Rowan5215
04.02.16 | Sgt Peppers Lonely Hearts Club Band |
Shuyin
04.02.16 | Swans - The Seer |
Mystletainn
04.02.16 | opeth - black waterpark |
Jasdevi087
04.02.16 | Pearl Jam - Ten |
IronGiant
04.02.16 | any album by The National but if you need one specific album then I'll go ahead and say Marquee Moon. Run of the mill guitar album feat. Bryne-esque vocals isnt enough to warrant it a classic. Great album nonetheless |
PattBraderson
04.02.16 | Nine Inch Nails - The Downward Spiral |
Brabiz
04.02.16 | Yes to literally all of these. But 7 hard |
AlexKzillion
04.02.16 | Radiohead - Kid A |
ZippaThaRippa
04.02.16 | Circle Takes the Square - As Roots Undo |
BigHans
04.02.16 | Any vote for 5 should be met by a firing squad. |
dmp3131
04.02.16 | Honestly always thought Nirvana's Nevermind was overrated. I appreciate it for what it is, but I can't get into it whatsoever. |
UnderTheNorthernScar
04.02.16 | Kanye West - MBDTF
Joy Division - Unknown Pleasures |
YetAnotherBrick
04.02.16 | Slayer - Reign in Blood |
UnderTheNorthernScar
04.02.16 | 4 is the only album I can describe as truly villainous, menacing sound. So for that reason alone BWP has a special place in my heart (even though Still Life wins any day of the week) |
YetAnotherBrick
04.02.16 | " The National is one of the most consistently boring bands"
ha |
Frippertronics
04.02.16 | The Smiths - The Queen is Dead |
UnderTheNorthernScar
04.02.16 | @LPFTW Ill be sure to check that out. I never could get past the track after Disorder, which is the only track I love by them. Everything after that is just so... morose |
Friday13th
04.02.16 | Elliott Smith - Either/Or |
UnderTheNorthernScar
04.02.16 | " The National is one of the most consistently boring bands"
Wrong |
Artuma
04.02.16 | white pony |
Friday13th
04.02.16 | gotta dig There Is a Light That Never Goes Out |
Artuma
04.02.16 | was gonna nominate 7 but someone already did so gj
also the one who nominated 9 needs to get lynched hard |
ArsMoriendi
04.02.16 | Pinkerton needs to be in this |
Frippertronics
04.02.16 | I find TQID to be a nice album, but it's nowhere near as good as some people give it credit for.
no it doesn't Ars |
UnderTheNorthernScar
04.02.16 | Hell yeah, I love moments like that, super organic yet powerful. I'll for sure give that a spin tommorow. Joy division is one of those bands I've always wanted to like, and I think you may have just given me a reason to |
ArsMoriendi
04.02.16 | Yes it's a nomination for sure I hope it wins too |
worthlessscab
04.02.16 | Agalloch - The Mantle
Agalloch - Ashes Against the Grain |
ScuroFantasma
04.02.16 | TPAB |
JigglyPDiddy
04.02.16 | 1 and 4 |
Ashen
04.02.16 | we have somehow made it this far without nmh |
porcupinetheater
04.02.16 | Queen - A Night at the Opera |
Ashen
04.02.16 | put aeroplane on the list |
InFlamesWeThrash666
04.02.16 | Brand New - The Devil And God are Raging Inside Me
Nirvana - Nevermind
|
InFlamesWeThrash666
04.02.16 | there u go |
sonictheplumber
04.02.16 | I can't believe some of you think some of the queef ass shit on this list beats the album that has a day in the life, fixing a hole, mr kite, good morning good morning. Suck my fuckin dick you little kids. And I won't cum. I just want you to suck it for hours and hours until you're in pain |
sonictheplumber
04.02.16 | Jk :D but really sgt pepper is great
And tbh all the albums on this list have had an influence on someone and are well liked by a lot of people. The "everything I don't like is overrated" phase I grew out of |
hesperus
04.02.16 | Mr. Bungle - California |
sonictheplumber
04.02.16 | That being said 9 is my pick for biggest fart |
CaimanJesus
04.02.16 | Green day - Dookie |
hesperus
04.02.16 | Sorry, I had to. I really don't get the appeal. |
altertide0
04.02.16 | The dark side of the moon |
Avagantamos
04.02.16 | morbid angel - altars of madness |
Ovrot
04.02.16 | Metallica - Master of Puppets
not even best two metallica |
porcupinetheater
04.02.16 | Only hope for Ovrot now is to pretend he isn't human and instead be The Riff |
Mystletainn
04.02.16 | "morbid angel - altars of madness"
failure |
Ovrot
04.02.16 | i mean it's good but RtL and Kill em' all is better |
Brabiz
04.02.16 | I disagree with everything after 11 to 19 |
Mephistopheles
04.02.16 | Deathspell Omega - Paracletus |
ryu
04.02.16 | NIN - The downward spiral has my vote too.
Joy Division would be a close 2nd |
Cimnele
04.02.16 | was going to suggest The Mantle but it's there already lol |
worthlessscab
04.02.16 | suggest their other album. they are all garbage anyway |
Keyblade
04.02.16 | funny how this is like the same albums as the greatest lp ever made tournament |
XingKing
04.02.16 | There are too many good choices. I don't know how to pick which one is more overrated! |
DoofusWainwright
04.02.16 | Swans Swans Swans - doggy face cover |
onionbubs
04.02.16 | Dookie has an average of 4 or above? Hmmm
The who - tommy |
onionbubs
04.02.16 | Actually no. Ok computer. And this is coming from a fan of radiohead |
smaugman
04.02.16 | 4 doesnt belong here haha. 24 is prob the most overrated |
CalculatingInfinity
04.02.16 | Anyone who votes for this should be banned from Sput forever [2]
As for me I pick Joanna Newsom - Ys |
altertide0
04.02.16 | Good pick |
Snowdog808
04.02.16 | I certainly hope 11 goes far in this tournament. |
onionbubs
04.02.16 | yea 24s the most overrated.
21's gonna go really far.
god i hope 7 doesn't last. but i know its going to. |
Zig
04.02.16 | 3 and 20 are overrated as shit.
But I feel AC/DC - Back in Black should be here. |
BandNewbac
04.02.16 | boring bathtimes - an otherwise clouded mind |
Aftertheascension
04.02.16 | Radiohead - OK Computer |
Pangea
04.02.16 | Agreed with 2. There are atleast 5 beatle albums better than it |
MyNameIsPencil
04.02.16 | edit cause I realize it had been a long time since I heard my original pick and that wouldn't have been fair:
Cryptopsy - None So Vile |
Greem
04.02.16 | Rage Against the Machine - Rage Against the Machine |
adr
04.02.16 | London Calling
Hunky Dory
Lust for Life
all decent, but yeah overrated |
AnimalsAsSummit
04.02.16 | 18 and 24 |
JamieTwort
04.02.16 | Fear of a Blank Planet
Painkiller
Pick one I guess |
adr
04.02.16 | Painkiller is best Priest fuk ya'all |
DoofusWainwright
04.02.16 | Screamadelica |
Ryus
04.02.16 | a lot of these suck dick. 19 is prob the worst though |
frigyourgenre
04.02.16 | Mbdtf |
TumsFestival
04.02.16 | 10 as fuck |
JamieTwort
04.02.16 | "Painkiller is best Priest fuk ya'all"
It's closer to worst Priest. |
MarsKid
04.02.16 | Godspeed You! Black Emperor - Lift Your Skinny Fists Like Antennas to Heaven
Damn it feels good to be a gangsta |
AlexKzillion
04.02.16 | Surprised at the amount of albums that I find overrated that are on here. |
DoofusWainwright
04.02.16 | 1st 3
2nd 21
3rd 22
4th 11
5th 1
Would prob be my top 5 |
emester
04.02.16 | 4 wins
Album is synonymous with bandwagoning |
wtferrothorn
04.02.16 | have a feeling that this tournament isn't gonna end well, but I might as well put my own in
The Beatles - The Beatles |
smaugman
04.02.16 | emester, you're drunk, go home |
Friday13th
04.02.16 | 34 and 39 are way under the # ratings requirement. |
SmileNerd
04.02.16 | 21
22
44
|
Friday13th
04.02.16 | #2: Pixies - Doolittle
#3: Explosions in the Sky - The Earth is Not a Cold Dead Place |
ChoccyPhilly
04.02.16 | American futbol |
ChoccyPhilly
04.02.16 | Yeah, soz I forgot they had an EP too |
NeroCorleone80
04.02.16 | Gonna throw Jane Doe in there |
Cimnele
04.02.16 | Sunbather |
ChoccyPhilly
04.02.16 | Sweet, in that case:
Royal Blood S/t
Black Sabbath - Paranoid |
NeroCorleone80
04.02.16 | Appetite for Destruction
Rust in Peace |
ChoccyPhilly
04.02.16 | Nvm I'll just stick with two in that case |
wtferrothorn
04.02.16 | edit: nvm just put me down for The Beatles - The Beatles |
DoofusWainwright
04.02.16 | Aladdin Sane and Michigan? Solid slightly under the radar albums within their respective artist's discogs? :/ |
wtferrothorn
04.02.16 | okay yeah, I guess they wouldn't be overrated, lemme change that. |
MarsKid
04.02.16 | I vote 17, 23, 34. |
NeroCorleone80
04.02.16 | Rust in Peace |
BigBlob
04.02.16 | Jane Doe |
MarsKid
04.02.16 | Aight |
altertide0
04.02.16 | R.E.M. - Murmur
Nick Drake - Pink Moon |
Avagantamos
04.02.16 | the national - high violet |
BigBlob
04.02.16 | 20 then |
DoofusWainwright
04.02.16 | LPFTW - yeah I should have read the rules
Avag - The National overrated? Of all the bands.... smh |
eaglefan1998
04.02.16 | weezer - blue album |
DoofusWainwright
04.02.16 | Oasis - what's the story |
DoofusWainwright
04.02.16 | M83 - hurry up we're dreaming
Put it up and it's probably my numero uno |
brandontaylor
04.02.16 | modest mouse the lonesome crowded west |
brandontaylor
04.02.16 | death grips - jenny death |
truekebabpower
04.02.16 | 42 for sure |
Greem
04.02.16 | The White Stripes - White Blood Cells |
Avagantamos
04.02.16 | joyce manor - s/t |
DoofusWainwright
04.02.16 | Ooh 44 is a great pick |
Greem
04.02.16 | LPTFW agree with your picks |
Ovrot
04.02.16 | remove rust in peace
|
Avagantamos
04.02.16 | white pony is here |
torts
04.02.16 | lmao fuck this site |
porcupinetheater
04.02.16 | Animals as Leaders - Animals as Leaders |
Ovrot
04.02.16 | remove rust
this is geneva convention tier war crimes |
Ovrot
04.02.16 | just put white pony two more times |
ArsMoriendi
04.02.16 | Can I pick a second one? Loveless! |
Ryus
04.02.16 | you sadden me ars :[ |
Friday13th
04.02.16 | Well maybe Smashing Pumpkins are...overrated *hint hint*. Ars I know you won't pick Siamese Dream but pick something good. |
ArsMoriendi
04.02.16 | I'm not nominating Siamese Dream lmao
I'll nominate Frances the Mute |
Ryus
04.02.16 | good pick. the mars volta is fucking terrible |
DoofusWainwright
04.02.16 | Yeah Mars Volta are fucking hideous - wonderful choice that man |
ArsMoriendi
04.02.16 | I won't lie, I like the radio cut of The Widow... everything else on there though like omg |
Friday13th
04.02.16 | yeah not bad, not bad |
UnderTheNorthernScar
04.02.16 | Oh so its cool to hate TMV now? what the fuck has this site devolved into.. |
Ryus
04.02.16 | when did anyone say it was cool
it just so happens we have the same opinion
|
Friday13th
04.02.16 | I like Deloused but they went downhill |
Friday13th
04.02.16 | Still not the most overrated on here. The ones I strongly disagree with are 2, 6, 12, and 26, 40 and 48. |
UnderTheNorthernScar
04.02.16 | Most of these albums are awesome, but I agree that the opening 5 minutes to Frances the Mute is some of the most annoying shit |
brainmelter
04.02.16 | 9 is overated x1000 |