Doibhin69: Star Wars: My Final Verdict

Doibhin69 01.13.20	obviously my ranking is completely different now but this is currently how I feel about all of these movies.
Valkoor952 01.13.20	Swap 1 and 3 and then 3 and 4 and this is a very respectable ranking. Would still rank solo lower.
cazzill 01.13.20	List isn't too bad. I'd have 6 and 8 way further down though
Lelle 01.13.20	ROS needs to be lowest. What a clusterfuck that movie was.
wojodta 01.13.20	I agree with a lot of the list. Although I wouldn't have III as #1. ROS is the worst. Half the shit that happens in that doesn't even make sense or shouldn't be possible.
NOTINTHEFACE 01.13.20	To my dying breath, I will never understand what anyone sees in the steaming pile of rancid vomit that is the prequels. They seriously have zero redeeming features. Say what you want about the sequels, but at least they feel like real movies told by professional directors and actors, not shitty B movies with CG glued soullessly over the top.
BookoftheFallen 01.13.20	I can’t wait for the next trilogy, which will be a jar jar binks origin story.
SymbolicInTime 01.13.20	Top 4 is top 4. I'd also swap 10 and 6. Close enough for me at that point
LanaDelRey 01.13.20	lmao Revenge of the Sith as number one? Is this a joke? and the new trilogy is pretty bad but it's nowhere near as awful as the prequels. I'm curious to hear why you think Revenge of the Sith is a better movie than Empire Strikes Back.
wham49 01.13.20	1 is despicable
twlight 01.13.20	1. EP 5 2. EP 4 3. EP 3 4. Rogue One 5. EP 6 6. EP 9 7. Solo 8. EP 1 9. Ep 7 10. EP 2 11. EP 8
polyrhythm 01.13.20	As underwhelming as the sequel trilogy proved to be, ranking any of them lower than the prequels is pretty lol. At least the sequels are actually functioning movies I can cherry pick things I enjoy from the new films, like sifting through a basket of bruised fruit. There is nothing I enjoy about the prequels. The story is great on paper, but never makes it to the screen. Same for Anakin's fall to the dark side. Takes about ten minutes to happen and the acting makes me cringe, cannot take that shit seriously The prequels are also shot badly, written horribly, full of dated ugly CGI, appalling dialogue, and over choreographed lightsaber duels that are no fun to watch. There is no emotion or weight to those fights, despite Ewan McGregor's best efforts in III I mean we got the Duel of the Fates OST and Darth Maul's character design, so I guess that's something?
Doibhin69 01.13.20	I expect people to disagree with my opinion about the prequels and that's fine. I've always been a fan of episode 3 and the lightsaber duels in it especially the obi wan and anakin duel which is one of my favorites along with the amazing music. I like seeing the turn of anakin to darth vader in that movie minus the awful NO line which is terrible. Ewan Mcgregor and Ian Mcdiarmid are both my favorite parts of the prequels easily.
iglu 01.13.20	ep V , epIV, ep VI the rest should be deleted from life.
SteakByrnes 01.13.20	Revenge of the Sith slaps so hard, it's my number 1 as well. I haven't seen episodes 8 or 9 yet so I can't say whether or not I fully agree with the list, but mine would look pretty similar
Valkoor952 01.13.20	"As underwhelming as the sequel trilogy proved to be, ranking any of them lower than the prequels is pretty lol. At least the sequels are actually functioning movies" The prequels are better Star Wars movies and there's nothing you can do about it.
wojodta 01.13.20	The reason the prequels are better than the new trilogy is because the prequels at least had (or attempted to have) a meaningful story. The sequel trilogy just feels like fluff. There's no point to its existence. The acting and presentation is better, but everything else is worse than the prequels.
Doibhin69 01.13.20	The reason the prequels are better than the new trilogy is because the prequels at least had (or attempted to have) a meaningful story. The sequel trilogy just feels like fluff. There's no point to its existence. The acting and presentation is better, but everything else is worse than the prequels [2]
neekafat 01.13.20	11 is 4 1 is 1
CaliggyJack 01.13.20	"As underwhelming as the sequel trilogy proved to be, ranking any of them lower than the prequels is pretty lol. At least the sequels are actually functioning movies" Imagine thinking Last Jedi is a "functioning movie"
TheBarber 01.14.20	U forgot to rank the christmas special goddammit
BankZZ 01.14.20	1. V 2. IV 3. VI GAP 4. III 5. Rouge One 6. VII GAP 7. Solo 8. I 9. II Haven't seen the rest.
Divaman 01.14.20	I just like the first three films (4, 5 & 6) and Rogue One. None of the others ever happened.
Gyromania 01.14.20	return of the jedi is better than hope imo, and force awakens is better than phantom menace and clones, and infinitely better than last jedi and rise of skywalker
Henderson 01.14.20	The reason the prequels are better than the new trilogy is because the prequels at least had (or attempted to have) a meaningful story. The sequel trilogy just feels like fluff. There's no point to its existence. The acting and presentation is better, but everything else is worse than the prequels [3] Exactly, at least the prequels, despite a kinda weak story, introduced a well-developed and interesting universe we didn't have before. The sequels have done absolutely nothing in that aspect, which is why they fall flat for me. VII takes zero risks but as a retread at least it's entertaining, VIII took many risks which made for an interesting film, though most didn't work, and IX has taken zero risks and is also a complete clusterfuck from beginning to end. V > IV > VI >> Rogue One > III >> VII > I >> II > Solo > VIII > IX
Davil667 01.14.20	„I just like the first three films (4, 5 & 6) and Rogue One. None of the others ever happened.“ ^ Word. Diva knows.
Gyromania 01.14.20	rise of skywalker just took a massive shit on this whole franchise imo. same with last jedi. force awakens was a ripoff of new hope, but it could have been a launching pad for something awesome to follow. and even though it wasn't especially original, it was a fun movie with some memorable scenes. the two to follow it felt incredibly scatterbrained and incoherent
NOTINTHEFACE 01.14.20	TLJ is a great, flawed movie with some of the best moments and scenes of the entire franchise. Fight me.
NOTINTHEFACE 01.14.20	I haven't seen RoS yet but if it shits all over TLJ's mold-breaking arcs then I'm sure it's terrible.
Crawl 01.14.20	The new trilogy might objectively be better than the prequels, but I truly believe that Lucas had an ambition with the prequels. After all, what we consider a Star Wars universe was mostly introduced in the prequels. The dialogue is awful, some characters are annoying, sure. But at least the movies weren't only a blatant money making machine.
Gyromania 01.14.20	last jedi was so gud because it subverted ma expectations
NOTINTHEFACE 01.14.20	obviously, but it's still irritating to me. like, we get it, you're super far left. i'm sure i'm just being biased though, since i tend not to agree with anything he says. i can't discuss these topics without a shitstorm of users trying to misconstrue and tear apart my every word though, so i always have to tread lightly. i do think things like 'trans rights' are utterly ridiculous. what rights do they need that they don't already have? maybe in regards to employment and employer biases i could see it being an issue. but insofar as policing language and such, i think it's terribly wrong. don't most doctors and psychologists on the planet consider it a mental disorder? i don't think it's healthy that we encourage and reinforce mental instability in people. personally. i absolutely adore that sophie album and think that some of its lyrical themes are appropriate, like 'it's okay to cry' and such, but first and foremost what i love about it is the music and challenging and experimental it is. i just don't think we need another pitchfork esque fluff piece on it
Gyromania 01.14.20	spread the gospel
Wildcardbitchesss 01.14.20	“ I'm just not really a fan of rey and how she basically can do anything with no training.” Luke one shotted the Death Star his first time piloting an X-Wing.
iglu 01.14.20	but at least luke struggled, there is no tension or a feeling of danger in the new films cause rey just knows what to do all the time.
Doibhin69 01.14.20	but at least luke struggled, there is no tension or a feeling of danger in the new films cause rey just knows what to do all the time. [2]
wojodta 01.14.20	Luke one shotting the death star isn't that hard to believe. He was a good pilot before that. It can't be that difficult to just get in an X-Wing and know how to fly it. Also, Luke spent like half of Ep. V training and still got his ass kicked by Vader. Luke's growth was more believable than Rey's for sure.
Tundra 01.14.20	This is the correct ranking, Clone Wars would be right up there with 1 and 2 for me
CygnusX1 01.14.20	Star wars movies have always been bad. They're just cool to watch because spaceships and lazer swords
Doibhin69 01.15.20	Episodes 7-9 are a waste of time. They shouldn't have happened.
Faraudo 01.15.20	"To my dying breath, I will never understand what anyone sees in the steaming pile of rancid vomit that is the prequels. They seriously have zero redeeming features. Say what you want about the sequels, but at least they feel like real movies told by professional directors and actors, not shitty B movies with CG glued soullessly over the top." This is the only important opinion here, Attack of the Clones is unforgivable.
Valkoor952 01.15.20	It is also one of the few wrong opinions
CaliggyJack 01.15.20	Phantom Menace is still the best Star Wars movie. Yall can suck it.
SteakByrnes 01.15.20	Literally the only good things about Phantom Menace are Qui Gon Jinn and Darth Maul
Source 01.15.20	what about the guy who jiggles his face
SteakByrnes 01.15.20	Okay yea that part is hilarious
SymbolicInTime 01.15.20	Out of all the Star Wars movies, only two have successfully put me to sleep. Episode 1 and Solo
iglu 01.17.20	"Literally the only good things about Phantom Menace are Qui Gon Jinn and Darth Maul" that's not saying much
CaliggyJack 01.18.20	And Mace Windu, and Duel of Fates, and Pod Racing, and Natalie Portman, and Ewan McGregor as Obi-Wan, and awesome locales, and Ian McDermid