|List fails for not having any Unearth. And with all honesty, Avenged Sevenfold-Waking the Fallen should be here.|
3 is the only one I actually own here, and it's good, but not great. I want 3. 5 isn't that bad from what i've heard from it, probably better than ATR.
Just my opinion.
|2 im not a fan of, 3 sucks 4 sucks and 5 sucks.|
|2 is great and 4 is good|
|Don't like 4 but 5 is alright although TEOH is much better. 1 and 3 are good. Needs more Burn In Silence.|
Also, are people really starting to get annoyed at Converge being labeled metalcore? I rather like that label for it.
how is that not metalcore?
Anyway list needs more Poison the Well, Botch and 7 Angels 7 Plagues
|oh 3 4 5 suck (i know 5 is a joke but whatever)|
|2 and 3 are good, 4 and 5 are alright. I want 1.|
|i love 2. 3 and 4 are solid too. i hate hate hate hate hate 5|
|needs more III: In the Eyes of Fire|
|LIST NAME FAILS|
|The first 4 range from good to sick, and the 5th I'm not very fond of.|
Good live show though.
|Needs more Waking the Fallen by Avenged Sevenfold.|
Unearth is really overrated, not as good as ATR.
|I only have 2 and 3 but I agree they aren't too bad at all.|
|list title is an oxymoron|
|2 and 5 rule |
|What the fuck is Underoath doing on that list?|
|Besides your first 2 selections, the rest of this list completely contridicts what your claimed intentions were. "As you guessed, this is metalcore that isn't generic/boring/dumb as shit." |
|I feel downright offended by the lack of "The Carrier" here...|
|Johnny Truant is a pretty good shout.|
|3 and 5 are decent, 2 is very good but overrated, never heard 1 or 4|
|1 is great but I like their last release better.|
but lack of Oh, Sleeper means fail.
|lol this list is is from march of last year goddamn guys|