NeroCorleone80
06.05.15 | Easy 3.5 at least |
JamieTwort
06.05.15 | This would be a great album for sure. |
JamieTwort
06.05.15 | I would honestly prefer this to any Dio-era album. |
TheMagicalBlender
06.05.15 | Someone should do this idea with Metallica's Load/ReLoad and make it one album. Take out half of the songs off each album and take the other halves and make it one. But I like your picks for your list, though. 1, 5, and 8 are good. |
NeroCorleone80
06.05.15 | This would be better than Dehumanizer for sure, but still dont think it would beat H&H or Mob Rules |
NeroCorleone80
06.05.15 | Might actually make a playlist of this and jam it front to back. See how it holds up. |
TheSonomaDude
06.05.15 | I wanna do a Load/Reload one. BRB
|
TheSonomaDude
06.05.15 | This would still be a 3/5 tbh |
NeroCorleone80
06.05.15 | Better than a Load/Reload one. Hell even TE and NSD individually are better than those. |
TheMagicalBlender
06.05.15 | No doubt about it, but if Metallica had cut all of the filler out of Load/ReLoad, put seven tracks on one disc and seven on the other, and release it as a double album instead of two individual albums, then St. Anger may be Metallica's only bad album. |
NeroCorleone80
06.05.15 | All Moving Parts is so underrated. Some great riffing. |
DikkoZinner
06.05.15 | This would definitely rule |
wham49
06.06.15 | really guys, combining 2 bad albums still makes one bad album. I am as big of Sabbath fan as there is, but possibly only 2.5, a full point behind any other Ozzy era release |
deathschool
06.06.15 | Iiiinteresting |
ArsMoriendi
06.06.15 | "really guys, combining 2 bad albums still makes one bad album."
Yeah, but I'd argue that 3/8 of the songs on Technical Ecstasy are wonderful and all 3 are on this list (and he also included Gypsy although it sucks... I'd swap it for Rock 'n' Roll Doctor, which although it has bad lyrics, is at least musically cool.)
All Moving Parts is so underrated. Some great riffing. [2] Deff my favorite on TE. |
JamieTwort
06.06.15 | "really guys, combining 2 bad albums still makes one bad album."
Taking the best moments from 2 bad albums will obviously make a better album and in many cases make 2 bad or average albums into 1 good album.
Neither of these are bad albums though, especially not for Sabbath who went on to release much worse albums. |
manosg
06.06.15 | With the exception of Forbidden and Born Again, I can't say they released much worse albums than TE and NSD.
But yeah combining these two albums definitely makes a better one even though it would still be somewhere at the bottom of my top 10 Sabbath. |
NeroCorleone80
06.06.15 | This would be solidly 9th for me. |
manosg
06.06.15 | I assume our only difference at the bottom is 13. I'd have it over Never Say Ecstasy. |
NeroCorleone80
06.06.15 | Yeah I'd prefer this. I'm actually jamming it now and because of how similar both albums are the flow is pretty good. |
Titan
06.06.15 | 4.0 for me |
NeroCorleone80
06.06.15 | Wouldn't be far off |
NeroCorleone80
06.06.15 | Air Dance flows perfectly into Dirty Women |
JamieTwort
06.06.15 | "With the exception of Forbidden and Born Again, I can't say they released much worse albums than TE and NSD."
They released about 7 other albums that I'd personally rank below them.
|
MrSirLordGentleman
06.06.15 | 4.0 for me [2] |
NeroCorleone80
06.06.15 | so yeah this rules |
wham49
06.07.15 | they did release worse albums, but not with the originals. Mid 80's through, with Iommi as the only original. Compared to other bands, they are still decent releases; however for the original 4, pretty poor. |
NeroCorleone80
07.02.15 | They should release this |
NeroCorleone80
07.22.15 | Junior's Eyes is up there with the best Sabbath solos |