TheLongShot
11.28.17 | lol @ Ummagumma over Piper and Saucerful
"The Grand Vizier's Garden Party" tho
nvm you have Saucerful listed twice |
Higsas34
11.28.17 | Glad you pointed that out! |
sixdegrees
11.28.17 | syd is too low here imo |
Higsas34
11.28.17 | I might be crazy but I think Ummagumma has just enough memorable moments to BARELY edge out Saucer. |
Havey
11.28.17 | Opeth's music can most accurately be compared to snowflakes |
Higsas34
11.28.17 | Pretty much everything from 1-5 would be at least a near classic 5. |
TheLongShot
11.28.17 | “I might be crazy but I think Ummagumma has just enough memorable moments to BARELY edge out Saucer.”
I think it’s pretty memorable but also I don’t think memorable = good. Piper and Saucerful crush it musically IMO |
ElHombreChino
11.28.17 | Piper at the gates so low...
I dont' event consider Endless River as a Pink Floyd album... |
ivanhowe2017
12.25.17 | This is, by far, my Pink Floyd album rating:
1. The Piper At The Gates of Dawn: 4 stars
2. A Saucerful of Secrets: 4 stars
3. More (OST): 4 stars
4. Ummagumma: 4 stars
5. Atom Heart Mother: 4 stars
6. Meddle: 4.5 stars
7. Obscured by Clouds: 4.5 stars
8. The Dark Side of The Moon: 5 stars
9. Wish You Were Here: 5 stars
10. Animals: 5 stars
11. The Wall: 4.5 stars
12. The Final Cut: 3.5 stars
13. A Momentary Lapse of Reason: 4 stars
14. The Division Bell: 4.5 stars
15. Endless River: 4.5 stars |
ivanhowe2017
12.25.17 | TheLongShot: I absolutely agree with you. Piper At The Gates of Dawn and A Saucerful of Secrets have more memorable moments than Ummagumma, which, in turn is a Double Album consisting four live tracks from Pipes and Saucerful + some studio outtakes. In my humble opinion, it is a weird album to start a Pink Floyd collection, although it is good.
El Hombre Chino: Endless River was actually billed as a Pink Floyd project, which was built around some unfinished tracks left by Richard Wright from The Division Bell Recording Sessions. |
ivanhowe2017
12.25.17 | IMHO, The Final Cut should not be considered a Pink Floyd album, but a Roger Waters de facto project. However, it ironically was billed under the Pink Floyd monicker. |
BlackwaterPork
12.25.17 | The fuck is 10 doing so low |
Meridiu5
11.03.19 | Meddle master race |
Sinternet
11.03.19 | pipers destroys everything else they did
animals was ok too i guess |
