SandwichBubble
03.10.17 | Haven't heard them all, but Alice in Chains - Dirt for me. It isn't terrible though. |
Trebor.
03.10.17 | not Pinkerton first of all
Every Beatles record |
FullOfSounds
03.10.17 | It doesn't quite reach the best of all time chart but I really don't like Mars Volta - De-Loused in the Comatorium |
Trebor.
03.10.17 | Shape of Punk To Come is massively overrated
Devil and God isn't that great, Blackwater Park is lame |
talktothehead
03.10.17 | Elliott Smith - Either/Or
Pearl Jam - Ten
Pink Floyd - The Wall(not bad though)
Nine Inch Nails - The Fragile
Iron Maiden - The Number of the Beast
Interpol - Turn on the Bright Lights
The Smashing Pumpkins - Siamese Dream
Opeth - Blackwater Park |
Trebor.
03.10.17 | Rage Against The Machine's s/t is probably my least favorite thing on the chart |
Spec
03.10.17 | with every year i age, weezer gets worse |
ConcubinaryCode
03.10.17 | angel dust and operation mindcrime for me |
Avagantamos
03.10.17 | metallica |
onionbubs
03.10.17 | any pink floyd album |
guitarded_chuck
03.10.17 | "any pink floyd album"
"wish you were here
dark side of the moon
animals"
lol wtf |
onionbubs
03.10.17 | the moment i saw you commented in this thread i knew youd say something about that lol |
AmericanFlagAsh
03.10.17 | "Interpol - Turn on the Bright Lights"
Stop it ALA |
Frippertronics
03.10.17 | Interpol is total shit though |
dbizzles
03.10.17 | Shape of Punk To Come is massively overrated [2]
Thank you, Treb. I've been on that boat for years. Might be the most overrated album of all time, imo. |
talktothehead
03.10.17 | what fripp said yeahh |
talktothehead
03.10.17 | year I like those Pink Floyd albums : (
but it's okay! different opinions and all |
talktothehead
03.10.17 | yeah i agree
people care too much about like mindedness. i just love those albums especially animals |
Dylan620
03.10.17 | only one on the chart I have rated under a 3 is Loveless |
ArsMoriendi
03.10.17 | "wish you were here
dark side of the moon
animals
lift your skinny fists
the doors s/t
the devil and god
rain dogs
master of puppets
TPAB"
Out of all of these Rain Dogs makes me want to fight you the most |
FullOfSounds
03.10.17 | "only one on the chart I have rated under a 3 is Loveless"
embrace the fuzz my man |
AmericanFlagAsh
03.10.17 | "Interpol is total shit though"
Yeah well so are you. |
FullOfSounds
03.10.17 | Oh god year I feel bad, Tom's voice can definitely get grating |
Ryus
03.10.17 | queen - a night at the opera
metallica - master of puppets
metallica - ride the lightning
refused - the shape of punk to come
brand new - devil and god
tool - aenima
kyuss - welcome to sky valley
faith no more - angel dust
and others |
ArsMoriendi
03.10.17 | "by the way, i think we've had this conversation before on a list i made"
Yeah I remember that list... it's too bad he ruined Tom Waits for you |
ArsMoriendi
03.10.17 | From the albums I've heard:
Weezer - Pinkerton
My Blood Valentine - Loveless
Judas Priest - Sad Wings of Destiny
At the Drive-In - Relationship of Command |
AmericanFlagAsh
03.10.17 | "My Blood Valentine - Loveless"
You're done too |
ArsMoriendi
03.10.17 | Loveless is the worst of he 4 I listed too, it's a 2/5 whereas the other 3 are 2.5/5. |
FullOfSounds
03.10.17 | Downward Spiral's 4.4 average has baffled me |
FullOfSounds
03.10.17 | wow you guys need to get sad and listen to loveless every night |
Ryus
03.10.17 | yeah downward spiral i never liked
everyone who says loveless should be banished from the site |
wtferrothorn
03.10.17 | Endtroducing... and The White Album are both 3's for me, so I guess those |
talktothehead
03.10.17 | Can we stop hating each other for our differences and start loving each other for our similarities?
.........we all like Radiohead here...right? right? .....right? |
Ryus
03.10.17 | loveless is perhaps the album that most greatly affects me emotionally |
FullOfSounds
03.10.17 | hugs and kisses for all, except the loveless haters |
dctarga
03.10.17 | Ouch! Right in the nostalgia! |
ArsMoriendi
03.10.17 | @thiswastheyear: Haven't heard it |
FullOfSounds
03.10.17 | "we can all bond over leaves turn inside you, should be top 5 on all time chart tbh"
future sounds 5 prob |
ArsMoriendi
03.10.17 | "hugs and kisses for all, except the loveless haters"
: fair enough |
talktothehead
03.10.17 | it's not hard to be a sounds 5 tbqh |
FullOfSounds
03.10.17 | honestly ala i've been getting stricter and stricter with my ratings so a 5 is harder to come by |
Ryus
03.10.17 | leaves is good but not a 5
|
Papa Universe
03.10.17 | What have I started? |
Ryus
03.10.17 | on some listens i really connect with it, but other times its just kind of blah
i dont know why that is |
Trundle
03.10.17 | Kendrick |
SandwichBubble
03.10.17 | @UniqueUniverse a war |
Papa Universe
03.10.17 | oh my |
Rigma
03.10.17 | Purple Rain |
Ryus
03.10.17 | prince is god |
Frippertronics
03.10.17 | damn flagash in with the weak insults
hmu we can cry to limpwristed indie whenever you want |
Frippertronics
03.10.17 | Parade is the better album tho |
Azertherion
03.10.17 | Obviously any Brand New record. Or pretty much most of the post-hardcore this website jams to :D
On the other hand, I'm going to smash any Pink floyd hater that comes my way !
Fripp, how come that you don't like Interpol ? Paul Banks is so cute :( |
Relinquished
03.10.17 | list is correct |
Frippertronics
03.10.17 | Interpol strikes me as the worst of post punk revival with an overly sterile sound, a third rate ian curtis impressionist at the mic and boring songwriting in general |
TVC15
03.10.17 | Prince is God [3] |
Frippertronics
03.10.17 | tl;dr the post-punk revival bands who try to imitate joy division, new order, the cure, etc are terrible |
talktothehead
03.10.17 | agreed with fripp yeah
can't speak for the new order part i haven't gotten to them yet |
runaways
03.10.17 | Devil and God isn't that great is an incorrect statement, but Deja is better |
runaways
03.10.17 | also literally every Pink Floyd album
Beatles are a little overrated but Abbey Road and The White Album are worthy of their acclaim. Revolver, Sgt. Pepper, Rubber Soul...not so much. There are about 3-5 good songs on those albums |
Frippertronics
03.10.17 | New Order were really rucking great until the mid 90s
shame they fell from grace harder than interpol themselves did |
EliteTaste
03.10.17 | every one that isn't vomir |
CrazyDiamond7
03.10.17 | Only ones I can think of are:
Sex Pistols-Never Mind the Bullocks
Weezer- Blue Album (Don't dislike it, but it's sooooo overrated)
Probably turn on the bright lights too.
Also the amount of Loveless and Pink Floyd hate makes me sad.
"we all like Radiohead here...right? right? .....right?"
Let's not tempt fate...
|
Papa Universe
03.10.17 | By the way, does anybody remember whether it too equally as long for the "Best of 2016" chart to appear? Cause it's March and the 2017 one ain't there yet. |
Azertherion
03.10.17 | Honestly out of all the post punk revival Interpol are the ones I dislike the less; while I agree with you on bands like Editors and stuff, I've quite enjoyed Antics and Our Love to Admire.
Imo Joy division itself is a bit surestimated, still good but does certainly not deserves such high ratings. However hating on the Beatles is so lame, Revolver buries every pop album that has been made since then. |
Papa Universe
03.10.17 | I have a certain admiration for Post-Punk like Interpol in general. Indeed, they sound like every other post-Joy Division Post-Punk band ever, but I still find their music to be great. |
Azertherion
03.10.17 | I mean, in most cases the Post punk revival stands for indie pop rock with a d0rk aesthetic. Sometimes they manage to write good and enjoyable pop songs, but that's about it.
Still, prog rules. I don't think we say this enough on this website. (comment sponsorised) |
DoofusWainwright
03.10.17 | Beathoven blows |
Azertherion
03.10.17 | I almost said "fuck you doofus" reading this.
|
ArsMoriendi
03.10.17 | Interpol - Turn on the Bright Lights isn't even in the top 200, why do people keep mentioning it on this list? |
Azertherion
03.10.17 | Plus it's actually Beethoven. |
FullOfSounds
03.10.17 | Martyn Jacques is a false prophet |
Azertherion
03.10.17 | How can one dislike the Moonlight Sonata is beyond me. |
Frippertronics
03.10.17 | If more revival bands went in the style of the pop group, this heat, bauhaus, wipers that would be cool |
zaruyache
03.10.17 | Radiohead, Megadeth |
Frippertronics
03.10.17 | Schoenberg is low key the GOAT |
rabidfish
03.10.17 | TPaB for sure
Any AC/DC that's around there somewhere
Any Kanye that's around there somewhere
|
FullOfSounds
03.10.17 | beethoven couldn't write a banger if his symphony depended on it |
Azertherion
03.10.17 | Chopin's Nocturnes remains the ultimate jam. |
Papa Universe
03.10.17 | @Ars: They keep mentioning all sorts of things, so let's just let it fly. |
Azertherion
03.10.17 | "Schoenberg is low key the GOAT"
Too much atonal works. Interesting for sure, but it can't be the great thing ever. |
rabidfish
03.10.17 | 'If more revival bands went in the style of the pop group, this heat, bauhaus, wipers that would be cool'
No, there would only be shitty bands asociated with actually good bands. Besides, don't u dare take away that Joy Division T from the kool kidz. |
Papa Universe
03.10.17 | Preoccupations is a fantastic Post-Punk revival band...just sayin' |
Azertherion
03.10.17 | Will listen after finishing Ez3kiel's discography. |
tre
03.10.17 | Shape of Punk To Come is massively overrated [69] |
FullOfSounds
03.10.17 | I wanna hear a modern Wipers now |
CrazyDiamond7
03.10.17 | Protomartyr and Ought are great as well. The latter is sort of in line with the wierder, noisier breed of post-punk. |
wtferrothorn
03.10.17 | "Any AC/DC that's around there somewhere
Any Kanye that's around there somewhere"
neither of them are there, you're welcome for looking |
dbizzles
03.10.17 | TPAB shouldn't be even be on a best of 1,000,000 list. |
ianblxdsoe
03.10.17 | i fucking hate you all this thread makes me want to pour hydrofluoric acid in my eyes |
rabidfish
03.10.17 | 'neither of them are there, you're welcome for looking'
noice! |
Papa Universe
03.10.17 | "i fucking hate you all this thread makes me want to pour hydrofluoric acid in my eyes"
Yeah, I figured I accidentally started a shitstorm. oh well |
Minushuman24
03.10.17 | rust in peace tbh |
unclereich
03.10.17 | Neutral milk hotel |
Yotimi
03.11.17 | Streetlight manifesto |
riffariffic7
03.11.17 | DJ Shadow - Endtroducing...
Kate Bush - Hounds of Love
Radiohead - Kid A
Depeche Mode - Violator
The Notorious B.I.G. - Ready to Die
I don't outright hate any of these albums, I just don't think they're as "classic" as people claim. Most of these, I feel, just haven't aged well at all; especially Violator, what a dull slug of an album. |
SandwichBubble
03.11.17 | "2 people like this" is accurate, cause the rest are at each other's throats :b
|
FullOfSounds
03.11.17 | Aww Violator has some bangers |
Frippertronics
03.11.17 | The Dreaming is better than Hounds |
riffariffic7
03.11.17 | @FullOfSounds - I don't mind Depeche Mode. Frankly, one of my favourite songs of all-time is actually "Never Let Me Down Again". Violator has some good tracks, "Policy of Truth" is probably my favourite, but I find that the album starts to drag after a short period. |
riffariffic7
03.11.17 | Try not to take it too personally then. It's just an opinion, man. I bet you have a ton of albums that you hate that I love too, so who gives a shit? |
Snowdog808
03.11.17 | Shape of Punk To Come is massively overrated [70]. At least Kanye West isn't quite popular enough here to make the list, overwise he'd be one of my easiest answers ever. |
ShaquilleONeal
03.11.17 | The Mars Voltas "De-loused in the Comatorium" has got to be the most overrated for me. The Mars Volta is filled with extremely talented musicians, but it seems like none of those musicians were on the same page with the album. De-loused feels like it goes in so many different directions at the same time, and its hard to really comprehend what they were trying to accomplish. It truly feels like the album is on drugs. Francis The Mute is superior, because it has all the talent of De-louse, but they are all in the same page.
Glassjaw's "Worship and Tribute" is another overrated album for me. Half the album completely blows me away, and the other half feels like the songs go way to long and bores me. Because of this, I feel like that Worship and Tribute shouldn't be the poster boy of early 2000's Post Hardcore music.
John Lennon's solo music is not only overrated, but its completely abysmal in my opinion. Lennon was completely fucked up on drugs during his solo career, and it shows. All of his music writing is sloppy, and his ideas are not well thought out.
Lastly, I think the entire 60's is by far the most overrated decade in modern music. There is so many critically acclaimed artists that were completely fucked up on drugs, and it really shows in thier music. Jimi Hendrix is an example of this. He is a brilliant guitar player, but his music writing goes in so many different places, and its hard to really comprehend what he is trying to do. Don't get me wrong, the 60's did have great music, but the over-glorification of the decade is something that I will never understand. |
Sinternet
03.11.17 | answer is pretty clearly Pink Floyd with Queen a close runner-up |
tre
03.11.17 | "I feel like that Worship and Tribute shouldn't be the poster boy of early 2000's Post Hardcore music."
This album isn't on the best of all time chart, but I disagree. I think Relationship of Command is the overrated post-hardcore album of the early 2000s over W&T. I don't think W&T is perfect, but every song on that album holds its own and it never goes repetitive. |
UndineParty
03.11.17 | All of them, they all suck |
FullOfSounds
03.11.17 | Fucking spot-on with De-Loused Shaq |
Rigma
03.11.17 | Agree that Frances > De-Loused but disagree that they weren't on the same page |
MeatSalad
03.11.17 | number of the beast is the lowest rating i have on the all time list at 3.5 |
Papa Universe
03.11.17 | So is this thread dead yet or what? |
Papa Universe
03.11.17 | Yeah, I guess so. |
wwf
03.11.17 | Providence on F#A# is sort of a meandering piece of shit
Also Red by King Crimson sucks for quite a bit of the runtime |
Tunaboy45
03.11.17 | pinkerton wtf is wrong with you |
Demon of the Fall
03.11.17 | It took me a while to find an album that I thought was plain average/bad & it was Rage Against the Machine, which I believe has no business on a list like this. I think a few other higher entries are a little overrated but this stuck out big time. |
Demon of the Fall
03.11.17 | Neutral Milk Hotel is simultaneously boring & annoying too, which is quite the achievement... |
Demon of the Fall
03.11.17 | And I never "got" Loveless, not sure it's "bad" though |
Aberf
03.11.17 | I can never get the appraisal of Radiohead - Kid A. |
bgillesp
03.12.17 | Loveless 3/5 |
ZippaThaRippa
03.12.17 | Master of Puppets
Rust in Peace
No way |
Lord(e)Po)))ts
03.12.17 | Definitely megadeth and iron Maiden hands down |
Lord(e)Po)))ts
03.12.17 | Oh and Metallica of course |
evilford
03.12.17 | everyone dissing floyd is dead |
elliootsmeuth
03.12.17 | Can't really say which one is worst because I haven't heard them all and worst implies objectivity, but my least favorite is probably Blackwater Park. Never really got the appeal of Opeth. |
Lord(e)Po)))ts
03.12.17 | Obviously the worst of what you heard is what this is implying dude |
evilford
03.12.17 | always thought megadave was overrated. rust is about a 4.4 but should NOT be the highest rated metal album on this website |
0GuyMan0
03.12.17 | jesus fuck this thread triggers me so much.
Especially the Rage S/T and Operation Mindcrime detractors. HOW. |
evilford
03.12.17 | rage s/t has detractors? |
MeatSalad
03.12.17 | calm your tits homeboy, they're good and most importantly influential albums but both are extremely overrated as a result
also agreed hard ford, 4.6 is just absurd |
evilford
03.12.17 | dave mustaine worst voxist of all time agreed |
Lord(e)Po)))ts
03.12.17 | "answer is pretty clearly Pink Floyd with Queen a close runner-up"
dumb |
0GuyMan0
03.12.17 | I'll take Dave Mustaine over Vince Neil.
And I don't buy that Operation: Mindcrime is overrated. I don't buy that that album is anything but UNDERrated. Some dudes on Sput giving it a nice score doesn't change the fact that they are criminally ignored (though I'd be willing to admit that Silent Lucidity and 20 years of mediocrity may have lent a hand).
I might be on board with the Rage observation. Maybe. But they are in my pantheon and I fucking miss them so much and it hurts. |
Papa Universe
03.12.17 | So now it's dead, aye? |
Astral Abortis
03.12.17 | All of them basically |
Astral Abortis
03.12.17 | Legit answer tho, Neutral Milk Hotel |
Papa Universe
03.12.17 | Oh, not yet... |
Papa Universe
03.12.17 | Why NMH? |
Astral Abortis
03.12.17 | Because it's literally the worst album ever made |
Yotimi
03.12.17 | I'll accept anyone's answer except Loveless. Then you're a piece of shit |
Astral Abortis
03.12.17 | Loveless doesn't suck but it doesn't deserve a spot on the charts |
Ryus
03.12.17 | I'll accept anyone's answer except Loveless. Then you're a piece of shit [2] |
ZippaThaRippa
03.12.17 | I used to like that album but now even thinking about it hurts me. So much semen. |
p4p
03.12.17 | A New Hope and Symphony No. 9 |
AlexKzillion
03.12.17 | Marquee Moon, Pinkerton, Exile on Main st. |
Shadowmire
03.12.17 | Elliott Smith - Either/Or
Brand New - The Devil and God Are Raging Inside Me
Kendrick Lamar - To Pimp a Butterfly
NOFX - The Decline
only brand new isn't good at all though |
Azertherion
03.12.17 | I don't where does this Brand New praise comes from, the band is so mundane. |
Ryus
03.12.17 | well
yeah |
TheWrenKing
03.12.17 | dream theater or tool probs |
Azertherion
03.12.17 | Tool haters |