Emeritus
Reviews 107 Approval 96%
Soundoffs 127 News Articles 30 Band Edits + Tags 62 Album Edits 78
Album Ratings 3493 Objectivity 66%
Last Active 01-12-23 5:14 pm Joined 08-27-12
Review Comments 20,969
| Opeth Ranked
All Opeth is good Opeth : ) | 13 | | Opeth Sorceress
Naturalistic vibes and explorative songwriting galore, Sorceress emphasizes adventure above all else. It manifests a warm, yet occult atmosphere, particularly within the gorgeous "Sorceress 2" and colorful "The Wilde Flowers." A rollicking progressive metal jam could fully transform into beautiful musical passages of acoustic guitar pluckings and ethereal mellotrons. There are unfortunately some bland lyrics similar to the weaker moments of Pale Communion, but vocals are improved overall. My review: https://www.sputnikmusic.com/review/71772/Opeth-Sorceress/ | 12 | | Opeth Pale Communion
Heavier than predecessor Heritage, it takes that sound to a new and exciting places. For example, as emeritus staff writer AngelOfDeath put it, "River" starts out like an Allman Bros. song and then goes like full on psych jam at the end." Despite being solid musically, Pale Communion is also cheesier and has some oversinging by Mikael Akerfeldt. However, the composition choices are still interesting, despite lessening the jazzier qualities of Heritage. The bookend tracks, Moon Above, Sun Below, and Voice of Treason are the highlights here. My review: https://www.sputnikmusic.com/review/63867/Opeth-Pale-Communion/ | 11 | | Opeth In Cauda Venenum
In Cauda Venenum boasts better production and is packed with more ideas and genre-bending goodness than the previous two records, but some uninspired moments and weird vocal quirks from Akerfeldt hold it back from true greatness. Still, it has some of their best tracks of their 2010s albums and the songwriting sounds more streamlined and satisfying overall. My review: https://www.sputnikmusic.com/review/80257/Opeth-In-Cauda-Venenum/ | 10 | | Opeth Deliverance
After the masterpiece Blackwater Park, Opeth seemed to sacrifice some of the complexity in favor of a more straightforward approach. While every album they did before and a few after are superior, this is still an excellent album that deserves a better reputation. While far from their best, there's no bad songs here, and the whole middle section of the record is incredible. Master's Apprentices and the title track contain some of the beautiful acoustic material that would be fully expanded on within Damnation, the other side of this coin. My review: https://www.sputnikmusic.com/review/64034/Opeth-Deliverance/ | 9 | | Opeth Orchid
The songwriting is all over the place and the production is raw, all part of this masterful debut's charm. Quieter, meditative sections are the most sinister the band have ever recorded, with gothic, fantasy lyrics resembling bands like Swallow The Sun. Orchid may be primitive compared to the refined sounds of Ghost Reveries, but possesses a very unique sound that the band would go on to perfect during the turn of the century. | 8 | | Opeth Morningrise
The bookend tracks are the best on here, as the middle run of songs tends to drags at times. Black Rose Immortal falls into this trap, but overall remains one of their best songs from this decade. Morningrise corrects songwriting mistakes from Orchid, while lessening the unpredictability factor it had. Both are around the same level of quality overall. | 7 | | Opeth Heritage
This takes a lot of time to grow on you, but once you give it a chance it's a highly rewarding listen. Some of the vintage elements fall flat, but this is not the 70s prog tribute album that some would have you believe it is. The songwriting itself is largely original, with incredible drumming and adventurous songwriting throughout. Haxprocess has a beautiful ending guitar solo, and Folklore is endlessly intriguing. The album as a whole is very warm sounding, perfect for summer and autumn months. | 6 | | Opeth Watershed
Watershed is better than most would tell you, despite the bizarre songwriting choices and jarring transitions. The highlight here is Heir Apparent, featuring stunning, diverse instrumentation and an incredible outro. Though most of the album's strongest qualities lie in the softer, creepier approaches it has; Hessian Peal embodies this beautifully. Burden and Coil are gorgeous tracks as well. My review: https://www.sputnikmusic.com/review/63120/Opeth-Watershed/ | 5 | | Opeth Damnation
This sees Opeth release a nonmetal album for the first time in their career, featuring some of their best songs in the form of Windowpane, Death Whispered a Lullaby, and Closure. | 4 | | Opeth Ghost Reveries
The best introduction to the band. This balances their metal sound with softer progressive rock amazingly. Moments like the first half of Hours of Wealth, all of Isolation Years, and the middle section of Harlequin Forest are all examples of Opeth at their most beautiful and poignant. While Watershed is technically even more diverse, Ghost Reveries is the band exploring uncharted terrain and doing what they do best. No other Opeth release exudes such a wonderfully gothic atmosphere quite the way Ghost Reveries does, and the band has yet to top this since it came out. | 3 | | Opeth My Arms, Your Hearse
An amazing evolution from Morningrise, and one of their only albums that doesn't drag anywhere. There are almost no weak moments, and refines the songwriting from the first two records perfectly. I also love the guitar effects they use in here, they're sparse but add a lot to the sound. | 2 | | Opeth Still Life
Still Life increases the presence of progressive rock and has even more impressive instrumentation. Certain elements of this would go on to be perfected in Blackwater Park, especially the production and increased emotion. A good amount of their best songs are here, including White Cluster, Face of Melinda, and Moonlapse Vertigo. | 1 | | Opeth Blackwater Park
Defying genre barriers, Blackwater Park is nothing short of incredible from start to finish. Easily their most emotional album, besides maybe Damnation, with tracks like Dirge for November and Bleak possessing profoundly tragic qualities throughout. Steven Wilson's contributions had a large part to play, and the production and added vocals bring a new side to the band. There are hundreds of reasons that most Opeth fans consider this their best album, but mine are mainly personal. This was my introduction to Opeth after hearing about them during my musical explorations as a preteen. When first hearing Blackwater Park at my young age, I was blown away by the stunning beauty and crushing brutality it harnessed throughout. Blackwater Park introduced me to a whole new approach in listening to music, as well as thinking and writing about it. It isn't hard to see why this is among the very best progressive metal has to offer and one of my personal favorite records of all time. | |
facupm
04.03.14 | 1 is 1 | Onirium
04.03.14 | Oh god I'm tired of these lists...
But 3 is 1 | mandan
04.03.14 | I dig the descriptions, but disagree with 1 being 1 and with your description of it. This is better than that dumb ranking I saw the other day in that at least it feels justified.
Having said that, 4, 6 & 7 should be higher. | BMDrummer
04.03.14 | Pretty good list, band rules. | Epilogue
04.03.14 | 2 is 1
always | MO
04.04.14 | "There was a list with this exact title yesterday. Just saying."
who cares its peth | Epilogue
04.04.14 | burden is also best ballad | forkliftjones
04.04.14 | yep 10 is 10 | savaah
04.04.14 | Very accurate. I would put Damnation a little bit higher though, that album destroys. | Vakarian12
04.04.14 | mayh> | Ending
04.04.14 | 3
5
1
4
2
Rest are all the same as me. | mandan
04.04.14 | Come to think of it, describing 5 as "One of the best progressive rock albums ever made" feels a bit exaggerated, although I haven't listened enough to that one, but dang. | BlacKapes
04.04.14 | swap 8 and 9 and 4 and 5 and you got it | TalonsOfFire
04.04.14 | Done. I had been debating myself about those ever since making this and honestly it is the right choice | Funeralopolis
04.04.14 | 3
5
1
4
rest sucks | mandan
04.04.14 | Well dude, you seem pretty convinced (I saw what you did on 5, interesting change).
More users will show up soon enough. | JokineAugustus
04.04.14 | switch 1 and 3 and that's pretty good | mandan
04.04.14 | Yeah, mid-era Opeth fans seem to overwhelm early-era Opeth fans on this site. | MikeC26
04.04.14 | I'd put 5 higher but hey who gives a fuck right? | TalonsOfFire
06.05.14 | Hmm if I ranked this now 5, 6, and 9 would be higher | facupm
06.06.14 | 1 shall always be 1 | TalonsOfFire
06.06.14 | So true, and that's all that matters | Vakarian12
08.17.14 | mayh not at 1. LOL | facupm
08.17.14 | im tired of opeth lists
still 1 is 1 | sputnik1
08.17.14 | BWP so overrated. Still Life will always be their best. Then MAYH. | Totengott
08.17.14 | 6 is too high and 10 and 9 are too low. | TalonsOfFire
08.17.14 | THERE I FIXED IT | KingdomOfTyrant
08.17.14 | Now, it's very similar to my list except for Morningrise, good ranking. | TalonsOfFire
05.27.15 | I updated my descriptions, added Pale Communion, and switched a few albums around. Do most of you consider Pale Communion better than Heritage? That's the consensus I've seen at least. | beefshoes
05.27.15 | No, Heritage is much better. | Psynuts
05.27.15 | list is pretty correct, but 9 needs to be 3 | TalonsOfFire
05.27.15 | I'm definitely seeing more love for Deliverance recently, which is nice, but 3 is a bit too high haha. Agreed beef, over time that's definitely how I eventually felt. | Psynuts
05.27.15 | yh it probably is, but I just love that album and feel that it doesnt really get enough love | TalonsOfFire
05.27.15 | Black Rose Immortal has some incredible moments and oozes epicness, but gets a little disjointed around the middle. Watershed is very close to their debut albums for me, very underrated for them. | Royl123
05.27.15 | Nice descriptions... | TalonsOfFire
05.27.15 | thanks... | chinesewhispers
05.27.15 | 4 is 1 yuh | TalonsOfFire
07.20.16 | I'm predicting that Sorceress will be their best since Ghost Reveries, sure hope it's true. | TheHamburgerman
07.20.16 | Hey now, switch 2 with 5, and 3 with 4 and we're in full agreement | TalonsOfFire
07.21.16 | 3 and 4 are close, almost interchangeable like 6 and 7. | Artuma
07.21.16 | "I'm predicting that Sorceress will be their best since Ghost Reveries"
lol | BigPleb
07.21.16 | Thought you'd heard the new one for a minute then | BigPleb
07.21.16 | Heritage was so good. | Hawks
07.21.16 | No way Sorceress is gonna be better than Watershed so it can't be their best since Ghost Reveries.
You never know I guess, but I'll be very pleasantly surprised if that actually happens. | BigPleb
07.21.16 | Album cover is best since GR. | TalonsOfFire
07.21.16 | Agreed Pleb, the cover is awesome
My description is just what I predict will be on the album from the previews they released. I know it probably won't be better than Watershed, and maybe even Heritage, but hey I'm an optimist. | DominionMM1
07.21.16 | top 4 are top 4 | TalonsOfFire
07.21.16 | True that. My opinion on the ones after can sometimes change tho depending on the mood. | AtomicWaste
07.21.16 | Has Sorceress really already leaked? | Ocean of Noise
07.21.16 | No, he's just predicting what his opinion is going to be on it | TalonsOfFire
06.17.23 | Didn't have ICV on here! I fixed that and updated some descriptions, but overall want to keep this as it was when I first wrote it. |
|