Monkees, Young Jeezy, Jimi Hendrix, Johnny Cash, The Damned Things, The Game, Yes, and a couple others
|
newsteamchannel4
09.23.20 | closest is Boards, but itβs subjective and youβd have to squint to make any discog perfect.
Music - 5/Beautiful Place - deffo 5/Geogaddi - 5/Campfire - 4.5/Tomorrowβs Harvest - 4.5
So I guess theyβre not a 5.0 but theyβre plenty close to me, I had to force myself to put 4.5βs on their last two. Discounting Twoism and Hi-Scores too (which are also 4.5βs in my book but again I, nor anyone, can be actually objective enough to say).
|
Trifolium
09.23.20 | Ah so many of us do have bands that are very close to being perfect throughout their whole discog after all! |
SmashIsTheWay94
09.23.20 | I only have one band with multiple 5's, but there are still a few that I pretty much consider 5/5 bands. I think a band qualifies if they have at least one 5 and I love everything they've done (or almost everything depending on the size of their discog.) So I'd say Unwound, Modest Mouse, Fugazi and maaaaybe Slowdive |
Ryus
09.23.20 | '96-'00 modest mouse |
SmashIsTheWay94
09.23.20 | ^pretty much yeah |
sixdegrees
09.23.20 | cant think of any |
kevbogz
09.23.20 | Fall of Efrafa hands down. |
Avagantamos
09.23.20 | Autechre get an average of like 4.5 from me across all their albums and EPs, which is nearly 30 releases |
Ryus
09.23.20 | how high is ur Intelligence Quotient be honest |
sixdegrees
09.23.20 | that's nearly 30 hours of experimental techno |
Storm In A Teacup
09.23.20 | Anberlin is another band I would be negligent to not bring up. Their 2nd, 3rd, 4th, 5th, and 6th albums during a year or two period were all 5s for me. |
Deez
09.23.20 | Neurosis/Ulcerate/Gorguts/Kayo dot/Crimson/Motorpsycho come to mind. Tim hecker. Grouper. Lots with 3or4 5s or more. Portishead of course. Coltrane/Deathspell. Plenty. |
JesperL
09.23.20 | hell yeah fogza, make sure to check her band marriages as well! |
evilford
09.23.20 | Gorguts
Meshuggah
Ulcerate
Neurosis |
Avagantamos
09.23.20 | my brain is hardwired into sean & bobby's Max/MSP patches, so my intelligence can vary wildy depending on which track I'm currently listening to. the results can be alarming, and even dangerous. |
asanisimasa
09.23.20 | I give Kayo Dot a 5 for being Kayo Dot but I can't say their discog is consistent 5s |
Avagantamos
09.23.20 | is your username referring to that Twine song? |
Trifolium
09.23.20 | We see some recurring bands here. They must be good then! |
DavidYowi
09.23.20 | The bands I have given the most 5s to are Gorguts, Rush, and Soundgarden, each tied at 3 albums. |
Trundle
09.23.20 | no 5.0 bands, but many 4.0+ bands |
bloodshy
09.24.20 | evilford, didn't you vote pink floyd over ulcerate though? |
Trifolium
09.24.20 | Yes many 4.0+ bands, relatable Trundle!
Gorguts seems to be universally loved. Perhaps I should give them a try sometime. |
davezillaMP3
09.24.20 | DAZZLE VISION is the closest for me, as 3 of their 7 releases being 5s, this is also the most 5s i have given an artist (some artists have 2, and the gazettE do not count right now as i am doing a through discog. run on them). They also have 2 albums i gave a 4.5, 1 4.0 and 2 3.5s) rounding out the average to around 4.3. At one point though every single one of their releases was a 5 for me before i did a disog. run of them a few months back. |
DamnVanne
09.24.20 | Jakob has only laid it down 3 times but each album is perfectly gorgeous |
Avagantamos
09.25.20 | gorguts is the best death metal band |
evilford
09.25.20 | Yes^^^ |
evilford
09.25.20 | And yes bloodshy I did. U keeping track? Lol |
Pon
09.25.20 | There are no 5.0 bands but Demilich's and Gorement's only albums are 4.5s so I guess they're closest |
evilford
09.25.20 | Jac nespithe is the ahrdest 5 ever made bruh |
Storm In A Teacup
09.25.20 | the best one album pop-punk band is +44 |
Jimbly
09.25.20 | Joy Division |
Trifolium
09.25.20 | Aha! So there still are more! Got to love those sweet, compact yet perfect discographies. |
teamster
09.25.20 | For me, Fen is the closest. |
SandwichBubble
09.25.20 | Most of my 5.0 bands have two albums or fewer. Or only released singles/EPs.
Pretty exclusive club. |
Lord(e)Po)))ts
11.03.20 | The Knife |
Lucman
11.20.20 | Jimmy Eat World, Lambchop, and The Weakerthans all have flawless discogs in my eyes. |
Evreaia
11.20.20 | Gris and Vali |
parksungjoon
10.06.21 | do bands with only 1 LP count? :^) |
kkarron
10.06.21 | They are true kvlt, so yes.
It's why I hate that SOD gave out a second album. It fucking ruined it. They banged out a crossover classic in like what, 3 days. That should've been it. |
parksungjoon
10.06.21 | the 2nd one is not much worse than the 1st tbh |
Cimnele
10.06.21 | Art Bears maybe |
Cimnele
10.06.21 | and This Heat! |
Trifolium
10.06.21 | Yipppeeee more 5.0 bands!!! |
parksungjoon
10.06.21 | do bands with only 1 LP count? :^)
|
Trifolium
10.06.21 | Of course! Who'd you have in mind specifically? |
parksungjoon
10.06.21 | demilich |
Demon of the Fall
10.06.21 | yep, this band is about as close as you can get (not inc. artists with 1 or 2 releases). |
Trifolium
10.06.21 | Demon yesssss πͺπΌ
Haven't heard them ever park. Maybe I should check but I'm not a dm-er at all usually. |
parksungjoon
10.06.21 | well its a weird band, hence why i like them [: |