TheMightyScoop
03.04.19 | you're wrong |
calmrose
03.04.19 | the albums I have heard here are definitely as good as I think |
Uzumaki
03.04.19 | For the first time, Scoop, we agree on something. |
Uzumaki
03.04.19 | May this not be the last! |
Doibhin69
03.04.19 | 4 is trash rest are good |
Ryus
03.04.19 | 2, 5, and 10 are all classics |
madrigal30
03.04.19 | Nah. These are all exactly as good as I think |
Ambrosian
03.04.19 | Am I the only one who thinks that the quiet tracks on Spiderland are awful compared to the louder ones? |
CaliggyJack
03.04.19 | You had me till Sgt. Pepper's
You started losing me at Jane Doe
You completely lost me at Queen is Dead |
TheMightyScoop
03.04.19 | @uzumaki fuck you, now I hate these |
Source
03.04.19 | expected 2
wasn't disappointed |
onionbubs
03.04.19 | besides jane doe, yea this ain’t wrong about much else
but then you had to fuck it all up by putting jane doe here |
BigHans
03.04.19 | I agree with this list completely. |
Sinternet
03.04.19 | nice bait |
AnimalsAsSummit
03.04.19 | all true except for 2 |
ArsMoriendi
03.04.19 | 10 is like a 4/5
9 is like a 3/5
8 is like a 4/5
6 is like a 4.5/5 and Pixies in general are amazing.
4 is like a 4/5 and gets too much love AND hate from most people
Would check 2 but haven't, don't care about the rest |
nightbringer
03.04.19 | It is plausibly logically impossible for me to believe that these albums are worse than I believe them to be. So insofar as this list attempts to bring that belief about, it is doomed to frustration. |
Zorg
03.04.19 | I will attribute dissenting opinions to the Dunning–Kruger effect. |
ArsMoriendi
03.04.19 | When will people stop using the Dunning–Kruger Effect for things where it isn't relevant?
Clearly not today |
Zorg
03.04.19 | That was the joke. |
Ryus
03.04.19 | ars how do you not care about the greatest band ever |
Uzumaki
03.04.19 | @Scoop, why the hate, boy? |
ArsMoriendi
03.04.19 | "ars how do you not care about the greatest band ever"
Rush, Converge, or Neutral Milk Hotel, or The Smiths? Fine, I'll answer 'em all.
*Rush is like soulless robot prog, impressive from a technical standpoint, but not fun to hear
*I don't do metalcore, so no Converge for me
*NMH is annoying in a way that doesn't gel with me at all... also that dude REALLY wants to fuck Anne Frank
*The Smiths are fine, but all of their melodies sound too similar for me |
Ryus
03.04.19 | i meant the smiths
damn |
TheMightyScoop
03.04.19 | Uzumaki is the type of guy to volunteer to sit on someone's lap when the car is full |
Uzumaki
03.04.19 | Man, what crawled up your ass and died? Unless you’re trolling, then you’re doing a bang-up job, congrats. |
TheMightyScoop
03.04.19 | Uzumaki is so dumb he thinks cheerios are doughnut seeds |
Uzumaki
03.04.19 | Aaaaaaand we’re done here. Have fun wanking your ego off. |
veninblazer
03.04.19 | 7 is soooo wrong, that's a pretty solid 5 for me. |
veninblazer
03.04.19 | 9 is debatable though. |
TheMightyScoop
03.04.19 | "aaaaaaaand we're done here"
that's what women say when Uzumaki tries to present his cock |
Valzentia
03.04.19 | #8 is a lie |
Gestapo
03.04.19 | oh. |
Doibhin69
03.04.19 | this site likes to hate on mainstream/popular music cause it's the edgy thing to do |
smaugman
03.04.19 | list was ok until number 1 grrrr |
Kompys2000
03.04.19 | Putting 2 on here is a fuckin travesty |
Source
03.04.19 | mission accomplished Zorg |
Papa Universe
03.04.19 | 10, 6, 4, 3, 2, 1 are correct |
tcat84
03.04.19 | "this site likes to hate on mainstream/popular music cause it's the edgy thing to do"
100%, I love this site cause it's helped me find many of my favorite bands today but so many people with hot takes.
But at the same time if you look at the charts , the classics get very high ratings and they persevere. |
pizzamachine
03.04.19 | 10 and 3 are overrated |
JeetJeet
03.04.19 | I can agree that 7 is incredibly overrated. |
Hendoi
03.05.19 | this list is not correct |
StrikeOfTheBeast
03.05.19 | 9 is every bit as good as it's made out to be. Hard to find a better concept album letalone soundtrack to a crazy movie. |
Space Jester
03.05.19 | Every album is only as good as the listener thinks it is due the circumstances surrounding the hearing the album affecting their perception and opinion of it at the time. This is subject to change due to the passage of time altering the listener’s perspective or the listener partaking in subsequent listens that help to give them a better understanding of the album. |
TheMightyScoop
03.05.19 | "Every album is only as good as the listener thinks it is due the circumstances surrounding the hearing the album affecting their perception and opinion of it at the time. This is subject to change due to the passage of time altering the listener’s perspective or the listener partaking in subsequent listens that help to give them a better understanding of the album." |
BerryGarlicia
03.05.19 | I agree completely |
rabidfish
03.05.19 | yes |
Space Jester
03.05.19 | Like and subscribe |
Doibhin69
03.05.19 | "this list is not as good as you think" |
MAN0
03.05.19 | I assume it's sort of part of the culture to meme and draw blood like this? Since this is basically just a thread for people to say which of these they like, you can heck off with 10, 7, 5, and 3. Especially 7 and 3. |
Deathconscious
03.05.19 | i've been had! at least we have Zorg here to set us straight though, we can be thankful for that. |
PyramidNoise
03.05.19 | "this list is not as good as you think" [2] |
madrigal30
03.05.19 | 7 is great. 3, not so much |
elliootsmeuth
03.05.19 | Are we all just ignoring that this is the first list from this guy in 10 years?? |
rabidfish
03.05.19 | Good list for a return |
LARGEMINT
03.05.19 | welcome back to the site, let me tell you about a certain list format that has been done 7000 times in the past 10 years |
neekafat
03.05.19 | Agreed on almost all of these that I've heard actually |
Zorg
03.07.19 | I think I'm going to have to do a Talk Talk review. |