Faenrir
03.19.19 | I know most people like Master over the others but it lacks the thrash energy the first 2 have.
Don't get me started on AJFA, it's vastly overrated :p |
Sinternet
03.19.19 | sorry the site autocorrected this list and made it blank |
Faenrir
03.19.19 | ^ yeah...no. Gtfoh |
Kroehny
03.19.19 | *incorrectly |
LOVEANDACCEPTANCE
03.19.19 | if this is your real metallica ranking you lick mad boots |
Faenrir
03.19.19 | *correctly
I'd accept a ranking with the first 3 in any different order though...it all comes to personal taste. But the rest is set in stone. |
LOVEANDACCEPTANCE
03.19.19 | 1-3 hold up as some of the most dogshit metal albums all time
ajfa is the only Metallica that can be considered great
rest is horrid |
StrikeOfTheBeast
03.19.19 | Top 4 is agreeable. |
kalkwiese
03.19.19 | One list a day mate |
kalkwiese
03.19.19 | 3 is too high |
kalkwiese
03.19.19 | Men |
StrikeOfTheBeast
03.19.19 | Nah 3 is fine where it's at. |
0xME
03.19.19 | Justice for AJFA!
(I'd put that one higher, other than that nice ranking) |
TheClansman95
03.19.19 | "correctly"... |
kalkwiese
03.19.19 | Men [2]
Also I'd switch AJFO with MoP |
Valzentia
03.19.19 | #1 is #1
St. Anger > Load and Reload |
LOVEANDACCEPTANCE
03.19.19 | men[3] |
wham49
03.19.19 | Not in my book but close |
Ambrosian
03.19.19 | Yep |
Jadmin
03.19.19 | 6 too low |
TheSpirit
03.19.19 | AJFA is too low, but hard props for putting KEA over MOP, it's so much better it's crazy. |
MusicinaBox
03.19.19 | Don't listen to much Metallica but I'm pretty sure this is a dogshit list. |
BerryGarlicia
03.19.19 | What is this bullshit¿? |
BerryGarlicia
03.19.19 | 3>6>1>7>4>10>8>2>11>9 |
StrikeOfTheBeast
03.19.19 | This is by no means a correct ranking, but it's not the worst one I've seen. Someone ranked Load as their second best on a different list if I remember correctly. |
Ikarus14
03.19.19 | I'd switch 2 and 3. Other than that, you're more or less spot on. |
Faenrir
03.20.19 | Lol @ the guy that dorsn't listen to 'tallica but thinks it's wrong haha
@ikarus14: yeah most people like MoP more than i do... i think kill'em all is underrated. It's much more thrash than MoP 😋 |
Morningrise767
03.20.19 | AJFA deserves to be higher, and yes MOP is over-rated. I agree with RTL in the #1 spot. |
Faenrir
03.20.19 | I really don't like AJFA that much. It's an album where you can feel they didn't know where to go. Kind of a mix of the more commercial metal they made with the black album and thrash that really doesn't work for me...and there's no bass.
For quite some time, i really thought Jason Newstedd wasn't that good. Then i listened to Floatsam and Jetsam. What a waste.
Still, it could be top 5 but i happen to really like their Garage Inc. album even though it's a covers one. |
Morningrise767
03.20.19 | I understand man, the lack of bass on AJFA kinda sucks. But there are some bangin' tracks on it (Blackened, t/t, One, Dyers Eve, Shortest Straw) Used to listen it all the time back in high school. But I agree RTL is their best album. |
Kalopsia
03.20.19 | yawn |
XyphDryne
07.22.21 | 1 is 1 |
AngryLittleAlchemist
07.22.21 | #6 is #2, #2 is 4, #3 is #3 |
TheSpirit
07.22.21 | well, you got the first 3 right
oh this list is old wtf |