L4titudes
01.23.14 | asjd;ogijasf |
Ending
01.23.14 | 1 by a country mile. |
DrMaximus
01.23.14 | Bergtatt. No question. |
MeatSalad
01.23.14 | The mantle is boring so 2 |
Gwyn.
01.23.14 | sweet another one
Never heard much of Mantle so going with Bergtatt |
Lotus
01.23.14 | bergtatt is the best black metal album of all time so... |
grish
01.23.14 | this isn't even an interesting comparison, bergtatt easily |
adace1
01.23.14 | Mantle |
Motiv3
01.23.14 | The Mantle |
Crysis
01.23.14 | These two albums have almost nothing in common |
L4titudes
01.23.14 | i'll make sure the next one is more "interesting" |
Atari
01.23.14 | "These two albums have almost nothing in common"
^this is true. Also, right now I dig the White as much as the mantle |
L4titudes
01.23.14 | they're two good albums from the same genre..... |
ZombicidalMan
01.23.14 | I don't think The Mantle is necessarily better, but I like it a lot more... |
Lotus
01.23.14 | listen to crysis |
Crysis
01.23.14 | Bergtatt is the album that basically created folk black metal and The Mantle is a record that meshes
about 10230946783048763 genres together, one of which happens to be folk black metal. It may take some
influence from Bergtatt, but that influence is minute at best and is clashing with so many other
influences at the same time that what little Bergtatt there is on that record is barely worth mention.
It's just stupid to try to compare the two. |
Judio!
01.23.14 | Wow, what an original idea for a list! I still like The Mantle slightly better but both albums are eniterly different, really not a fair comparison. Both 5's of course. |
L4titudes
01.23.14 | damn... well next was going to be Opeth vs. Limp Bizkit so maybe i'll try something different |
Crysis
01.23.14 | I think both albums are incredible btw |
Gwyn.
01.23.14 | please do |
Atari
01.23.14 | THE WHITE |
tommygun
01.23.14 | bergtatt |
ButteryBiscuitBass
01.23.14 | niqqa kno |
Athom
01.23.14 | Ulver. |
L4titudes
01.23.14 | alright ulver takes the cake |
Gwyn.
01.23.14 | sweet now delete this list and don't ever make another one |
ExcentrifugalForz
01.23.14 | reported |
L4titudes
01.23.14 | what a meanie |
ThyCrossAwaits
01.24.14 | As I said the last eight times this list was made...Bergtatt. |
Keyblade
01.24.14 | Comparing Bergtatt to Pale Folklore would've been more apt. Regardless, nothing can touch Bergtatt so |
DrMaximus
01.24.14 | ^ |
Hawks
01.24.14 | Both are 5's for me, but Bergtatt is better. |
Cygnatti
01.24.14 | bergtatt |
climactic
01.24.14 | BER
GTA
TT |
TMobotron
01.24.14 | Bergtatt wins for me but I love both. Idk they're obviously really different but I think you can make a point for comparing the two even if it's more because it creates a discussion about the two different folky approaches. |
Hastigr
01.24.14 | I FEEL QUALIFIED TO ENTER THIS DISCUSSION |
Hastigr
01.24.14 | (The Mantle is awesome, though.) |
DrHouseSchuldiner
01.24.14 | Bergtatt |
Avagantamos
01.24.14 | mantle |
zaruyache
01.25.14 | I never really got into Ulver. Mantle for me. |
someguest
01.25.14 | People are really choosing The Mantle over Bergtatt?
Hmm. |
DominionMM1
01.25.14 | worst list ever |
InAbsentia
01.25.14 | Both are incredible. Bergtatt beats The Mantle by an inch. |