Drbebop
03.30.20 | Love me some NIN. Interesting list, especially with Ghost 1-4 so high. Here’s my rank
1. The Fragile
2. TDS
3. Pretty Hate Machine
4. Broken
5. Bad Witch
6. Year Zero
7. With Teeth
8. Add Violence
9. Hesitation Marks
10. Ghosts 5
11. Ghosts 6
12. The Slip
13. Ghosts 1-4
14. Not the actual events
|
Tyler.
03.30.20 | bad witch is top 3 |
MiloRuggles
03.30.20 | TDS
The Fragile
Year Zero
Hesitation Marks
Broken
Still
Ghosts 5/6
EP trilogy
With Teeth
The Slip
PHM
Ghosts 1-4
All of this is based on empirical evidence and cannot be disputed |
Viriathus
03.30.20 | The Downward Spiral
The Fragile
Pretty Hate Machine
Broken EP
Bad Witch
The Slip
With Teeth
Year Zero
Hesitation Marks
Ghosts I-IV
Still needa hear the new Ghosts parts tho |
BAT
03.30.20 | where is broken and broken is #1 |
bobbydylan
03.30.20 | broken is an EP so i didn't include it. it would have put up pretty high tho. |
markjamie
03.30.20 | Top 2 are right on point. |
Minushuman24
03.30.20 | Big ol disagree:
TDS
The Fragile
Year Zero
Pretty Hate
Bad Witch
Locusts
With Teeth
Hesitation Marks
Slip
Together
Ghosts
All are great though |
Rickislost
03.30.20 | Definitely agree the Fragile should be at the top.
Iv always had a soft spot for With Teeth, but it never seems to be high on anyone's list |
Viriathus
03.30.20 | I love With Teeth and it used to be pretty high for me too until I got back into PHM hard and Bad Witch released. |
Sinternet
03.30.20 | with teeth is 1 |
Rickislost
03.30.20 | Im loving the recent EP series, but not the actual events is my favourite from them |
ArsMoriendi
03.30.20 | Year Zero - 5
The Downward Spiral - 4.5
With Teeth - 4
Pretty Hate Machine - 4
Broken - 4
Bad Witch - 4
Hesitation Marks - 4
The Fragile - 3.5
Add Violence - 3.5
The Slip - 3.5
Not the Actual Events - 3.5
Ghosts VI: Locusts - 3.5
Ghosts V: Together - 3
Ghosts I-IV - 2.5 |
ArsMoriendi
03.30.20 | Yea The Fragile is ranked low, yes it's way too long, yes a good third of the album drags down the good tracks
If it were 70 mins of the best material, it'd probably be a 4.5, but the album's 103 minutes |
DoofDoof
03.30.20 | Ars, spot on - The Fragile is way too long, mid range 3.5 at best |
Faraudo
03.30.20 | Seeing some Bad Witch appreciation on this thread.
Nice. |
HYPERVIOLET
04.01.20 | The fragile feels so uninspired to me. Especially coming after tds |
mryrtmrnfoxxxy
04.02.20 | hyper? |
HYPERVIOLET
04.02.20 | yes? |
